[aside] I love the the Planet Money podcast and highly recommend it. I wish more of the talking-podcasts I follow (Mixergy, Teckzing, back-to-work, stackexchange, etc) were available in 20 min chunks instead of the 60 min they all seem to favor. [/aside]
[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/04/15/135423586/when-the...
A lot of government debt is held by private entities. You're thinking about the national debt, and here is a long detailed explanation:
For more details, I recommend the blog of Bill Mitchell, especially his Debriefing 101 section: http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?cat=11
The brief answer to your question is that yes, money is always a zero-sum game, just by the definition of how accounting works. If you sum up all financial assets and liabilities over the entire world, they sum up to zero.
Now when people say that a country is indebted, what they really mean is that its government is indebted. The corresponding financial assets are owned by the private sector. It's really as simple as that.
That is why trying to pay down the government debt is such a stupid idea. All it does it attempt to force the private sector out of its financial assets. And as the communists learned the hard way, putting undue force onto the private sector against its natural behaviour usually leads to bad results.
http://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/products/prod_tbills_gla...
Debt serves an important function in modern economies as a safe place to put money. That's why this debt ceiling showdown is a problem. Investors will take their money somewhere else instead of putting it in T-bills if they think the US might default.
Trillions in debt looks ominous, but it represents the trust (and wealth) of thousands of investors.
The U.S. government is already working to cheat its debt investors by repaying them with devalued printed paper. One could argue that U.S. government debt is one of the least safe investments out there. You will get repaid, but it will be in devalued currency. That dollar you invested 5 years ago, for example, only buys about 1/3 as much oil as it did when you invested it. That is a catastrophic loss.
Even in the U.S., which is generally very responsible, government debt has been a terrible investment at times through the years. The U.S. massively devalued during the Great Depression and devalued again after World War Two. An investment in a U.S. ten-year bond in the late-1960s would have been absolutely creamed, I'm talking about losing much of the real value of your investment. That's not anyone's idea of safe.
Giving the government all your money to keep it afloat in those situations was still superior, even if the government ended up ruining the value.
http://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv/products/prod_tips_glanc...
Good point but really bad example which bring your intentions into question. Oil is in high demand, thus the price has increased. You should've picked a relatively stabler item to compare the price of.
Also, how much interest did you gain on the dollar in 5 years? An investment is not the same as putting a dollar bill in your pocket.
You could also measure against corn, or gold, or the cost of college. It's been pretty ugly for the dollar for the past 11 years, and it may get worse.
How can the average amount of debt for an individual, country and corporation all be negative?
Look into fractional reserve banking and the Federal Reserve.
How can every country be indebted? Don't mutual debts cancel each other out? How can the whole world be in debt?
Whom do they owe that money? Whom do they pay the interest? Does a government debt mean that each citizen has a debt? Does it mean the government owes that money to its citizens?
If anyone has insight in this, please enlighten me!