Interestingly, classic MacOS, at the times of 6.5 or 7, was somehow more customizable, and seemed to have more power-user features. Just like, well, Gnome back in the day %)
So, my daily driver is Xfce.
I think Dolphin is one of the very best Linux apps out there while I found Finder to be very clunky, often so unintuitive and useless that I resorted to command line instead. To be honest, it would probably have been fine if I took the time to learn the Mac idiosyncrasies like missing cut/paste, but Finder was one of my main gripes when I had to use Mac for work.
Dolphin just has weird omissions; for instance try to sort a directory of symlinks by the time those symlinks were created. As far as I can tell, you can't do this because Dolphin follows the links and sorts by the dates of targets (contrast with `ls -ltr` and Finder, which sort by the dates of the links.)
The apps are a different story, those tend not to go for a lot of customization and will usually just focus on optimizing for one or two use cases. If you have other use cases, the suggestion there would probably be to make a separate app.
The problem is they hopped aboard the same bandwagon Microsoft did with Windows 8, where every started throwing tablet/touch style UI onto desktop interfaces.
For the life of me, I don't understand why there wasn't a happy middle ground of "or we'll render the main menu as a regular menu bar".
But at this point it's not a GNOME criticism so much as an entire UI/UX industry criticism.
To actually make good native touch/tablet apps in GNOME, you need to use a separate library called libhandy (renamed libadwaita for GTK4), and the app needs to be designed in a different way. You can usually tell the difference with an app made specifically for touch screens because it will totally de-emphasize the keyboard and mouse. I see more and more of these type of apps but only in the last couple of years, and it's mostly not to target tablets but to target the new open source phones e.g. Librem, Pinephone, etc.
"Save space"? That's a laugh. Reducing clutter is ill defined and probably subjective, but saving space? Saving it for what? The default window decorations, widgets, etc are bloated, not slim and compact (as they would be, if they were saving space.) Everything has huge margins, big buttons, and empty voids. "Saving space" is not a principle Gnome cares about.
Do you know what huge margins and big buttons are actually good for? Touchscreen interfaces designed for fat fingering. That's what Gnome cares about.
Inkscape, old style: https://media.inkscape.org/media/resources/file/inkscape-0.4...
GNOME builder, new style: https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-builder/raw/master/doc/...
The old style has four bars at the top (titlebar, menubar, toolbar, secondary toolbar). The new style merges them all into one bar and moves the menus into the hamburger menu. The margins may be bigger in the new style but ultimately, space is saved and the UI chrome is reduced. Also, GNOME Builder is not an application designed totally around touch screens -- it's a text editor, for typing into.
I sympathize if you don't like this style of app (and I encourage you to use different apps if you were used to having a lot of menus and toolbars, and you don't like the new style of GNOME apps), but what you are saying about the design goals and motivations does not match what the developers are actually doing.
I've heard this a lot, but having used Gnome briefly and MacOS fairly extensively, I just don't see it. Also, have you seen KDE's Dolphin? If ever there was a Finder clone, it's Dolphin. With regards to copying MacOS, Dolphin devs have wiped the floor clean with Gnome.
Besides Dolphin specifically, KDE in general is flexible enough that making it look and feel like MacOS is pretty easy. Gnome though? It's not particularly MacOS-y by default, and Gnome devs have naked contempt for customization, so good luck if you want to try anyway.
However, I share your suspicion that most Gnome developers do not actually use Gnome as their daily driver.