News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by ttttqqqq on Saturday July 02, 2011 @03:51AM (#2721266)
I love Google marketing, it's like a Soviet propaganda assault. "The masses are clamoring for Google's new product. The next generation has spoken."
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by dekz on Saturday July 02, 2011 @03:26AM (#2721241)
Although my heart goes out for William (http://d.pr/41VG), I am quite happy google hasn't offered rich text features in plus.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by corin_ on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:24AM (#2721404)
There are some formatting options available - https://plus.google.com/106788603501468469828/posts/849WcarV...
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by FreshCode on Saturday July 02, 2011 @08:02AM (#2721503)
This is hilarious! Looks just like my little sister's Facebook feed.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by chunky1994 on Saturday July 02, 2011 @02:27AM (#2721164)
It's quite frustrating when you're 17 and can't use it, this is going to make a lot of kids unhappy.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by brackin on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:19AM (#2721296)
For some reason me and my friends are in and i'm 17. I don't remember entering my age into Google, I never lied just never entered it. Not sure what their data source it. Once hunch was Google accounts which use YouTube as they have an age limit.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by avolcano on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:29AM (#2721303)
Same here. I just did some poking around for places to put a day of birth into Google or see what my current one is and couldn't find one (not in Google+ or on the Google Accounts page). I have a feeling your YouTube theory is right though; there's a good chance I set mine to be a year older so I could watch the age-restricted videos.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by shii on Saturday July 02, 2011 @08:50AM (#2721545)
Same, and I think you're right about them using the Youtube age.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Breefield on Saturday July 02, 2011 @03:30AM (#2721248)
This summarizes everything I feel about the drinking age. Pure frustration and arbitrary dates/ages.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by corin_ on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:40AM (#2721426)
When you word it like that of course it's stupid, but what law would you suggest that doesn't use arbitrary ages? Obviously they don't fit everyone exactly, I know I was drinking before I was 18 and think that was fine, I've also known people who really hadn't matured by the time they were legally adults.

Do you agree that a 40 year old shouldn't be able to have sex with a 6 year old? Do you agree that a ten year old shouldn't be allowed to walk into a shop and buy a packet of cigarettes and a bottle of vodka?

Assuming yes, the only two options are an arbitrary age that won't be perfect for everyone, but will at least protect as many people as possible, or no law, and if shit happens to kids then oh well.

After that you can of course debate where the arbitrary ages are, for example I think it's ridiculous that 21 is the drinking age in America.

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by donall on Saturday July 02, 2011 @01:33PM (#2721995)
Do you agree that a ten year old shouldn't be allowed to walk into a shop and buy a packet of cigarettes and a bottle of vodka?

When I was 10, I regularly bought beer and cigarettes in the shop near our house. I also bought bread, eggs, milk, etc. I was buying these things for my parents. I don't think there's anything wrong with that, except for the fact that I occasionally bought sweets for myself with the change. Unsurprisingly, as a 10 year old, I was more interested in strawberry chewing gum and red licorice than beer and cigarettes (which I had tried and found to be revolting).

When I was 10, my older brother turned 16. My father started including him when he ordered wine with dinner and he had the occasional beer with his friends. I have never seen any evidence of my brother abusing alcohol.

On the other hand, I saw plenty of alcohol abuse when we moved to Ireland. The strictness of the law here leads to the same problems associated with any other illegal drug abuse. Users (in this case, minors) consume it in secret and often in uncontrolled and dangerous ways. I'd much prefer to have a 16 year old kid being kicked out of a bar for being too drunk than drinking a litre of whiskey in a field, passing out and dying of exposure.

</2¢>

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by corin_ on Saturday July 02, 2011 @02:29PM (#2722134)
I'm with you on lowering the drinking age in the US from 21 (though 18 seems pretty much OK in my view), and I also support legalisation of recreational drugs.

Your story of being 10 is pretty irrelevant, though, you're just one person. If everybody behaved a particular way in all aspects of life, we'd have no need for any laws at all. The fact that you were useful buying them and not smoking them doesn't mean other children won't do the opposite. These sort of laws have to protect the vulnerable, not build on the basis that all children are grown up enough to look after themselves.

As to drinking in bars, I'm not so sure. In my experience, I have, my friends have and random people I see any time I go out have been able to get very drunk without being thrown out. The only time I've seen people thrown out "for being too drunk" is actually when their being drunk has made them rude and/or violent, often towards bouncers. No-one I personally know has ever got so drunk that something bad happened, but I've seen no evidence that it's harder for that to be the case in a licensed bar than a field. Regardless, even if kids could drink legally, what's stopping them from, after being kicked out for being too drunk, heading to a field with a bottle of vodka?

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by donall on Saturday July 02, 2011 @10:31PM (#2722872)
I was probably rambling a bit too much there without making my point clear.

What I meant to convey was that I don't believe there is a credible risk of many 10 year olds abusing drugs. And if any of them do it, I think the main problem in their life is not the availability of the drugs.

As for drinking in bars, when I say "too drunk" I mean dangerously drunk, not just making a fool of yourself and being rude to the staff. The point is that most bars won't let you die on their premises, or even come close to it. In most cultures, recreational alcohol consumption has a social aspect and this is desirable. Drinking in a field in secret in the dark means that if somebody does get into trouble, it's less likely to be noticed before it's too late.

As for people being kicked out of a bar for being too drunk, I think most people would just go home and sleep it off. The sort of person who will go to the effort of acquiring more alcohol and heading off alone to drink in secret probably has other problems.

Again, I'm struggling to say this concisely, so I think the important point is that limiting access to alcohol/other drugs merely attempts to relieve one of the symptoms of a larger problem. It's like trying to cure lung cancer with cough medicine.

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Jach on Saturday July 02, 2011 @03:57AM (#2721273)
To go off topic some more, but the drinking age isn't as arbitrary as, say, the 'adult age' of 18. I'm pretty sure there's some research that your brain hasn't finished developing until around 21, and possible studies on top of that which suggest early drinking may hurt your brain.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by ugh on Saturday July 02, 2011 @05:22AM (#2721342)
That would be kinda odd, considering the drinking age varies from country to country and it isn’t 21 in most of them. In Germany, for example, you can drink (in public) and buy beer and wine when you turn 16, all other alcohol when you turn 18.

Wikipedia has this informative table: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_drinking_age

I would summarize it as follows: 18 wins. I suspect not for any scientific reasons.

So what’s the history of the 21? 21 was the age of majority when prohibition ended. Most states set their legal drinking age accordingly and that’s that. Today all states have 21 as the legal drinking age since they would lose federal funding if the didn’t.

By the way, today the age of majority is 18 in all but three states.

All those drinking age limits are arbitrary. I’m actually fine with that, as long as grownups can buy alcohol. Alcohol may still be harmful for 18-year-olds (well, even more harmful than alcohol is anyway) but I don’t think it’s the government’s job to tell grownups what to do when it comes to things like alcohol or smoking or various (not sure whether I want to write all) other drugs.

(It’s even possible to have a sensible argument about whether younger kids should be allowed to buy alcohol. When you drink too much beer when you are 16 in Germany you can’t kill anyone driving since you can only get your driver’s license with 18. Maybe those two years give those kids the time to get it out of their system and to learn about the effects alcohol has on them. On the other hand American’s can already have up to five years of driving experience when they are first legally allowed to drink, but I don’t think experience helps you when you are drunk driving. You just shouldn’t do it. That would be an interesting social science study – are young Americans or Germans more likely to drunk drive?)

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Jach on Saturday July 02, 2011 @05:33AM (#2721356)
Yes, I didn't mean to turn this into a debate on the merits of alcohol consumption or the role of the government in regulating it. I was using ex post facto research (that's probably not very strong anyway) as a rationalization for the current drinking age to suggest it's not just an "arbitrary number", but as I said in cousin comment there are similar justifications for other seemingly arbitrary numbers.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by sheffield on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:34AM (#2721309)
Then the 'adult age' should be 21 too, because at 18 you're not a grownup yet. And it seems that European children grow faster because they can drink at 18 or less (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drinking_age). Or maybe brain research only exists in the US.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by fleitz on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:49AM (#2721323)
The research is that if you don't have 21 as a drinking age your state doesn't get as much federal funding for highways. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Minimum_Drinking_Age_A...

"Shortly after repeal of Prohibition in 1933, most states set their purchase ages at 21 since that was the age of majority at the time, but a few set their limits lower."

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Jach on Saturday July 02, 2011 @05:28AM (#2721352)
Thanks for the historical correction. It looks like it was set at 21 for states before Prohibition as well. I'll admit then that research on teenagers is more rationalization for keeping the limit where it is, and you can similarly find other rationalizations for keeping/changing other seemingly arbitrary age limits like 18 for adulthood, 16 for driving (and counter-reasons, etc.) Also I may be putting too much stock in the available evidence, e.g. here's a writeup from 2006: http://www.nytimes.com/2006/07/04/health/04teen.html
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by bdhe on Saturday July 02, 2011 @03:02AM (#2721212)
Moreover, as far as I can tell, there is no way to change your birthday (without involving a credit card #). Heaven forbid you accidentally entered your birthday wrongly the first time, you're locked out with little recourse!
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by acak on Saturday July 02, 2011 @01:39PM (#2722011)
While the intention is noble, the illusion of scarcity and exclusivity around G+ that this creates among teens should actually benefit G+ when its finally open to them.

Kids to want to be acknowledged as grown-ups. It frustrates them a lot when someone says they can't have or do something because they're too young. This should increase the desirability factor of G+.

So G+, by using a roll-out strategy that is demographically reversed to Facebook's path (".edu" limitation et al), may still see the same crazed adoption in the teen segment.

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Mithrandir on Saturday July 02, 2011 @02:56AM (#2721200)
Of course, age limits are moot if they've lied about their birthday.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by tonfa on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:41AM (#2721428)
But it's not Google fault if they lied, right? (In case they are for example exposed to 18+ content on Google+)
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by jackolas on Saturday July 02, 2011 @04:06AM (#2721279)
I don't understand why they're applying US-centric age restrictions world-wide. There are other countries out there.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by corin_ on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:34AM (#2721422)
The over 18 limit is nothing to do with US law, it's Google making a moral decision (or more accurately, a PR decision that, if they are to have any privacy issues occur, they want to be able ot say "at least no minors were affected").

As to the 13 and over, it's very common for companies to make that a global policy, partly because US isn't the only country to have that law (off the top of my head I can't recall which others do), partly because it's a fairly common sense decision from an adult's point of view, meaning that few would argue against it, many would argue for it on grounds of morality rather than law. And the only people who'll ever complain are a few years away from being able to vote politically or with their wallet, by which time they will be allowed to do whatever they want, and will have stopped caring. So it's pretty win/win.

Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by JulianMorrison on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:49AM (#2721444)
Ugh. I certainly consider it immoral to lock children away from the ability to talk to one another online.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by corin_ on Saturday July 02, 2011 @06:58AM (#2721450)
Technically they aren't being prevented from doing it, they just have to have a guardian's permission. Much the same as a 7 year old could join a local football/baseball/whatever team, but would need parental consent to do so.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by orenmazor on Saturday July 02, 2011 @02:36PM (#2722152)
Facebook had all kinds of restrictions when it came out. my gf was not in university at the time and was very jealous, apparently, of those of us in facebook (on a highly related note, at that time facebook was just full of nerds and bros)
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by Skywing on Saturday July 02, 2011 @02:25PM (#2722125)
How about opening Google+ up to Google Apps accounts, too? Google Apps accounts cannot create Google Profile accounts, which are required for G+.
Re:Under-18 users request to open up Google+ for them by ignifero on Saturday July 02, 2011 @12:04PM (#2721805)
Actually, since google strives to make a difference here, they should cater to kids as well. Teens love social networking and, if anything, google can use its knowledge of the web to provide a safer, child and teen-safe environment even more than facebook did. It's actually going to be impossible to keep teens away if G+ ever becomes trendy.