Re:The Hume paradox: how great philosophy leads to dismal po...
by bryanrasmussen on Sunday May 09, 2021 @03:25AM
(#27093963)
>when the failure to grapple with inequality, and especially climate change,
The writing is of a quality that suggests the thinking behind it is very poor.
Re:The Hume paradox: how great philosophy leads to dismal po...
by jl2718 on Sunday May 09, 2021 @11:13AM
(#27096619)
I’m not a philosopher, but I’m sure there is a symbolic logic interpretation of this that would reveal it’s absurdity.
Something like: A is bad. B is bad. Not A does not decrease B. Therefore, not A is bad.
> The follies of a “first do no harm” approach are redoubled today, when the failure to grapple with inequality, and especially climate change, threatens the stability of the global order.
In one sentence, the idea of cautious changes is abandoned without a single argument, while it simultaneously argues for the kind of conservatism for which the author blames Hume.
That said, I totally do believe that a great philosopher is not a good statesman by definition. Our models, our theories, our thinking are not capable of encompassing the complexity of a single being, let alone a society. To change society's direction only the tiniest bit requires an entirely different skill set.