News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by hxa7241 on Sunday July 03, 2011 @09:18AM (#2723641)
A basic roundup of ethical problems for IP:

* Conflict with fundamental personal liberty: Mill's idea that we have unrestricted liberty except to the extent that it injures someone else, is fairly standard. But IP conflicts with that, yet IP is not fundamental, not grounded in physical fact. (See Koepsell: http://www.hxa.name/articles/content/ethical-case-against-ip...)

* Cannot be justified on the basis of harm: One could justify rights by showing that lack of them causes harm to those denied. But IP represents no physical relation where any harm could be rendered. (See Wilson: http://www.ucl.ac.uk/~rehbjgs/docs/could-there-be-a-right.pd...)

* Does not make complete sense as a generalised rule: The idea that a moral rule is generalisable, as a critical feature, is also standard (probably more so). But if everyone owned IP equally much there is no advantage, and everyone would be better off freely sharing copies. (And indeed, what do we seem to see amongst similarly large corporations? They buy big patent portfolios and agree, or tacitly accept, truces between them.)

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by michael_dorfman on Sunday July 03, 2011 @09:59AM (#2723697)
None of these are ethical problems if you accept the premise that the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for the production of said work, and can contract (exclusively, for a period of time) with a publisher for the distribution of said work.

Put another way: you may (or may not) be old enough to remember when an American paperback company, Ace books, produced and sold paperback copies of Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings" without paying Tolkien for the rights (and in direct competition with Houghton Mifflin, to whom Tolkien had contracted).

Are you prepared to argue that Ace did Tolkien no harm?

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by hxa7241 on Sunday July 03, 2011 @10:22AM (#2723728)
> if you accept the premise that the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for the production of said work

That is not the premise, that is the matter in question.

If it is simply assumed as the answer, nothing has been said.

As to the idea of harm here, it is not in the actions or materials themselves. It depends on assuming the particular law is the baseline, and then saying without that the person would be worse-off. That is effectively saying: people can make a living in a particular way because of the rule, and we have the rule because people can make a living in a particular way from it. This is a circular fallacy. It cannot be justified by itself.

Why is IP justified? -- as a rational argument, in terms more basic than the question itself . . . (having looked around a bit, there seems to be only one half-decent/plausible one: the standard economic one -- which is not really an ethical argument (and conspicuously lacks actual evidence anyway))

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by cschwarm on Sunday July 03, 2011 @02:49PM (#2724297)
> Why is IP justified?

From an economic point of view, by trying to prevent something like the tragedy of the commons.

Since everyone can make copies if there is no ownership, the majority of authors have no incentive to make their works public. And since authors can figure this out before starting to work, there's less production of works than beneficial.

In other words: Nobody would have spend the money to make movies like Lords of the Rings, or whatever you fancy.

The free market argument applies in a world with ownership, too: Those who paid the price for a work are assumed to be better off, otherwise they wouldn't have agreed to the bargain. If they would want works without ownership, they can always assemble, throw their money into one pot, and have works made for them.

Since they don't do this, an average, the incentive of having works with no ownership can't be that great.

You got to admit that every author is the possessor of his work, even in a world without ownership, since he possesses the first copy. So, the question is: How can you make him publish his copy?

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by wnight on Monday July 04, 2011 @03:48AM (#2725749)
> In other words: Nobody would have spend the money to make movies like Lords of the Rings, or whatever you fancy.

Sure. Like how nobody would write encyclopedia articles, operating systems, fiction, manuals, textbooks, etc, for free.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by SigmundA on Sunday July 03, 2011 @11:14AM (#2723805)
Ethically it simply comes down to giving credit where credit is due.

If you discuss a new idea that you have spent time formulating with a co-worker that is good for the company and the co-worker presents this idea to your common boss as their own and receive a promotion for it, is this ethically wrong?

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by hxa7241 on Sunday July 03, 2011 @12:18PM (#2723938)
Yes, that is wrong -- it seems covered by the ethics of lying/truth-telling (from Kant, it is contradictory: if lying were a universal rule, it would destroy the possibility of communication in general).

But IP is about more than just clear attribution. And clear attribution is not dependent on IP -- we can have it without the other IP features. So a justification of attribution is not sufficient to support IP too.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by SigmundA on Sunday July 03, 2011 @12:57PM (#2724023)
You haven't explained how they are different, what is the difference between a co-worker stealing your idea for personal gain and someone else in society doing the same?

In IP it's essentially about someone lying to society about the source of the idea.

The only difference I see is the organizational entities scope, but the ethic is the same.

IP is basically contractualized attribution.

Owning an idea as property is simply a societal contract that guarantee's you attribution for your idea.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by xilun0 on Sunday July 03, 2011 @02:02PM (#2724163)
you are pretending there is on difference between attribution of ideas and utilisation of ideas. I won't even explain why this is not true.
Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by SigmundA on Sunday July 03, 2011 @02:59PM (#2724326)
Where did I pretend there is no difference?

If in my example the company chooses not to implement the idea, I still deserve credit for the idea correct, not someone else?

Perhaps I would not receive a promotion because it was never implemented and proven to be beneficial to the company, but that does not make stealing an idea ethically fine does it, just because it was not utilized?

Not bothering to explain is just a cop out.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by stonemetal on Sunday July 03, 2011 @11:12PM (#2725243)
In IP it's essentially about someone lying to society about the source of the idea.

Right here. If I print a copy of Lord of the Rings and sell it, and there is no difference between my copy and the official copy. Then there has been no lying to society Tolkien's name is written on the cover an attributed as the author. Full credit for the idea has been given. In your example full credit for authorship was not given.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by andrewflnr on Sunday July 03, 2011 @07:47PM (#2724902)
I think what he is proposing is to accept it as a premise because it makes intuitive sense, and stop making it so complicated. Really, where do all these ideas about liberty and harm come from? Our intuition, or rather, our conscience. If you want to go really fundamental, why does harm to human beings matter at all?

What was said below about IP ethically being about attribution was pretty close to the mark, in my opinion. It just makes sense for people to have a right to control what they make, physical or otherwise, and to go too far beyond that seems to me to be dangerously over-thinking the issue.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by slowpoke on Sunday July 03, 2011 @10:19AM (#2723724)
>if you accept the premise that the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for the production of said work

Then please elaborate why we should accept said premise. You just state it like it's an universal law of the universe. It isn't. No artisan (or actually, no one at all) is entitled to a successful business modell.

And by the way, the "problem" aren't the people who are unwilling to pay for anything (which I am sure you or someone else will cite sooner or later). It's the people expecting to make money with art. It's cool if you can. If you can't, then you're not entitled to laws or monopolies that protect your failed business modell.

>Are you prepared to argue that Ace did Tolkien no harm?

Why should it have? More people were able to read his beautiful works. Are you prepared to argue how that constitutes as harm in the first place?

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by dctoedt on Sunday July 03, 2011 @11:40AM (#2723856)
> [The problem is] the people expecting to make money with art. It's cool if you can. If you can't, then you're not entitled to laws or monopolies that protect your failed business modell.

Agreed that there's no entitlement to laws or monopolies. And I grant you that some ultra-libertarians oppose any restriction on their personal economic freedom, citing moral reasons.

But society sometimes decides, for pragmatic reasons, that it's a sensible bet to grant limited-term monopolies [1], in the hope that over the long term everyone will benefit. We see that in the Writings and Discoveries Clause, article I, section 8, clause 8 of the U.S. Constitution.[2]

EDIT in response to comments: Just what monopolies to grant, and for how long, is of course the $64K question. It's been my observation that this is one of those issues where, for many people, where you stand depends on where you sit (or is it the other way around?)

[1] Technically, "monopoly" is a misnomer when applied IP rights in the general case. In economics, the term refers to someone having a lock on access to goods or services for which there's no 'viable' substitute. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly.

[2] http://topics.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articlei#section8

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by hxa7241 on Sunday July 03, 2011 @12:31PM (#2723964)
> Technically, "monopoly" is a misnomer when applied to IP

Whatever the technical rectitude of non-monopoly assertions, they really ought to sound fairly shady when one considers the very intent and mechanism of IP: to increase profits of the producer, by raising prices through restricting supply. IP is certainly supposed to quack like a duck.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by Symmetry on Sunday July 03, 2011 @12:03PM (#2723902)
Its true that copyrights aren't very much like monopolies in the economic sense, but they grew out of the the older, legal meaning of that term. Back In The Day the grown would sell patents granting the owner a monopoly over the production of some good as a way of raising money quickly. This practice has quite thankfully died out as a way of raising revenue, but our current system of assigning exclusive rights to creators grew directly out of it. The Wikipedia article on the Statute of Monopolies is pretty interesting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statute_of_Monopolies_1623
Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by michael_dorfman on Sunday July 03, 2011 @10:56AM (#2723778)
I'm not stating that the premise (that the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for the production) is a universal law of the universe. In fact, I'm not even stating that I agree with the premise. I'm just pointing out that it is an unstated assumption in much of the discussion surrounding IP.

In other words, the account given of the "ethical problems of intellectual property" above is dependent upon one rejecting that premise, and that contrarily, those that accept the premise will find the "ethical objections" to be unpersuasive.

If one is prepared to argue (as you apparently are), that Tolkien had no moral right to the proceeds of the sale of his books, then indeed no harm has been done. If, on the other hand, you accept the premise I elaborated (and which Tolkien explicitly appealed to, in a famous statement), the harm is evident.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by praptak on Sunday July 03, 2011 @12:33PM (#2723967)
"If one is prepared to argue (as you apparently are), that Tolkien had no moral right to the proceeds of the sale of his books [...]"

It is possible to believe that he had the moral right to the proceeds but only on the basis of the copyright policy that existed at the time he wrote the books. This doesn't mean you cannot at the same time argue that such policy should be abolished.

In other words the Tolkien case is a red herring here.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by apotheon on Sunday July 03, 2011 @10:27AM (#2723735)
> None of these are ethical problems if you accept the premise that the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for the production of said work

How do you figure? The problems still exist; you've just decided to de-prioritize them compared to the remuneration entitlement you posit.

Consider this alternative: the author of a work is entitled to be remunerated for anything for which he or she arranges an agreement with someone to remunerate him or her. Period. This would mean it is up to the author to make arrangements for someone to pay him or her when he or she produces something and turns it over to the employer, and that it is then the employer's responsibility to figure out how to make a profit from it by similarly arranging an agreement with someone else (when speaking of a standard employment relationship for authors).

> Are you prepared to argue that Ace did Tolkien no harm?

You're missing the distinction between direct harm on one hand, and unexpected competition for a monopolized market on the other. From a certain perspective, the harm in the second case is not harm caused by the unexpected competitor, but rather harm caused by the monopolist's failure to account for competition in its business model.

Re:The 'intellectual property' oxymoron by uriel on Monday July 04, 2011 @11:00AM (#2726699)
This is a strawman, nobody is arguing that people should not be allowed to demand compensation for their work, authors and musicians were able to demand compensation no differently from anyone else before IP came around, the problem is the demand that they should be granted a monopoly and control over the physical property of others, that is what IP is.