News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:48PM (#27042053)
Missing the point. These things are supposed to exist for pure marketing blitz, it doesn't matter if they're actually decenteralized or even outright fraudulent.

It just has to help bring in enough new suckers to allow the recipients of ethereum's huge pre-mine (now valued at about one quarter trillion dollars) to exit more of their positions without collapsing the price.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by chrisco255 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:58PM (#27042173)
No one person controls more than 1% of ETH supply. Satoshi still owns 1M BTC, or 5% of all BTC and it's said that the Winklevoss twins control about 1% of BTC supply.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:05PM (#27042238)
We don't actually know much about who controls the eth supply. Their pre-mine recipients were mostly anonymous and with the fast majority going to a few addresses. For all you know they recycled received funds back out in their crowd sale and bought multiple times.

Participation was limited because US residents-- by far the largest population of cryptocurrency users-- were prohibited from participating (though of course some did). [Edit: A comment below claims otherwise, I don't actually see support for that in my source, and my own correspondence from the time states that it wasn't. I'm not sure if something changed around the launch, or if I'm somehow mistaken.]

I dunno anything about winklevoss speculation, people often include funds held in custody as if they're owned by the custodian and reach weird conclusions. It's easy to list ethereum accounts that hold >=1% of all ethereum: 0x281055afc982d96fab65b3a49cac8b878184cb16, 0x6f46cf5569aefa1acc1009290c8e043747172d89, 0x90e63c3d53e0ea496845b7a03ec7548b70014a91, 0x53d284357ec70ce289d6d64134dfac8e511c8a3d, 0xab7c74abc0c4d48d1bdad5dcb26153fc8780f83e, 0xfe9e8709d3215310075d67e3ed32a380ccf451c8; while the largest Bitcoin address is under 1%. (Of course, parties can have multiple addresses, and as mentioned some parties hold coins for many other people)

Moreover, regardless of the distribution Bitcoin had no premine: Everyone who has Bitcoin received it in a open process available to the whole world with no particular privilege other than knowing and caring about it when it was almost worthless before other people did. (well, I suppose except for those people who stole theirs :)).

We don't actually know how many Bitcoin Satoshi-- if he's still alive-- owns: there are guesses based on assuming various earlier miners might have been him, but they're guesses. The 1M claim specifically is flat out false: it comes from counting up every coin mined during the first year that was still on spent at the time the figure started circulating a few years ago. It includes many coins known to have been mined by other people, including likely myself.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nocommentguy on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:30PM (#27042512)
Hi Greg,

> For all you know they recycled received funds back out in their crowd sale and bought multiple times.

Actually we know that they didn’t and so do you, because the funds didn’t leave the multisig until the sale ended

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:33PM (#27042546)
Turns out that money is fungible. The moment the crowdsale ended the CEO paid himself out a million dollars and left. ...
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:41PM (#27042636)
Do you have a source for this claim?
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by DennisP on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:10PM (#27042300)
U.S. residents were not prohibited. Here's the official announcement saying so:

https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/22/launching-the-ether-sal...

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by seigando on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:10PM (#27042298)
Wow. that puts him in the top 30 richest people on earth...according to https://www.forbes.com/real-time-billionaires/#233e45c53d78 which i randomly googled.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:55PM (#27042136)
Ethereum's pre-mine is worth more than half of ETH's market cap?
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by yaa_minu on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:59PM (#27042176)
Yes, 70% premine. Absolutely unethical
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by DennisP on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:08PM (#27042282)
Only a small portion went to the early devs, and an equal amount to the nonprofit foundation. The rest of that 70% went to the presale, which was open to anyone and well-advertised. First-year bitcoiners had a way bigger advantage than ETH presale buyers.

https://blog.ethereum.org/2014/07/22/launching-the-ether-sal...

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by Tenoke on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:30PM (#27042502)
In all fairness, a presale effectively means it went to them and then they sold it for money at the earliest price.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by DennisP on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:46PM (#27042678)
The bitcoins that people paid went to the nonprofit foundation, not to individuals. The foundation paid people salaries in exchange for work, and is still funding Ethereum development today.

I.e. it was a crowdsale raising funds for development, much like projects on Indiegogo except that it was a nonprofit instead of a business.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by knowaveragejoe on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:01PM (#27042195)
How does one learn this information? Do you have a link?
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by DennisP on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:16PM (#27042356)
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:40PM (#27042628)
"We are not blocking the US after all. Yay."

I hope you can see why many people believed the US was prohibited.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by DennisP on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:55PM (#27042776)
Yes, if they weren't paying attention.

There was serious concern that the Ethereum Foundation would get in trouble with the SEC if they sold in the US. They delayed the crowdsale for several months while they consulted lawyers, who finally signed off on a way to keep them out of SEC trouble. There was a lot of discussion about this in the community.

The presale was open for 42 days and very well known in the crypto community. Within the first few days it was clear that it was going to be one of the largest crowdsales to date, so it got regular media attention too.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nocommentguy on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:19PM (#27042397)
Describing a public crowdsale as a premine is unethical.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:32PM (#27042525)
Something doesn't stop being a premine once you sell it.

Once they've finished selling their premine to the public would it be accurate to say it wasn't premined at all? Of course not. So it's not accurate to exclude the partially sold portion now.

This massive understatement of their premine is a well known example of the dishonesty of ethereums operators and advocates.

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by tromp on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:35AM (#27047180)
Exactly. Selling a premine to "the public" is indistinguishable from selling only a fraction to the public, and the rest to yourself. While there is an opportunity cost to the latter, it may also serve to create an impression of large demand that further benefits the preminer.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by miohtama on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @06:12PM (#27043511)
I did a thread on the evolution of cryptocurrencies today. I cover the term “premine.” Your arguments do not make sense.

https://mobile.twitter.com/moo9000/status/138957146600232551...

Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by anotha1 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @03:53PM (#27042113)
I hope your wrong, for the sake of all the folks that invested in this.
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nocommentguy on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:29PM (#27042499)
Thank you for looking out for my financial well-being, internet stranger
[dead]
Re:D(?)A(?)O – Decentralization and Autonomy in “DAOs” by nullc on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:34PM (#27042551)
I've never spoken to anyone at AXA as far as I know, FWIW. Of course, the rest of your smearing is similarly nonsense.