2. We don’t know the long term effects of the vaccine. But we do know the long term effects of corona viruses (not specifically COVID19, but we can infer).
3. The vaccine isn’t 100% effective as it is, so while you mitigate short term risk, long term is likely higher with the vaccine given the estimated short term protection (implying multiple / yearly vaccines necessary) and relative risk of the virus (basically 0%) vs the vaccine (2% risk of severe incident)
You can’t do this with the vaccines too? Especially in the realm of long-term-sleeper side effects?
> relative risk of the virus (basically 0%) vs the vaccine (2% risk of severe incident)
I guess the problem here is your time frame is one month, rather than years out.
By not vaccinating, you're contributing to the problem at some nonzero level. Unless you're on an island away from the world.
> The issuance of an EUA is not an FDA approval (licensure) of a vaccine.
0.4% had severe adverse events, with no pattern.
> Serious adverse events are defined as: • Death; • A life-threatening adverse event; • Inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization; • A persistent or significant incapacity or substantial disruption of the ability to conduct normal life functions; • A congenital anomaly/birth defect; • An important medical event that based on appropriate medical judgement may jeopardize the individual and may require medical or surgical intervention to prevent one of the outcomes listed above.
It would not take very many such "serious adverse events" in a trial of 1100 before I'd argue that the vaccine is not safe for children.
And yes -- for an illness that is essentially asymptomatic in children, that's a legitimate concern.
Another way of putting it: this vaccine will make at least as many children as sick as getting Covid itself.
But it was indeed the 7 days following administration, not immediately after.
I guess I don't see a headache or fever from the vaccine as the same kind of sick as Covid, so no need to pursue the conversation if we disagree on that.
As a parent, I’m ok with those odds even if my kids don’t get much direct benefit. Contributing to reduced community transmission is worth it.
As far as mild side-effects go, another way of putting it is that at least as many kids will experience side effects from the vaccine as from Covid itself.
...and millions of kids are going to get this vaccine in the coming months.
I don't think 0.4% vs. 0.1% with n=1127 is significant, and the study mentions no patterns were observed.
We still have systems like VAERS to ensure side-effects that are too rare to be caught by a study of this size still get caught.
* Redness 5.8 vs 1.1
* Swelling 6.9 vs 1
* Pain 86 vs 23
* Fever 10 vs 1
* Fatigue 60 vs 46
* Headache 55 vs 35
* Chills 28 vs 10
* Vomiting 3 vs 1
* Use of pain med 37 vs 10
Only 1100 kids in the study and only 660 of them were followed up at least 2 months after the 2nd dose. These numbers seem unreasonably low.
This means that hundreds of kids had worse reactions than the placebo. All of this to prevent 11 symptomatic cases. I couldn't find the prognosis of these 11 symptomatic cases, but its highly likely that all of them were mild. To me, it seems like the overall health and well being of the vaccinated group was less than the placebo.
VAERS forms sometimes have more wording for that category: https://medcom.uiowa.edu/theloop/covid-19-vaccination-requir...
https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavi...
(EDIT: side-effect data for 12-15yo are pages 25-27 in this: https://www.fda.gov/media/144413/download)
I have to be honest...this strikes me as poor risk analysis by the FDA. This approval is based on a study of ~1100 children over two months, of which the absolute risk reduction was ~1.6% (16 cases -> 0). However, about 2% of kids had severe reactions to the vaccine itself.
(EDIT 2: a further 0.4% had life-threatening reactions, which are labeled as "severe adverse events")
They don't report the number of severe infections, but I'm guessing that the number is zero, based on what we know about Covid in children.