I hold an extremely high opinion of most HN readers. I have never before in my life talked with so many people who intimidate me through raw intelligence alone. I find it very hard to believe that there's some secret sexist agenda upon which they've all agreed.
Rather, I think HN has an extremely low tolerance for bullshit, and a hacker's typical hyper-focus on competence.
The hacker ethic is pretty egalitarian; it basically boils down to "If you know your stuff, you can hang with us." Peter Deutsch was 12 when he was messing around in the MIT lab, and no one minded---except the pointy-headed academics, which is typical.
So to say in the midst of a hackers' forum that we ought to judge on something other than technical merit...well, what do you expect? Startups don't need women---women are ditzy, appearance-focused, and scared of risk. Startups don't need men either---men are prone to irrational risky behavior, overconfident, and inconsiderate. Startups need engineers, and they are rare enough in both genders that they'll take them if they're blind, half-man half-woman, triple-lesbian, WHATEVER.
There are social issues (particularly in beginning CS classes, IMO) that can be addressed, but the issue is generally not male discrimination in the Valley, and that's what the article implies. That's what stirs the reaction here.
And stop your straw-man labeling. It brings down the level of discussion.
Tell me again who has power here: the people writing the headlines for the New Yorker? Or the poor HN engineer being forced yet again to don the sackcloth and ashes for having a Y chromosome?
Women in general are statistically less interested in math, science, or computers. They are also less violent and tragically underrepresented in prisons, low-wage jobs, and the combat arms of the military.
When women agitate to sign up for Selective Service and the great and the good militate to push more women into garbage disposal, gravedigging, and septic tank repair, that's when you'll know they're serious about equality.
If you refuse to use it, I salute you.
It's an observation, not an "absurdly wrong-headed, misogynist thing".
Edit: and Michael Arrington said "Every damn time we have a conference we fret over how we can find women to fill speaking slots. We ask our friends and contacts for suggestions. We beg women to come and speak. . . . And you know what? A lot of the time they say no. Because they are literally hounded to speak at every single tech event in the world because they are all trying so hard to find qualified women to speak at their conference."
And all Hispanics are lazy.
And all Irish people drink.
Etc.
The trouble with generalizations is that they stop being useful when you're dealing with individual human beings. It's your business if you want to say absurdly wrong-headed, misogynist things but at least sign your real name to them, huh?
edit: Ah, the good ol' HN No Girls Allowed Brigade. Good luck, travelers.