News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by choeger on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @06:56AM (#27116503)
This.

That move is just one step further in removing control. They now have sealed devices that can have who knows what functions but are confined to the network. Next step is to have a concealed upstream. After that they will somehow get a legal mandate to force such devices on you (like the EU did with cars). Maybe they will use smoke detectors or "emergency" services. In the end, this is exactly like in 1984.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by bregma on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:19AM (#27116651)
Less 1984 and more Fahrenheit 451. There is no central authority imposing this to exert control on the masses: consumers are imposing it on themselves willingly and industry is just giving them what they want. Juvenal redux.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by WarOnPrivacy on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:30AM (#27116742)
> consumers are imposing it on themselves willingly

Without reasonable alternative and without consent is like a LEO version of 'willing'.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by fouric on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:15PM (#27121480)
The existence of "reasonable alternatives" is largely irrelevant. Firefox is a reasonable alternative to Chrome, and yet very few of the people I tell about Chrome's tracking switch - they just don't care. Same for Protonmail/Gmail, iOS/Android, Linux/Windows (yeah, yeah, not everything runs on Windows - nobody I know will even attempt to dual-boot and do what they can on Linux), dumb/smart TVs (yes, reasonable dumb TVs exist - the Spectres, most notably). This is a willingness issue, not a lack of reasonable alternatives, in the majority (not all) of markets.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by gruez on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:53AM (#27116953)
You can buy commercial displays (ie. the ones used for signs). It's worse and more expensive, but it's still an alternative.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by ta988 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:08AM (#27117593)
This is similar to saying, if you don't want to be filmed in the street move to a private island. Doesnt solve the problem for most people. Brands don't care about the few exceptions that know their dark side. What they care about is that tens of millions don't.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by ryukafalz on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:11AM (#27117115)
TVs without smart features used to be priced like TVs still are now; the one I'm still using cost me something like $300 several years ago.

Those commercial displays are priced for businesses to afford. It's not something the average consumer is going to reasonably buy - especially not lower-income people.

(As an aside, it's fucked that the cheaper devices that low-income people can afford are always the ones with the most surveillance.)

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by dopidopHN on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:46AM (#27116893)
I never own a tv, I don’t plan to own one ever.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by WarOnPrivacy on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:49PM (#27121168)
I tossed out my OTA TV in 1992. I've never had Cable TV.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by rsfern on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:02AM (#27117038)
I don’t remember much backstory in 1984 for how the surveillance state came to be, but I think it’s totally plausible that a government could co-opt this self-imposed setup and use it for 1984-style control.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by GekkePrutser on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:10AM (#27117108)
IIRC there wasn't much backstory on how it came to be other than a war between continents.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by TchoBeer on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:25PM (#27120815)
It's 1984 and we're the proles
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by Clewza313 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:20AM (#27116664)
So armed Amazon goons kicking down your door and bringing you to the dungeons of the Ministry of Customer Obsession to be tortured with fake cattle prod knockoffs?
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by choeger on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:43AM (#27116866)
Nope. Much more like this:

You are legally obliged to install a smart meter, smart smoke detector and smart heating control in your home. If you rent, your landlord will install these things. If you own the authorities will inspect the presence and operation of these devices and fine you if you don't comply.

All these devices will be offered by companies like amazon. Coincidentally, amazon lobbyists shape the laws that make these things mandatory.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by smackeyacky on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:56AM (#27116977)
I don't think they have to make it mandatory, all they have to do is remove all the other choices. Simple to do if you have amazon or google amounts of money. Politicians are surprisingly cheap but they aren't as reliable as narrowing customer choice behind a mask of competition. Once the barrier to entry is lifted sufficiently high the job is done.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by endgame on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:09AM (#27117097)
Mandatory installation comes 3-5 years after insurance discounts for smart smoke detectors or whatever, to prod the last few hold-outs into "compliance".
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by t-writescode on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @04:55PM (#27123396)
"We find that tracking the smoke levels inside a house using the smart fire detectors gives firefighters an early warning system. For the safety of your pets and your children, who may not know how to use 911 or may not have a phone they can reach, and since you don't have a landline they can use, we are requiring all houses to be equipped with a FireProtection 2.0 capable smoke alarm."
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by smackeyacky on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @06:22PM (#27124347)
I would get worried when the FAANG companies start buying insurance businesses. Since a lot of have "smart speakers" and mobile phones listening to us and whatnot lying about our houses we installed voluntarily, lobbying for something like this seems completely unnecessary.

I really think the fears of government over-reach are something that has receded into the past. We didn't need to be forced into a surveillance society, we willingly paid for and installed it ourselves in exchange for "likes" and "upvotes" and being able to discuss big budget TV shows in real time with our fake internet friends.

Big brother turned out to be our dopamine circuits.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by userbinator on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:27AM (#27117819)
Rural life never looked so good...
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by sofixa on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:44AM (#27118034)
> You are legally obliged to install a smart meter, smart smoke detector and smart heating control in your home

If that's all they do, what's the problem here? All three have big and direct positives for everyone ( you, your home, your community) - a smart heating control saves energy ( climate catastrophe incoming, so could be useful), a smart smoke detector can alert the fire department if smoke is ongoing for more than X time, and a smart meter can be used to accurately predict, distribute, reduce and bill energy consumption. And if they all stay in their lane, there aren't many privacy downsides.

Edit: I'd appreciate a response to go with the downvotes and tell me what i'm missing

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by choeger on Friday May 14, 2021 @11:41AM (#27155428)
What you are missing is the motivation of the seller. The company is not interested in making your house a safer place and helping you living your life. Instead they want your data. And they want your data to essentially extract more money from you. This setup sees you as an obstacle that needs to be overcome and it is just a short step to sell that data to a third party. And no one, repeat: absolutely fucking no one, that collects your data clandestinely is doing this because they think you would agree with their motives. In the end, they always want to get an advantage over you.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by sofixa on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:10PM (#27213025)
And nobody is talking about a company, the whole premise was that there's a mandate to have a smart meter/smoke detector/etc.; if that were to happen, it isn't a company selling you something for their interest, it's a government telling you to get something for everyone's interest.

E.g. in France the smart electric meters are mandatory ( they don't belong to you but the utility in the first place), and are of a specific type that does nothing but collect electric consumption. I'm sure that if it were left to a private company there'd be a microphone or two just in case, but that really isn't the scenario we're talking about.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by mPReDiToR on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:55AM (#27119670)
You're missing the whole concept of choice.

Being forced into something "for your own good" is still being forced, and is anathema to some.

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by herbstein on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @03:43PM (#27122587)
And yet people are generally fine with seat belts, driver's licenses, etc. being "forced" "for your own good" in modern society.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by trompetenaccoun on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @08:55PM (#27137181)
A seat belt isn't capable of spying on you. Pretty sure people would have an issue with "smart" seatbelts that contain microphones and cameras.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by sofixa on Thursday May 13, 2021 @04:39AM (#27139864)
Which is why i explicitly qualified that the smart stuff in question should only be smart to do its job ( e.g. a smoke detector to alarm you and the fire department, not to have a microphone and camera to spy on you), like the French smart electric meters, which only report consumption to the utility ans nothing else.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by trompetenaccoun on Thursday May 13, 2021 @07:32AM (#27140934)
Except even if they can only do that, it's still possible to spy on the consumer's habits through their electricity consumption. What time do they sleep, are they really sick at home or did they they leave town, are they on holiday,...

And since they are connected to the internet, they're vulnerable to hacks, so this information could not only get into the hands of governments and energy companies, but all kinds of random people.

Btw in reality it's much worse than that. Many of the smart smoke detectors have microphones in them, which is a really smart idea. Sometimes companies even "forget" to tell the victims, er... I mean users about it: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2019/02/googles-nest-securit...

Re:Amazon Sidewalk by patentatt on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:33AM (#27117289)
Do the amazon knock off cattle prods hurt more or less than genuine ones? Like, do they just not work? Are they just bricks in boxes? Or do they instantly cause death? I’m joking, but I go through this logic each time I regrettably make an amazon purchase: what’s the knock-off failure mode. Vitamins? Heavy metal poisoning. No go. Pens? They don’t write well. Acceptable for amazon purchase.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by me_me_me on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @07:33AM (#27116778)
Time to invest in companies producing faraday's cages for houses.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by julianlam on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @08:17AM (#27117157)
You jest, but all I'm thinking about is just how unpolluted the 2.4GHz spectrum would be if everybody's house had a built-in Faraday cage, and how nice that would be...
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by BenjiWiebe on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @09:06AM (#27117577)
And as long as the faraday cage wasn't in interior walls, wifi would work really well on 2.4 inside your house, with such a nice low noise floor. You'd need it though, since cell service would be rather poor.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by qq4 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @11:30AM (#27119308)
Couldn't you have a cell antenna outside of the cage?
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by vineyardmike on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:20PM (#27121543)
My father used a foil as part of insulation and the wifi in that house is amazing.
Re:Amazon Sidewalk by amyjess on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @02:07PM (#27121409)
The fact that you can say this without being hauled off to Room 101 and tortured until you recant proves that this is in fact not exactly like 1984.