Here we saw the emperor go on a full war path against the entire place of origin of a couple of misguided individuals. Not a proportionate response.
The IRB is a gatekeeper, yes, but it is also a resource. You should be working with the IRB to make sure everything you are doing is above the board, because ultimately, if you do something unethical or harmful to individuals or society, that's still on you, even if you got your plan stamped by the IRB. You shouldn't have an antagonistic relationship where you use the vague and technically accurate but misleading descriptions of your research an an attempt to get a "get out of consequences free" card.
Which suggests an entirely new line of inquiry: testing IRB procedures to see whether unethical proposals will be approved if described in misleading terms.
While we're at it, we should check to see whether proposals ostensibly from people who are not faculty or students, or who perhaps don't even exist, are ever approved.
Regardless of the results, we can conclude that having to sign a statement promising to never do unethical research before submitting a proposal, and insisting on identity verification before proposals are reviewed, will lower the chances of unethical research proposals slipping through.
However yes, review of the patches was proper but all this could have been done with less unfounded accusations from gregs side.
Really curious who makes unfunded accusations ...
And the resulting conversations between Aditya Pakki and Greg. Aditya was never part of the hypocrite commit research, accusing them for this is just bad.
Greg's concerns proved to be overblown, but at the time they were raised he had reason to believe them valid.
At the time, UMC had not "debriefed" the kernel maintainers they lied to in the "hypocrite commits".
And then Pakki didn't mention that these new patches were generated by a tool, and submitted a bunch of "nonsense" patches with no explanation.
What reason did GKH have to trust anyone associated with the "hypocrite commits" at that point?
(ps. don't think you deserve all the downvotes here...)
Yes, they are bad patches and the research is also questionable. But this is not bad faith nor malicious.
Do you want to take a moment and explain how your broken static anylizer isn't involved?
Or, y'know. Click on the profile.
I did click your profile, but this is a post about deception. Trust no one.
I don't think it was an overreaction. I think it was a very valid reaction.