Re:Linux 5.13 Reverts and Fixes the Problematic University o...
by neatze on Friday May 21, 2021 @10:53AM
(#27234788)
What really happened (to the best of my understanding):
- Researchers submitted paper to IEEE.
- Researcher twitter about it.
- Tweet was deleted, because people pointed out it was bad humans subject researcher. (consent and deception)
- Other researchers not from UNM, filled complaints to IEEE.
- Researcher mislead (so far seems like) IRB, arguably IRB failed to do a job and just rubber stamped human subject research exemption, after research was conducted ...
- Paper got accepted to IEEE.
- Researchers push more patches to Linux kernel.
- Plonk email from Greg.
- UNM response latter indirectly blaming only researchers but not IRB.
- Paper get retracted from IEEE
- IEEE Response letter.
- We are here.
> Based on the overall positive reviews and the recommendation of all reviewers to accept the work, the PC did not discuss this paper during the online PC meeting; [...] When, after acceptance, the authors tweeted the abstract of the work in November 2020, several people expressed concerns about human-subject research featured in this work. At that time, the PC chairs discussed these concerns [...]. As a result of these discussions, the PC chairs asked the authors to clarify the experiments with the University of Minnesota Institutional Review Board (IRB). We now acknowledge that this offer was a mistake
Basically: they did not review it and once it was published and people complained, they reacted. What's the point of the PC then?