What could go wrong I guess. Are there distinct advantages to this?
This softfork also provides the necessary tools to make pay-join economically advantageous.
It improves fungibility (if that's even a word).
nullc seems to be saying that revealing (part of) the script isn’t necessary in case of cooperation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27023391
Am I misunderstanding you or nullc?
The root pubkey could be an N of N of parties to the transaction (e.g. everyone cooperates), or any other condition you can express with pubkeys alone.
So say that you have a coin that can be spent by 2 of 3 Alice, Bob, Charlie or it can be spent by Alice alone after one year has passed. The A/B/C 2of3 could be made the root, it would look like a single pubkey, and be indistinguishable from a ordinary single key wallet.
The timeout+alice condition would only get revealed in the even that Bob or Charlie will cooperate and the timeout gets used.