News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nullc on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:52AM (#27022032)
That is simply untrue. I think there is only one regular contributor to Bitcoin that is affiliated with blockstream, and meanwhile you can't name one contributor who left.

[Perhaps you think you'd name Gavin Andresen? but he had stopped contributing years before blockstream even existed. ... and left the space entirely after an infamous incident where he vocally endorsed a pretty obvious scammer.]

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nodja on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:01AM (#27022385)
Gavin Andresen and Mike Hearn are the big ones yeah. Sure they left before the 2018 drama but they did leave due to block size disagreements. But that's not here nor there.

The developers that left bitcoin aren't the developers putting commits on the protocol implementation. It's the developers that made tools on top of bitcoin itself. From not so legitimate sites like betting sites to sites and apps like openbazaar, retailers/payments processors, etc. After the 2018 debacle and the ever growing mempool/fee market most developers put bitcoin in legacy mode and started adopting other more frictionless coins like ethereum, bcash, litecoin, etc.

I have a multireddit setup that has the big crypto subreddits inside (r/btc, r/bitcoin, r/bitcoincash, r/ethereum, r/monero), I check it once or twice a week when I'm bored, and I barely hear anything new coming from the bitcoin camp, no development discussion, no cool new service, no adoption talk. It's all HODL memes, value talk and the occasional lightning network update. I don't see development talk among the bitcoin community anymore.

I'll repeat what I said, the developers that cared about bitcoin have left, the only people left that have a saying are people building layer 2 solutions (blockstream mostly) and miners. This upgrade doesn't affect miners, so I doubt they will contest.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nullc on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:15AM (#27022458)
> due to block size disagreements

There were no block size disagreements going on when gavin wound down his involvement-- but now you've moved from "blockstream" to block size disagreements.

Regardless of the history, -- bullet dodged there considering what eventually happened.

> Mike Hearn are the big ones yeah

The sum total of hearn's contributions to Bitcoin core were a dozen commits which were mostly one line string changes. To have left he would have had to have started rather than a couple drive-by tweaks.

https://web.archive.org/web/20170809023814if_/http://s12.pos...

> the developers that cared about bitcoin have left

Just repeating it doesn't make it true. Pretty ironic to say you rarely "hear anything new coming from the bitcoin camp, no development discussion" on a thread exactly about such a thing.

I dunno what if it's you or I that inhabit a weird alternative reality, but one of us does because there is constant exciting Bitcoin news... and sure, a lot of memes too, they're often pretty funny even if a bit much. But over time the character of the news will become different as Bitcoin becomes more ubiquitous.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by ur-whale on Monday May 03, 2021 @04:26AM (#27022779)
> exciting Bitcoin news

I think you're being disingenuous.

We're talking about the speed and volume of new tech being added to the Bitcoin ecosystem, not just about the fact that one such feature is (trying) to be added.

The reality is: if you compare the speed at which and the amount of new stuff being built in and atop the ethereum ecosystem to the innovation in the Bitcoin ecosystem, the difference is absolutely striking.

And BTW, IIRC, Vitalik walked away from Bitcoin and went on to create ETH for exactly the reasons outlined by the GP: a power grab by a small clique of fanatics that led to stagnation.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nullc on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:12AM (#27023008)
> And BTW, IIRC, Vitalik walked away from Bitcoin and went on to create ETH for exactly the reasons outlined by the GP:

You've been fed a marketing pitch that doesn't have a lot to do with reality. The only 'bitcoin development' Vitalik did before creating eth was running an investment scam for developing "quantum miners" -- no joke.

What you were led to believe here is simply false, a convenient excuse for an embarrassingly massive premine.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by dmaharding on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:06AM (#27022970)
> The reality is: if you compare the speed at which and the amount of new stuff being built in and atop the ethereum ecosystem to the innovation in the Bitcoin ecosystem, the difference is absolutely striking.

Here's a list of technical developments related to Bitcoin (including LN) grouped by month and topic as covered by a single publication over the past three years: https://bitcoinops.org/en/topic-dates/

I'd be interested in seeing a similar such list for Ethereum or any other cryptocurrency that shows a similar pace of development.

Edit: removed paragraph based on accidental misattribution.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nodja on Monday May 03, 2021 @06:32AM (#27023417)
> I'd be interested in seeing a similar such list for Ethereum or any other cryptocurrency that shows a similar pace of development.

I can't seem to find one for ethereum, the closest probably would be going through their blog entries and filtering by "research and development". https://blog.ethereum.org/category/research-and-development/

I did find a similar list for bitcoin cash: https://cash.coin.dance/development

Note that both lists are a bit deceitful because they include proposals not yet included/implemented. The bitcoinops list also seems to double entries if you don't sort them alphabetical, so take that into consideration if just comparing pure amount of features.

Also the coin.dance list does not list layer2/sidechain implementations. Stuff like SmartBCH would probably over inflate such a list, it would also be unfair because SmartBCH is based on work the ethereum devs did (EVM/web3).

Both lists seem to start around the same date so I'd say they're comparable.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nootropicat on Monday May 03, 2021 @08:51AM (#27024379)
Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by ur-whale on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:20AM (#27023052)
> Your earlier post seemed to indicate that you only scan "the big crypto subreddits"

Nice and well-formed ad hominem, but before proceeding, I'd suggest re-reading the name of the user that made the claim about crypto sub-reddits.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by nullc on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:23AM (#27023076)
Okay, so he's mistaken about the author of the comment but how is

> Your earlier post seemed to indicate that you only scan "the big crypto subreddits" for news; may I suggest that maybe popular subreddits aren't the best place for news about research and development.

In any way an ad hominem? Check out his link, it stands on its own.

If you're surprised about that level of activity it might just be that you're not reading the places where that sort of thing is discussed. But there is nothing bad or insulting about that suggestion.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by ur-whale on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:22AM (#27023697)
Neither he or you have any idea where I gather information on cryptos.

You are both essentially speculating and accusing me of being ill-informed without providing a shred of evidence.

[EDIT]: And even if you were correct, you're both attacking the messenger and not the message. That pretty much fits my definition of an ad-hominem.

I claim (I might be wrong, please provide counter-evidence) that there is more innovation in the Ethereum ecosystem than in the Bitcoin ecosystem.

As proof, I offer, however misguided these efforts might be (you can't innovate if you don't try "silly" things), sorted by more to less silly:

    - cryptokitties

    - NFTs

    - DeFi

    - scalability via layer 2 solutions

    - scalability via sharding

    - actually working smart contracts instead of a vague promise of their eventual feasibility based on a yet-to-be-deployed piece of infrastructure

    - a concerted effort to move to PoS

    - ongoing work on integrating ZK (zcash, beam, grin, monero)-type transactions.
Many of these things don't seem to have an equivalent in the Bitcoin space (except L2 scaling).

The list provided by the GP (https://bitcoinops.org/en/topic-dates/) IMO very much falls in the "polishing the turd" category: many tiny improvements that very few people care about and show the disconnect between Bitcoin development and what the market wants.

The fact is : ethereum is here, it has real smart contract, it is well on its way to have PoS, and it's slowly gaining market shares over Bitcoin because they move faster.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a big fan of Bitcoin and its ecosystem, but the pace at which innovation occurs in there is probably my number one peeve about it: if Bitcoin doesn't get its act together it will get the rug pulled from under it by Ethereum.

Re:Bitcoin Core: Bitcoin Core 0.21.1 released with Taproot a... by keymone on Monday May 03, 2021 @08:53AM (#27024403)
> - cryptokitties

colored coins existed on bitcoin before ethereum was a thing

> NFTs

colored coins existed on bitcoin before ethereum was a thing

> DeFi

meaningless buzzword that vaguely gestures at scripting possibilities, which again, were in bitcoin before ethereum was a thing

> scalability via layer 2 solutions

was on bitcoin before ethereum was a thing

> scalability via sharding

not a thing for at least few years and will be either a spectacular failure or multiple separate chains with atomic swaps between them

> actually working smart contracts instead of a vague promise of their eventual feasibility based on a yet-to-be-deployed piece of infrastructure

smart contracts were a thing on bitcoin before ethereum existed

> a concerted effort to move to PoS

a gigantic failure that undermines security of ethereum and market will not be merciful

> ongoing work on integrating ZK (zcash, beam, grin, monero)-type transactions.

happened on non-ethereum ecosystem

there's really not a lot to be excited about ethereum these days. years and years of promises of global scalable computer, finally an admission that it was all a giant lie and now again years and years of promises of ethereum 2.0 that will not actually for real be global scalable computer, except there's no proposed solutions for any problems because it's easier to part fools from their money with empty promises than with serious discussion about tradeoffs.