Most of the phone companies were Ma Bell, which had a government-sanctioned natural monopoly from 1936 to its breakup in 1984.
If it was natural, why was a government sanction necessary?
(I realize that I answered the question "Why is regulation necessary?", but it goes along with the sanction.)
While it ultimately failed, there was a method to the madness.
Govt likes monopolies and companies like to have govt keep out competition, which is what the govt did for AT&T.
Interestingly enough, AT&T had been a govt monopoly well before 1936 and then lost that and regained it again in 1936.
AT&T loved being a monopoly.
A natural monopoly means that competitors are kept out naturally. No government intervention would be needed.
Depends. When Ireland privatized it's state owned teleco, it included all the wires going all over the country.
I think a factor in making this easier in Europe is that all phone lines were put in by entirely government owned and operated enterprises, and it can't be argued that the public doesn't own them. In the US, if I'm not mistaken, most of the phone companies were and are at least somewhat private entities that invested private money in putting in the lines. Although often protected by exclusivity etc. this makes the "public owns it" argument much more murky.