Nowhere in the article did it even imply any of the players in this transaction were trolls.
Read it in that light, and things tie together much more smoothly. Whether it is good writing (e.g. effectively conveying a point) is questionable, since it obviously has cause confusion.
the consortium that bought nortel's patents didn't do so for the patents themselves, they did so to prevent google from having the patents. And they didn't want google to not have the patents not because they were afraid of google bringing products to market based on those patents, but because they didn't want google to be able to shield themselves from patent lawsuits.
These were probably the ones that those companies wanted, and the entire reason that the price is so high. They simply could not let Google be the sole owner of the patents, because that would give Google way too much power in the mobile space.
Out of all the companies, MS is probably the only one that did it specifically to hurt Google. However, this also could signal that MS is going to make their own WM7 phone.
Exactly what is the basis for this?
As you noted Nokia with whom Microsoft shares some interest would benefit from owning those patents. In addition, Microsoft as owner of Skype now has a substantial interest in patents applying to telephony networks.
It's not clear to me that that was their final bid, either. Maybe it was, but I can't imagine Google letting something important to them climb at auction from from $0.9 billion to $4.5 billion without staking another bid.
The second thing I don't understand is the connection between the price paid by a consortium of major tech companies[1] for a collection of patents from a formerly major tech company--only a few of which are even software at all--to Fred Wilson ranting about Lodsys. Who is the troll here? Nortel? What is the significance of the dollar figure? How does it "echo the sentiment" of Wilson?
[1]:BetaBeat says "...a coalition of Microsoft, Apple, RIM, and Sony...", while the actual press release[2] states: "Apple, EMC, Ericsson, Microsoft, Research In Motion and Sony."
[2]:http://www.marketwatch.com/story/nortel-announces-the-winnin...