Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by MikeUt on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:29PM
(#27039412)
> Does the artist not have a right to decide whether to license that?
They shouldn't have that right. No, let me re-phrase that - others shouldn't be deprived of their right to enjoy works of art, at the whim of the copyright holder.
Copyright's justification is the promotion of "science and the useful arts", not putting copyright holders in the position of censors on who may enjoy which works.
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by klyrs on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:47PM
(#27039635)
Are you also in favor of providing musicians (and actors, writers, producers, etc) a lifestyle where they have the freedom to create, and give away their work for free, without going hungry? Where is that money going to come from?
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by MikeUt on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:52PM
(#27039685)
I am okay with the compromise that one must pay for copyrighted works. But if you're not given the option to pay (a reasonable amount), copyright should not prevent you from enjoy that work.
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by terrywilcox on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @02:54PM
(#27041387)
Who decides what is a reasonable amount?
In the real world, that's called "negotiation".
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by etrabroline on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:31PM
(#27042517)
Apple decided that all songs sold on iTunes for about a decade would cost exactly 99 cents. The music industry did not collapse. Almost all full size major video game releases have cost $60 for two decades and that industry has grown tremendously. The statutory maximum price could be significantly higher than what is typical to prevent works from being unobtainable without interfering with price negotiations of most works.
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by MikeUt on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:29PM
(#27042497)
That's orthogonal to my point. I only added the reasonable amount requirement because otherwise the change in law is useless - if you don't want to license to someone, just charge a billion dollars.
But to answer your question, a court would decide, based on comparable deals, and with ample (but not infinite) latitude for the rightsholder to deviate from established prices.
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by gowld on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:30PM
(#27039414)
Music already has compulsory licensing.
Re:Why Don’t Some TV Shows Sound the Way They Used To?
by phone8675309 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:35PM
(#27039473)
The only compulsory licensing for public performance of music in the US is if the work is represented by ASCAP, BMI, or SESAC, according to Wikipedia[0].
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_license#United_Stat...
That's not what the article was about, as I understand it; the music concerned is generally still being distributed in its own right, but the show's license was for a limited period (and/or distribution channel).
> we could just move to a mandatory licensing regime
I'm not sure a mandatory licensing regime would be a good answer for anything; or at least it could be really hard to design one.
Suppose the next populist presidential candidate wants to use some popular artist's latest song at rallies. Does the artist not have a right to decide whether to license that?
Suppose Pornhub wants to license Disney's content, to stream alongside the other material they provide. Shouldn't Disney have a say in whether to allow that or not?