Re:Introduction to C++ with Game Development
by nasmorn on Friday July 01, 2011 @04:10PM
(#2719966)
On the other hand it is one of the fields where the use of C++ is completly warranted. It is fun and offers challenging problems.
I started programming like that and I sure liked it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Introduction to C++ with Game Development
by Total_Meltdown on Friday July 01, 2011 @04:38PM
(#2720061)
You're talking about two different issues. If you're maintaining UDK or something, then yes, C++ is absolutely required. But people who maintain UDK aren't learning to program anymore. They know how to write solid C++ in their sleep, so they can focus on the challenges that game development throws at them.
What eropple was saying - and I completely agree - is that C++ is a difficult language to learn on, especially when writing games. I say this as someone who learned C++ mostly by working on games. The language can tend to distract you from the problems you're trying to solve, and vice versa. The time I spent hunting segfaults could have been used building a more stable codebase or getting my product to the players.
Completely warranted? If you're doing very-high-end stuff, yes. For the majority of indie-esque games and the stuff you'll be capable of doing when learning to program, and learning to write sane code during your formative stages? Not so much.
C# with OpenTK (or SlimDX, or XNA) or Python with PyGame are both superior choices for that sort of thing.
Re:Introduction to C++ with Game Development
by Impossible on Saturday July 02, 2011 @05:16PM
(#2722458)
To be fair not everyone is making indie games. Although I wouldn't suggest starting out with C++, and wouldn't suggest it to people wanting to make games for PC as a single developer in a small team, if you eventually want to be a programmer working on AAA PC, console or mobile games you have to know C++ well in order to get hired, even if you primarily work in a different language. C++ is also still required for higher end indie stuff. I don't see that changing any time soon.
If they're not making indie games, or are making "higher end indie stuff," they wouldn't be reading an article like this.
Re:Introduction to C++ with Game Development
by Impossible on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @08:42PM
(#2761261)
Eh not necessarily. Someone in high school or college could be reading this article because they want to work on AAA games in the future and need a decent starting point, not because they want to start making indie games right now. You have to learn somehow and the game industry still hires junior programmers.