News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Thursday May 06, 2021 @10:42PM (#27071429)
College admissions in the US are messed up. There is no way for a student to be in control of their destiny through hard work, because there are far too many variables and randomness in college admissions.

Ideally what colleges should do is to use a standardized test and go strictly by the results of the standardized test. Standardized tests are not perfect, but if there are flaws in standardized tests then fix them, because it is better than the alternatives. The advantage for students would be predictability and being in control of their own destiny. Students would not have to apply to 12 to 15 colleges, instead the would apply to 2 to 3. The benefits for colleges would be better predictability as well. Today colleges use complex mathematical models to predict who is likely to accept their admission offers. Then they use "yield protection" to avoid admitting highly qualified students who are unlikely to accept admission offers. It is complicated.

Colleges can use complex data analysis to guess which students are likely to accept but hapless students can’t run data analysis to determine which colleges are likely to accept. Colleges, especially public ones, ought to minimize the guesswork and use more objective criteria to admit students. Students need to be able to control their own destiny through hard work. That’s only possible if guesswork and data analytics and so on is minimized.

Other countries such as UK use test scores for college admissions. At one time the US too used scores. But US colleges introduced subjective criteria ("holistic reviews") because far too many Jewish people were getting admitted when they used objective criteria. (Not kidding, see https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2019/03/histor... ).

Even public universities perform complex gymnastics to decide which 4.0 GPA student to admit. Even when two students have taken the exact same courses (including AP courses) and have the same GPA, colleges do not consider them the same. (See here https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-04-12/covid-co... )

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by phobosanomaly on Thursday May 06, 2021 @11:29PM (#27071808)
That really depends on what you mean by 'destiny.'

If you go to community college, work hard, and get decent grades you are more-or-less guaranteed a transfer spot at a good state school.

It's actually pretty easy to transfer from a California community college right into UCSD, UCLA, UCR, etc., and these are all excellent, affordable schools. Nowhere in that process do you have to take the SAT or the ACT. You just take college classes, and get college grades that show how you perform in college. You prove yourself by actually doing the thing the standardized test is supposed to evaluate.

I would propose that we look at tests not as the solution, but as another layer of bullshit hoops people have to jump through. Just get people bootstrapped into the damn thing at low-cost, and see how they perform. Evaluate them based on that. Being an SAT savant doesn't mean someone will actually be able to do anything meaningful in the real world.

Sure, that path may not guarantee you a spot at MIT, but if you come from a variety of backgrounds and have some humility about the whole thing you're going to be just fine and you will have more than enough control to steer your destiny in whatever direction your interests lead you.

Anecdotal, but all of my friends who make over $100k went to state schools for undergrad and grad school, and not going to Yale didn't seem to pose too much of an obstacle to them leading happy, productive, and fulfilling lives.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @12:58AM (#27072333)
> Ideally what colleges should do is to use a standardized test and go strictly by the results of the standardized test. Standardized tests are not perfect, but if there are flaws in standardized tests then fix them, because it is better than the alternatives

Standardized tests are terrible. Predicting the outcomes of standardized tests is very simple, it's a function of your parents income. https://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/08/27/sat-scores-and... With a 0.95 R^2.

Simply put, standardized tests would make sure that only rich people go to good schools.

> Other countries such as UK use test scores for college admissions. At one time the US too used scores. But US colleges introduced subjective criteria ("holistic reviews") because far too many Jewish people were getting admitted when they used objective criteria. (

No. That's not what happened. This is the history according to the National Educational Association: https://www.nea.org/advocating-for-change/new-from-nea/racis...

In the beginning, US colleges did not use standardized tests. A well-known racist who was against the "intermingling of races" created standardized tests to exclude races he did not like. And for the most part, it worked beautifully, except that too many Jews were getting in, so they added other criteria on top. The idea of standardized tests exists because of racism. It was recognized by its inventor to be a tool for racism and classism.

> Other countries such as UK use test scores for college admissions

Yeah, how's that going? Notice who gets into Oxford and Cambridge? It's not really the lower classes. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/... Only 20% of Cambridge students are eligible for a grant that takes 50% more than the median income to get. https://www.varsity.co.uk/news/16287 That means that they overwhelmingly come from families with very high income.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by usaar333 on Friday May 07, 2021 @01:34AM (#27072553)
> With a 0.95 R^2.

That's not the R^2 of your SAT based on income; that's the R^2 of average scores within an income bucket. Predictability based on income is far, far lower with other factors more significant (https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9gs5v3pv).

> The idea of standardized tests exists because of racism. It was recognized by its inventor to be a tool for racism and classism.

Huh? Prior to tests, schools were even more classist. Standardized tests have also been used in all sorts of societies historically explicitly to break class lines. i.e. the Chinese Imperial Examinations (created over 2,000 years ago) intentionally were created so that candidates were not just merely young aristocrats recommended by other aristocrats (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_examination).

And yes, the institution of holistic review (ironically, not relying as much on tests) was absolutely driven by anti-semitism. See https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2018/6/21/holistic-admiss....

Of course, neither the history of testing or holistic admissions says anything about the actual value of them today.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @01:58AM (#27072721)
> That's not the R^2 of your SAT based on income; that's the R^2 of average scores within an income bucket. Predictability based on income is far, far lower - in fact, in California at least, both student ethnicity and parental education is more predictive as far as background factors go (https://escholarship.org/uc/item/9gs5v3pv).

You write that as if you disagree with my comment, but then you go on to agree with it. Scores are highly predictable from income and factors like race. Yes. That's what makes standardized tests not just worthless, it makes them classist and racist.

> Huh? Prior to tests, schools were even more classist.

This is why tests were introduced, schools were claiming to admit people based on skill. But then the "wrong" people showed up with skills. So they introduced tests. You should read the history of testing that I linked to before, it explains this very nicely.

> Standardized tests have also been used in all sorts of societies historically explicitly to break class lines. i.e. the Chinese Imperial Examinations (created over 2,000 years ago) intentionally were created so that candidates were not just merely young aristocrats recommended by other aristocrats (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_examination).

You should totally read a book on this. I suggest "Civil examinations and meritocracy in late imperial China" by Elman. The examinations were extremely onerous and required pretty deep pockets. The exams were a way to choose among elites. Just like standardized tests today!

> Of course, neither the history of testing or holistic admissions says anything about the actual value of them today.

The fact that scores are basically a proxy for income+race does say something about their actual value today. Zero. Let's stop building on the infrastructure of racism and oppression that those who came before up put up.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Friday May 07, 2021 @10:58AM (#27076658)
> Scores are highly predictable from income and factors like race. Yes. That's what makes standardized tests not just worthless, it makes them classist and racist.

Is there some aspect of standardized tests that makes the test easier for rich white kids while making it harder for others? If so the solution is to fix the test, not eliminate the test.

It should be expected that in a nation that prides itself as the land of opportunity, there will be some correlation between wealth and the genes you were born with. Hard work is important, but it is not the only determinant. Being born smart is a factor too, right? Smarter parents beget smarter kids. If so there will be some correlation between wealth of parents and how well the kids do in tests. Blaming that on some kind of bias in standardized tests is insane.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by dragonwriter on Friday May 07, 2021 @11:33AM (#27077006)
> Is there some aspect of standardized tests that makes the test easier for rich white kids while making it harder for others?

Rich white kids are less likely to have, for one of many examples, been deliberately exposed to toxic levels of lead by action of their state government.

There are a myriad of other unequally-distributed social and environmental impacts on cognitive function and academic ability, and evaluations of standardized testing tend to control for very few of them.

Standardized testing reveals uncorrected racial and economic injustice, it isn’t the source of it. Blaming standardized testing is a way of avoiding addressing the problems it reveals.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by adrianN on Monday May 10, 2021 @09:25AM (#27105720)
Rich kids who have quiet rooms and can afford tutors have it easier than poor kids who have to share their room with siblings and can't afford tutors.
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by tester34 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:19AM (#27106926)
>Rich kids who have quiet rooms and can afford tutors

I do agree that this is advantage, but nowadays there's internet and you can have cheap as fuck access to very good materials

Been there, did that.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by tester34 on Friday May 07, 2021 @04:14AM (#27073584)
>Scores are highly predictable from income and factors like race. Yes. That's what makes standardized tests not just worthless, it makes them classist and racist.

Saying that "standarized test" is racist is some joke?

What's your alternative then?

>The fact that scores are basically a proxy for income+race does say something about their actual value today. Zero. Let's stop building on the infrastructure of racism and oppression that those who came before up put up.

Skew the odds then?

A lot of people do that, but it requires putting effort which in majority of the cases is what people lack - determination, desire and other.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @10:51AM (#27076561)
> Saying that "standarized test" is racist is some joke?

A joke? It's deadly serious. Standardized tests help entrench racist ideas and keep the poor out of good opportunities.

> What's your alternative then?

Simple. If universities want government funding they must admit classes that accurately represent the socioeconomic conditions of the wider population. 1% of the class can be in the top 1% of the income bracket. If a university doesn't like this, that's fine, they can go their own way. They get 0 federal dollars and no federal backing for student loans that go there.

Let colleges figure this out. They're smart. You need to solve problems at the output level, what society you want. And we can all agree that the society we want is one where your skin color doesn't determine your fate.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by tester34 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:05AM (#27106718)
>A joke? It's deadly serious. Standardized tests help entrench racist ideas and keep the poor out of good opportunities.

With Internet access I think you can overcome shitton, at least when it comes to english, math and similar like physics, computer science

Unless you're literally taking about poorest of the poorest who cannot even access internet.

>Simple. If universities want government funding they must admit classes that accurately represent the socioeconomic conditions of the wider population. 1% of the class can be in the top 1% of the income bracket. If a university doesn't like this, that's fine, they can go their own way. They get 0 federal dollars and no federal backing for student loans that go there.

I don't see it working in practice.

Even when there are standarized tests there is significant gap between top and bottom students, with your approach the gap will be even wider, thus it will decrease quality of classes unless you change system even more

and I guess that's what you want to do - change system even more.

So, how would you pick students?

let's say that 500 students that sit at top 50% income applied, how will you decide which will be accepted?

Also

What will happen to those top performing students that will not be accepted due to them being at top $$$?

Rejecting them in long run will cause your whole nation

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Friday May 07, 2021 @11:04AM (#27076717)
> If universities want government funding they must admit classes that accurately represent the socioeconomic conditions of the wider population. 1% of the class can be in the top 1% of the income bracket.

That's insane. They are in the top 1% because of being smarter and because of hard work (especially in the US, where they are more likely to have made their wealth on their own than inherited it). Their children are likely to inherit some of these traits. Limiting the number of smart & hard working kids in universities will lead to a dumber nation.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @11:36AM (#27077037)
> They are in the top 1% because of being smarter and because of hard work (especially in the US, where they are more likely to have made their wealth on their own than inherited it). Their children are likely to inherit some of these traits.

That is literally what racism is! White people mostly make up the top 1%, so we should give them more opportunities because they're in the top 1% because you think they're genetically superior? What you wrote is exactly how all of this insanity of scientific and rational racism started in the 1800s. How we ended up with standardized tests, IQ tests, phrenology, and eventually with Hitler and Stalin exterminating inferior people.

If you adopt your view, then you end up with a strictly racist and classist society. People at the top get their kids into the best schools because they have money and connections, those schools provide the best education and the best social connections, and the cycle continues forever.

No. The children of people in the top 1% are not predestined to be genetically superior. They are not some sort of ruling race. They are just people who happened to have been born to rich people.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Friday May 07, 2021 @12:06PM (#27077356)
> That is literally what racism is!

No, it is the opposite of racism. Racism is when some people are treated differently just because of their race. When you do well because you're smarter and work harder, regardless of race, then that's the opposite of racism.

> White people mostly make up the top 1%, so we should give them more opportunities because they're in the top 1% because you think they're genetically superior?

You are putting words in my mouth.

> The children of people in the top 1% are not predestined to be genetically superior.

Your argument is with Charles Darwin, not me!

If the goal is to help people in lower socio-economic brackets, then the best way to do that is to make college free, not eliminate standardized tests. I see too many deserving students accepted into good colleges decide that they can't go because they can't afford it.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @05:40PM (#27081159)
> No, it is the opposite of racism. Racism is when some people are treated differently just because of their race. When you do well because you're smarter and work harder, regardless of race, then that's the opposite of racism.

No.. when you say that the children of people in the top 1% who are overwhelmingly of one race should be given disproportionate opportunities because of some genetic factor, that is racism. It is literally saying "people of this race should be given more stuff"

> You are putting words in my mouth.

I am not. I repeated what you said. You said that the children of the 1% are somehow genetically superior. I pointed out that the 1% is overwhelmingly white. And I wrote down your beliefs. That white people are genetically superior.

That is the simple logical consequence of your beliefs. And it a chain of reasoning we have already followed right into slavery and concentration camps as a species. One that we should not follow again.

> Your argument is with Charles Darwin, not me!

Look back on that chain of inferences and think to yourself where you went wrong, how did your thoughts, that you consider innocent, lead to an extremely racist conclusion.

There are only two outcomes possible. Either you look at your chain of reasoning and its simple plain outcome "white people are genetically superior" which you seem to believe in, and you feel ok with that. In which case this is just plain racism. Or you look at it and realize that no there is something deeply wrong here. And you will find that the idea that your parents are wealthy somehow meaning that their children are genetically superior is bankrupt.

Your choice. Racism or changing your thought process.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Saturday May 08, 2021 @11:30AM (#27088011)
> No.. when you say that the children of people in the top 1% who are overwhelmingly of one race should be given disproportionate opportunities because of some genetic factor, that is racism.

All I am saying is that if people who are in the top 1% got there because of being smarter and being willing to work hard, then to the extend these traits are heritable you should expect their children to have these traits as well. Such kids can be expected to do well in school. Should they be given disproportionate opportunities? Absolutely not. But if they do well in school do not assume that's because they have been given disproportionate opportunities!

> I pointed out that the 1% is overwhelmingly white. And I wrote down your beliefs. That white people are genetically superior.

Nonsense. I am not white, and I do not believe white people are genetically superior. I am Asian.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Saturday May 08, 2021 @07:04PM (#27091613)
> All I am saying is that if people who are in the top 1% got there because of being smarter and being willing to work hard, then to the extend these traits are heritable you should expect their children to have these traits as well.

And that is literally racism. The idea that the groups that are in power are there for a generic reason. It's precisely what people in the 1800s said. It's literally what fuels Nazis and the KKK.

All you are saying is something blatantly racist. I have no idea what else you want to me say to you?

If you want to sit here and defend racism then I'm out. But I hope you can live with yourself every morning that you can read Mein Kampf and recognize yourself.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Saturday May 08, 2021 @09:15PM (#27092307)
Good luck to you man!
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by tester34 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:09AM (#27106757)
>No. The children of people in the top 1% are not predestined to be genetically superior. They are not some sort of ruling race. They are just people who happened to have been born to rich people.

You act as if parents just paid some money and people could score anything they want on standarized tests.

It requires shitton of effort to score top 1%.

I knew people who if could, then would buy themselves $top_score easily, but on standarized tests they didnt/barely passed.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by usaar333 on Friday May 07, 2021 @02:21AM (#27072869)
> it makes them classist and racist.

What do you mean by these terms? I'd argue that they only are if the results, conditional on future college performance, are biased by class or race. Are they? The article you linked doesn't say.

> The exams were a way to choose among elites. Just like standardized tests today!

What percent of students scoring over a 1500 on the SAT are from the top 1% of household earners? I doubt it is not a minority. There's obviously an income correlation, but it's far better than simply taking rich kids.

How do you propose selecting students?

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by light_hue_1 on Friday May 07, 2021 @10:56AM (#27076627)
> What do you mean by these terms?

By racist and classist? That an identical child, who happens to be born poor or who happens to be born with a darker skin color, will have fewer opportunities and worse life outcomes.

That's literally what a racist society is. Where your skin color plays a large role in your fate.

> How do you propose selecting students?

Simple. We start with the society we want. One that is not racist and not classist. In other words, your skin color and the income of your parents should not play an overwhelming role in your life outcomes.

We tell universities that if they want any federal funding they must admit classes that accurately reflect US demographics. 1% of the incoming class is from the top 1% of earners. Same for socioeconomic status. Colleges can do whatever they want, if they don't like the deal, that's fine, but they get no federal funding and they get no federally-backed student loans.

You start with the outcomes you believe are just. And you set up incentives to get that outcome. That's literally what we do everywhere else. We tell car manufacturers that they need to make cars that have fewer emissions, we don't tell them how. They figure it out. Universities will figure out how to make this happen, they're full of smart people.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by usaar333 on Friday May 07, 2021 @12:18PM (#27077526)
> who happens to be born poor

Yes, that's troublesome, but it is inherently impossible to solve this. Less poor parents generally educate their children better (or at least keep their children in better environments), so this is difficult if not impossible to correct. I ensure my preschooler does her reading lessons every night - poorer parents (on average) don't. How are you supposed to correct for this?

> or who happens to be born with a darker skin color

Huh? Are you in tech? If anything, the "darker" kids were performing better at the schools I attended growing up (in the Bay Area).

> We tell universities that if they want any federal funding they must admit classes that accurately reflect US demographics. 1% of the incoming class is from the top 1% of earners. Same for socioeconomic status.

Well, demographics is a bit arbitrary, so the only way to do this across whatever you are trying to measure is to run a US-wide lottery for every school.

This would functionally kill the concept of universities as tracked systems and I imagine it would be strictly better for all of the top schools to simply forgo federal funding to preserve their very purpose.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Friday May 07, 2021 @11:09AM (#27076765)
> That an identical child, who happens to be born poor or who happens to be born with a darker skin color, will have fewer opportunities and worse life outcomes.

Yes, your appearance does have an impact on life outcomes, that much is true. But standardized tests are not to blame. In fact, standardized tests are the solution, because the test doesn't know what you look like.

> 1% of the incoming class is from the top 1% of earners.

If the 1% of earners are in the 1% because of being smart and because of being hard working, and the children inherit these traits, why punish the children for that?

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by tester34 on Monday May 10, 2021 @11:22AM (#27106981)
>Simple. We start with the society we want. One that is not racist and not classist. In other words, your skin color and the income of your parents should not play an overwhelming role in your life outcomes.

How about your look, height, voice and so on?

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by naveen99 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:58AM (#27114709)
Should mbti types be represented in university equally 1/16, or proportionally to their demographics in the usa ? What about in engineering ? Should mbti types be equally represented in all professions?
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by naveen99 on Tuesday May 11, 2021 @01:40AM (#27114593)
and should the us let immigrants in that match the current us demographic or the global demographic ? If global demographic, then eventually the us will be similar to the global demographic. If not, what point in time should the us demographic be frozen ? What about remote workers, should they have the us demographic or the global demographic?
Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by esyir on Friday May 07, 2021 @06:42AM (#27074451)
Well standardised tests seem to do badly at that, seeing that they're deliberately tweaking cutoffs to hinder certain groups. And reducing its wishes to exclude them.

Turns out discrimination doesn't apply to Asians, as far as universities go.

Re:How college became a ruthless competition divorced from l... by flowerlad on Friday May 07, 2021 @10:41AM (#27076433)
> Standardized tests are terrible. Predicting the outcomes of standardized tests is very simple, it's a function of your parents income.

Correlation is not causation. See Skirt Length Theory https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/skirtlengththeory.asp