Don’t get me wrong, there’s some good places up here for other aspects of Mexican and Mexican adjacent food, but I dearly miss San Diego style burritos and haven’t found a replacement.
As for the other criteria. You say it's achievable but I challenge you to find a place in SF. I seriously was on a four year quest to find such a place. There are a few places that come close on like two or three criteria - EBX on divis and chandos in... Sacramento, come close, (except for the foil, which is universal), but otherwise it's just not as good.
If you have to ask, etc...
Somewhat more seriously, I think an aspect of California food is that it's highly regional and it ends up being a bit of a fool's errand expecting it to be replicated precisely out-of-region.
It's bizarre you can't get a structurally integral burrito south of San Jose, never mind Weehawken, and I'm equally bewildered, as an adoptive Northern Californian, that foil could possibly be such a point of contention.
The only possible advantage to foil is that if you don't eat it all it's marginally easier to take home.
I can only assume that San Diegans take their burritos home far too sober. Surely that can't be true. We have to get to the bottom of this.
The answer to your question is, you can't get what you're looking for in SF, but if you're willing to drive for nearly an hour, you will find the burrito of your dreams at Adalberto's in Fairfield.
Go for the real thing - tacos. Forget burritos. They’re universally subpar.
Key differentiators:
- no fillers (no rice, no beans; beans acceptable in breakfast burritos)
- generous portions of meats
- chicken that is finished by grilling on the grill, not ropa-style pulled straight out of a dewey plastic bin
- wrap that is toasted
- wax paper wrap instead of foil (lets the burrito breathe instead of becoming damp and gooey). Also avoids the danger of accidentally biting into the foil and getting that delicious aluminium flavor.
- salsa roja cremosa