News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:53PM (#27269568)
It still basically does not differentiate between Epic Games and me. And I can’t handle the fines. The chilling effect this will have on people is being downplayed pretty harshly by people who are basically suggesting you should just pray that you don’t get put into massive debt because you made a mistake on a side project.

For that reason, GDPR will always draw some ire from me.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by t0mas88 on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:12PM (#27269775)
The fines are based on your revenue and the impact. So they do differentiate between Epic Games and you.

And for me as a user, it sucks if your side project leaks my credit card and SSN, because I'll be dealing with the identity theft and fraud. If you're not competent enough to keep them safe, then use a vendor that is or don't process then at all.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:19PM (#27269852)
If it were only SSN or credit card data, this would be understandable. But I assume you’re aware GDPR is far broader than this.

And as well, GDPR, again, doesn’t guarantee the safety of your data. It just adds fines to some circumstances where your data is misused. But an honest breach doesn’t lead to fines as far as I can tell, so you just have to live with that possibility either way.

As best as I can tell, there is no legally binding texts anywhere that limits the fines. The maximums start at €20 million and go higher if you’re huge. In the mindset of “hope is not a strategy,” this maximum fine being the only legally binding limit is enough to make you go home. Maybe small companies can hope for preferential treatment, but as an individual even small fees could do serious harm.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jokethrowaway on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:57PM (#27270664)
Work behind a limited company and let it fail.

Escape to Mexico in the worst scenario.

South America is anyway becoming more and more appealing the more the West progress.

That said, not that it changes much but I stopped taking EU customers (I take businesses and not customers) because of vatmoss and gdpr.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Aerroon on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:18PM (#27271671)
Vatmoss was so blatantly dumb in its implementation that it makes me wonder whether the MEPs even spent 5 minutes thinking about the implications of it. How can you look at all the VAT systems and not realize that almost all of them have a minimum threshold?!

It is a bit ironic that it's probably a good idea for an EU service to not serve EU customers.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by sealeck on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:55PM (#27269592)
Don't let people enter their data onto your side projects unless you're willing to treat it responsibly?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:59PM (#27269623)
Intent doesn’t matter; the fear is the same: life-destroying fines. If that’s the choice, I’d just opt out of taking EU customers.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Hamuko on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:01PM (#27269642)
How many examples of life-destroying fines do you have?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:03PM (#27269672)
So basically, you’re in the “No, it’s fine — this will only ever get used against bad guys!” camp. We had 9/11 here in America and the BS that followed and I don’t humor this line of thinking. (Nor humour.)
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Hamuko on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:04PM (#27269687)
No, I'm in the "prove that the thing you are claiming to happen actually happens" camp.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:06PM (#27269703)
I’m not claiming something happened — do you understand how chilling effects work? The threat of potentially massive fines with very little legal bounds for not following regulations that individuals basically can’t follow means that people who want to follow the rules but aren’t big enough don’t play anymore.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Hamuko on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:07PM (#27269716)
So no one's life has ever been ruined by the GDPR? But you're still sure that this will happen? What is this based on?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:13PM (#27269790)
I can get fined between 0 and €20 million at any moment because I am an individual and have no means to fully understand GDPR nor hire a DPO for my stupid personal websites. I make no money in ads or otherwise, but I am still treated like Epic Games if I collect sign up emails or logs. I only still run this stuff now because I’ve been running it for over a decade. I can tell you right now I am hesitant to run websites anymore.

If you don’t understand how “ambiguous threat of a fine” isn’t calmed by “it hasn’t happened yet,” I can’t help you. What if my site was politically controversial? Should I trust all EU governments to act responsibly and not take advantage of their power ever?

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by anoncake on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:31PM (#27269958)
If there is a real danger that EU gouvernments start abusing their power like that, why is it only Americans that are afraid of it? Not EU citizens, who actually are familiar with how their states behave?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jokethrowaway on Monday May 24, 2021 @07:00PM (#27270686)
I'm a EU citizen in Europe and you can count me scared
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Aerroon on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:31PM (#27271728)
I'm an EU citizen and GDPR is one of the reasons why I'm hesitant to run a website. I don't see how you could look at the risk from GDPR and find it reasonable to run it as an individual. An individual is liable for any fines with everything they own. Companies usually cost something to run, even if they only exist to hold something.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by anoncake on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @04:04AM (#27274179)
> I don't see how you could look at the risk from GDPR and find it reasonable to run it as an individual.

By not being paranoid.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:41PM (#27270047)
Clearly, nobody is afraid by it: I am getting buried insanely any time I criticize GDPR in any way. It is a thing you are not allowed to critique on HN.

So I wouldn’t say americans are particularly more bothered by it. But why shouldn’t we be? I have no representation in EU law.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by drdavid on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:19PM (#27271673)
I live in the US. I care not one iota about their cookie law and I'm not going to nag my visitors about cookies. Of course the site uses cookies. That's how you retain your settings from session to session.

At the same time, I'll happily give you any data I have about you. I don't really collect anything. Your IP address gets logged and you give me an email address if you want to get a newsletter (on most sites of mine). I'll even happily delete your data, such as it is.

I'm in the camp that says if I have your data I have to secure it. So, I'd rather not really collect more than I need. I don't even need to know your real name and you're more than welcome to use a fake email address for many things.

But, no... No, I'm not going to nag my viewers with a cookie notice. I don't care if they come from the EU. I don't like the nag and I'm not going to nag you.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by anoncake on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:48PM (#27270094)
> Clearly, nobody is afraid by it: I am getting buried insanely any time I criticize GDPR in any way. It is a thing you are not allowed to critique on HN.

Not if your criticisms are entirely unfounded and bordering on paranoia, no.

> But why shouldn't we be? I have no representation in EU law.

What? Do you think only EU citizens have rights in the EU?

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:58PM (#27270175)
> Not if your criticisms are entirely unfounded and bordering on paranoia, no.

I am not a lawyer and I do not have access to a lawyer. I can't afford it. Therefore, I have to assume that I simply do not have the expertise to understand GDPR fully. And unlike most laws, it is not a matter of "do things right and nothing will happen", and it has very vicious teeth on top of that.

So from my PoV, the risk profile of GDPR is HUGE. If I'm running some pre-existing software stack written in the early 2000s, it simply doesn't have the necessary data provenance tracking that is needed to be GDPR compliant.

For what it's worth, I make no money from things I run, not even on ads. Zilch. However, I've spent at least hours processing GDPR requests, and I have absolutely no idea if they are being done correctly, because I'm not a lawyer, and I do not have access to a lawyer.

> What? Do you think only EU citizens have rights in the EU?

I'm talking about representation in the sense of a democracy. I am part of the system in the U.S. - I can vote. I have no representation when it comes to laws made in the EU. The reverse applies too, but as far as I know there's nothing quite as scary as GDPR from the U.S. side.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by orwin on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:54PM (#27270140)
I don't understand. You can contest your fine if it is really too big, but honestly, at my last job we had one client project that got "caught". The CNIL (GDPR watchdog for France) was really helpfull, gave them 6 month to get into shape and proposed them a plan on what to do with the data to meet their goals. The kind of plan that cost a company 5-10k euros to elaborate (2 man/day of a good architect), and 10k (10 man/day of a junior db dev) to implement. So between a third and half the price to make the business legal again was basically paid by the CNIL. I think that's fair tbh.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:01PM (#27270204)
That's the thing: I'm not a company, I'm a person, who happens to run websites, that make no money. A 10k euro fine would run me off the internet.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by danhor on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:49PM (#27270599)
The point of the comment is that the CNIL handled the part that the "good architect" would have needed to do, thus saving the company 5-10k. The company "only" needed to implement it, the other part was handled for them. The GP didn't mention fines, so I guess none were given out?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Aerroon on Monday May 24, 2021 @09:23PM (#27271692)
You're effectively saying that we don't really need limits on state power until the state has used that power. That's a pretty bold stance considering all the abuses of power modern states engage in. Why don't we just have an absolute monarch? It would make things much easier!
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by anoncake on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:15PM (#27269813)
Maybe it doesn't in America. Here it does.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:14PM (#27269795)
Can you show me one example where there was a "life-destroying" fine?

Not "a big company was fined an amount of money that would be life destroying if I had to pay it for a personal project", because revenue/economic means are a key factor in GDPR fine calculation.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Hamuko on Monday May 24, 2021 @04:56PM (#27269603)
My name, my address, my phone number and my credit card details are the same regardless whether you or Epic Games is storing them in a database.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:02PM (#27269655)
A data breach alone is not a GDPR violation as far as I know. Your data is just as at risk of being exposed no matter what. As far as I can tell the intent of GDPR is to prevent companies from selling or using your data in ways that you did not consent to. However, the bookkeeping requirements quite literally break the internet that existed where one person could run a website. As it turns out, I do not have a Data Protection Officer for my wiki I started in 2008. Does that mean I am not GDPR compliant?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:32PM (#27269971)
> As it turns out, I do not have a Data Protection Officer for my wiki I started in 2008. Does that mean I am not GDPR compliant?

Do you have more than 250 employees? Are you a public authority or body? Are you performing activities that "require regular and systematic monitoring of data subjects on a large scale"? Is your core activity processing on a large scale of special categories of data pursuant to Article 9 or personal data relating to criminal convictions and offences?

No? Then no need to have a data protection officer or data protection impact assessment.

You still need to implement appropriate safety measures and efforts to follow GDPR, where "appropriate" takes the scope of your processing into account. https://gdpr-info.eu/art-24-gdpr/, need a legitimate reason for using the data, etc., but all of this is very doable, and you're probably already in compliance if you care the smallest bit about your user's privacy and follow normal best practices like rotating your logs.

IIUC (there are two directives and I'm less familiar with the other one) you don't even need a cookie dialog as long as you aren't setting any unnecessary cookies.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by amichal on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:26PM (#27269914)
And you dont need to have one:

.... hiring an actual Data Protection Officer is only required by the GDPR if you meet one of three criteria:

  * Public authority — The processing of personal data is done by a public body or public authorities, with exemptions granted to courts and other independent judicial authorities.
  * Large scale, regular monitoring — The processing of personal data is the core activity of an organization who regularly and systematically observes its “data subjects” (which, under the GDPR, means citizens or residents of the EU) on a large scale.
  * Large-scale special data categories — The processing of specific “special” data categories (as defined by the GDPR) is part of an organization’s core activity and is done on a large scale.
https://gdpr.eu/data-protection-officer/
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:39PM (#27270032)
This is good to know. But while I will admit my mistake, the problem points to a bigger issue, which is, as a layperson and not an expert on European law, I simply do not have the expertise necessary to understand the law and its implications. This is of course true of any website under any jurisdiction, but most laws don’t come with such absurdly vicious teeth, and therefore the risk profile is a lot different. So perhaps my example was misinformed. But that’s kind of the problem: you need to have a lawyer to really be sure of these things. I don’t have a lawyer.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by amichal on Monday May 24, 2021 @06:00PM (#27270189)
I think the fines/penalty headlines are a big misunderstanding/distraction (which got me too until I had to spend the time on reading the actual law for an actual EU client). They are what happens if you continually, willfully disobey the principal of the laws AND are also proportional to you income (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day-fine which are common in some EU countries)

If you are a small operator who messes up AND you are in the EU and you ignore strongly worded letters of warning with instructions on what you need to do to comply then you MIGHT be fined/penalized.

If you are not making money in the EU than you are seriously unlikely to even be noticed messing up.

If you miss-configured the logs on your blog or small non-EU business and kept user ids and IP addresses AND are outside the EU no one will bother you.

If a privacy conscious EU citizen contacts you to close an account they made with you or delete your data you have many weeks (90 days i think ultimately) to respond, negotiate and do your best to get it done (and provide them whatever data you may have collected on them)

If you have any of a dozen legitimate reasons to have personal data and you clearly explained this to the EU citizens you collected data from you are not going to hear from anyone. e.g. a EU company I work with has extensive logs of their employees changes and updates to data (imagine git commit messages). These are required logs for the business, an ex-employee cannot ask you delete that history under GDPR. Same for their b2b customers. The existence of these logs are made clear up front. It's a regulated requirement that they exist etc.

If you decided to sell the log data to a third party as part of some profile of the citizen and you didnt say you intended to do that then you ABSOLUTELY would hear from someone. But I would think you very much should and this is the point.

Same principles apply for California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the US.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by hkh28 on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:00PM (#27269636)
GDPR fines are set among other things according to the resources of the entity that broke the rules. As a private person making a side project, you won't be liable for millions.

The most recent examples of individuals being fined have been fines around €200 [0]

[0] https://gdprhub.eu/index.php?title=ANSPDCP_(Romania)_-_Fine_...

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by amichal on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:42PM (#27270054)
This[1] site seems to track actual fines. I found maybe a dozen fines of individuals. Here is the largest fine of a 'private person' I could find: https://www.enforcementtracker.com/ETid-69. If the database is at all accurate and the description of the violation is correct I would say they were well into Criminal territory and not civil fines. [1] https://www.enforcementtracker.com
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:05PM (#27269691)
The maximums however, are absolutely insane. Am I supposed to just hope that in the range of 0 to €20 million, it’s something I can afford?
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by tephra on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:09PM (#27269741)
Getting a maximum fine not only means that your handling of personal data was especially egregious but that you probably didn't cooperate in any ways with the relevant DPA and refused to rectify the problem.

I.e the maximum fine is highly unlikely for anyone to get, and if you get it you have done some very bad things.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by jchw on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:33PM (#27269981)
Yes, and what the GDPR crowd is telling me is that I should just trust the EU to always act fairly and never engage in any kind of politically motivated subterfuge.

And not only that, my concerns and dissent regarding GDPR piss people off so much, that at this point, every comment I post just gets downvoted immediately. Now I realize it’s against HN guidelines to discuss this, but when I post a comment and the delay it takes for me to return from the post page is enough for my comment to already have a downvote, I feel discouraged. It’s very clear the person who did that had no good faith intent on a discussion nor intent to even minimally read my comment. And I’m supposed to try to argue my points in good faith despite this.

The pro-GDPR crowd may be winning the mindshare but they are inheriting the cancer of something not allowed to be criticized. And if we ever do see an egregious fee driven by political motivations, am I supposed to feel smug for having predicted the possibility or sad that my mere expression that the default maximum fines are so ridiculous that they basically terrorize anyone who is not a multinational corporation turned out to be well-founded?

All I ever asked for was for people to recognize the chilling effects that this regulation can have. The internet used to have so many small websites, forums and wikis, and many of these fall under the umbrella of GDPR. And this is basically the treatment I get for trying to represent this dying breed of website: as some corporate shill worth being buried and not considered.

It’s not like I care that much about being with the mob, but it pains me that as the open internet gradually dies, people flat out just don’t care. GDPR as it is today is just represents a huge amount of risk for anyone that is not a multinational corporation, and it only gets scarier the further down you are. I’m sorry but just telling people to not worry about how the law is written will not work. Some people will ignore it, some people will try to follow it, and some people will just stop trying altogether deciding the risk simply isn’t worth it. And that latter part is most likely to occur for websites that are more objectionable, since they will likely face harsher treatment just due to cognitive biases alone, since we’re talking about considerations that humans make rather than the word of law.

Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by tgsovlerkhgsel on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:33PM (#27269988)
No, you're supposed to hope that the legal system will apply the law fairly and correctly. The law does NOT say that they can fine you 20 million Euro. The 20 million is an upper limit on a fine, but the law also specifies how that fine is determined, which _by definition_ is "something you can afford", because that's literally one of the factors.
Re:3 years of GDPR: The biggest fines so far by Ekaros on Monday May 24, 2021 @05:36PM (#27270012)
Maximum fine is there for large corporations. If it wasn't specified at atleast that range many of them would ignore or knowingly break the legislation. And in general checking for many crimes the upper end of penalty is pretty big. Like DUI here could mean 2 years in prison. Though that is exceedingly rare.