Slowing down, concentrating, and having lots of time are definitely helpful for thinking but he implies that it is sufficient for thinking and that everyone has that luxury.
What about people operating under duress like in wars or pandemics? Can epidemiologists slow down while a pandemic spreads exponentially? Can soldiers slow down while they’re being shot at?
I’m pretty sure those people would like to have the space to make better decisions but more often then not, they don’t. Those are very wicked problems.
What's there to think, either shoot back or run. OTOH planning war strategy is thinking.
> Can epidemiologists slow down while a pandemic spreads exponentially?
They have to if they have to invent the medicine. I think you are confused b/w hardwork and thinking.
Even as Engineers we know that some of the problems we come up against in the course of a project could have been foreseen and tackled if only we spent some time to deeply understand the project.
I countered with the implication that there may be more important factors than just time for those acting in time-constrained situations to make "good" decisions and that he was oversimplifying, not that we always think before we do everything.
AFAIK, most people don't eat their meals under duress. I could be wrong though.
I don't know for you but I know that when I slow down and tell myself to relax, start poking at the problem from different angles things go well. I dont know how it happens. The brian reaches a point you even continue solving the problem while sleeping. There might be hacks for that but with the right intention and time it mostly happens for me.
In real life we often have to make suboptimal decisions merely because we cannot spend much time on each one.
they are the smartest in that decision space, probably due to training in it and have made a lot of similar decisions in the past.
For most ill defined problems, it's best to accept you may be wrong, but make the best quick decision you can, and be willing to reevaluate.
It's funny that the paper author goes only into multitasking / concentration after wondering why people struggle to think critically. Sure, distracted thinking is generally not good thinking, but slowing down in and of itself won't improve your judgment skills. It's kind of a bummer that after the author says "there's a problem with critical thinking!" -- he moves on and doesn't talk about ways to actually develop critical thinking besides, you know, this 4 minute essay that just says "slow down the decision making process." I would have hoped he would have talked about different ways to analyze or prioritize problems, or discussed game theory or maybe gone into wicked problems[1].
Oh well
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicked_problem