News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by mrtksn on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @06:25PM (#27135908)
It's a well known fact that Bitcoins are mined through renewable clean energy when over $60K and dirty coal dug by newborn baby labor when under $55K, therefore Musk did the right thing.

Cynicism aside, I was very curious if Musk can somehow push the crypto coins to be used as a currency. I guess that failed?

AFAIK manufacturing is a relatively low margin business that is sensible to price and supply fluctuations so it needs supply chain contracts for months if not years ahead which means using it as a currency that is not quickly converted to fiat must be like a huge challenge that only a financial machine building genius like Musk can solve.

Is there a data on how many cars were sold through BTC?

Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by throwaway4good on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:11PM (#27136337)
I find it shocking that only few people appear to understand why it makes no sense to talk about mining “transitioning to more sustainable energy”. Even here on hn.
Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by mrtksn on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:22PM (#27136425)
What I don't get is, why people are talking about environmental impact per transaction. Transactions or not, the computers are churning constantly to solve the useless function that would produce the hash with the most 0s in it.

It really doesn't have anything to do with transactions(the fees are only a fraction of the profits). The energy impact would be precisely correlated to the fiat price since the miners will be paying for the energy and equipment in fiat.

Transactions or not, the higher the price, the dirtier the proof of work blockchain is.

Just look at the most recent block: https://www.blockchain.com/btc/block/00000000000000000002865...

reward: 6.25BTC fees for transactions: 0.5BTC

total revenue: 6.75BTC, that is ~ $350K at the moment.

Each block is mined every 10min on average, so it is 2.1M per hour. So the total energy consumption is limited to $2.1M per hour or $1.5B per month at this price. It would be $150M if the price was $5k instead and $30B if the price goes to $1M per BTC. When that happens, 1 transaction will amount to the energy consumption of an American family for 1 year or more. At $1M per BTC, $360,000,000,000 worth of energy would be wasted per year on calculating a hash of a block that is functionally exactly the same with the same amount of transaction as the one calculated for $360, $3.6 or $0.03.

I'm sure I'm missing something like investors betting on price increases, infrastructure elasticity etc. but the correlation must be roughly like that.

Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by cesarb on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:17PM (#27136846)
People talk about environmental impact per transaction because a transaction is the "useful" part of Bitcoin (even the coins themselves do not really exist, they are actually the unspent outputs of transactions). Yes, since for now the block rewards are still much bigger than the transaction fees, the energy impact of miners is still not very correlated with the number of transactions; but you can still attribute all that cost to the "useful" work it did.

That is: the transactions did not (directly) cause that cost, but they are the "benefits" of incurring that cost. It makes sense to think about how many "benefits" you got from a given amount of costs, or inversely, how much cost there was for each unit of "benefit". To put it another way, if the costs are identical, it's better to have 1000000 transactions than just 100 transactions; "environmental impact per transaction" (or its inverse, "transactions per unit of environmental impact") captures that perfectly.

Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by ErikVandeWater on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @11:16PM (#27138026)
> To put it another way, if the costs are identical, it's better to have 1000000 transactions than just 100 transactions; "environmental impact per transaction" (or its inverse, "transactions per unit of environmental impact") captures that perfectly.

I don't think it's possible to decouple # of transactions and the price of Bitcoin though. Every additional Bitcoin transaction proves it is a feasible means of exchange, driving the price higher.

Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by somjeed on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @11:37PM (#27138117)
There are many other considerations that make a transaction possible. If you remove them, then a transaction wont have much value. For instance, security of chain's history or censorship resistance are required. These features can fall apart quickly with incentive misalignment. They are tail risks and easy to ignore until it happens
Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by throwaway4good on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:46PM (#27136618)
Agreed - it is the mining rewards that drives the environmental impact.

I think the reason people (media) talk about transactions is that blocks and mining rewards are hard to understand.

Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by jude- on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @10:33PM (#27137803)
PoW runs just fine on 100% renewable energy. That PoW pollutes at all is because society allows it. Nothing stops the EPA (and similar bodies across the world) from requiring exchanges in their jurisdiction to do taint analysis on newly-mined coins in order to determine whether or not they came from a "certified-green" miner, and if not, apply an extra carbon tax on them (or deny their sale outright).
Re:Tesla has suspended vehicle purchases using Bitcoin by throwaway4good on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @07:15PM (#27136367)
I wouldn’t be surprised if no cars were sold by Tesla via Bitcoin.

A transaction of that sorts would certainly trigger various anti-money laundering regulations where I am from (somewhere in the EU).