News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google's War on Nonsense by Alex3917 on Monday June 27, 2011 @10:29AM (#2701402)
Fairly ironic considering this entire article was basically rewritten in twenty minutes from two or three original blog posts, so that the NY Times could run ads against their own version. This entire article adds exactly nothing to the originals.

And what's more, whenever I check my RSS feed from the NYT I regularly see entries like this:

>The 6th Floor: Sentence of the Week

"Five diverse candidates this week."

It seems like the NYT is just trying to distract Google from the fact that 90% of their own content is not much better than the content farmed stuff they're criticizing.

Re:Google's War on Nonsense by scott_s on Monday June 27, 2011 @03:24PM (#2702614)
I find your characterization inaccurate. What this author did was tie together a blog post from a week ago with Google's recent algorithm changes. The piece she quoted was an example of the sort of thing Google is trying to combat. What she adds is this connection. Readers of HN probably don't need these dots connected for us. But most readers of the NY Times probably do, since most of them do not have the experience and understanding of the web that most HN readers do. This is the sort of thing newspapers have done for as long as they've been around.

I find your claim that 90% of the content on the NY Times is "not much better than the content farmed stuff" absurd. Most of the writing on the NY Times has a clear voice and purpose, and much of it is original.

Re:Google's War on Nonsense by Alex3917 on Monday June 27, 2011 @03:59PM (#2702764)
"I find your claim that 90% of the content on the NY Times is 'not much better than the content farmed stuff' absurd. Most of the writing on the NY Times has a clear voice and purpose, and much of it is original."

Even their so-called original writing often isn't original at all. Just look at their article on Choquequirao from this week, which took up half of the travel section:

http://travel.nytimes.com/2011/06/26/travel/in-peru-machu-pi...

Seem at all familiar? Probably because it's practically a word-for-word rewrite of this article from 2007, with a couple paragraphs from various other articles thrown in for good measure:

http://travel.nytimes.com/2007/06/03/travel/03inca.html

Re:Google's War on Nonsense by scott_s on Monday June 27, 2011 @04:09PM (#2702813)
I think that one instance of the NY Times publishing a rewrite of their own travel article from four years ago is hardly damning. Compare this to, say, the front page, which links directly to 100+ original, recent articles and even 4 video features. In this context, I consider comparing the NY Times to a content farm absurd.
Re:Google's War on Nonsense by spacemanaki on Monday June 27, 2011 @02:59PM (#2702518)
I don't think that's really fair. It's true that the NYT website is in the same fundamental business as content farms, that is using content to attract pageviews (forgetting the pay wall for a minute), but much more than 10% of the NYT is very high quality, compared to content farms. Sure, there's fluffy stuff printed every day, but there's also the kind of journalism and writing that you can't buy at .9c/word.

In this case, just look at the links to other Opinionator blogs on the right hand side of the linked article, for examples of stuff you won't find in any content farm.

  * a five parts series on early computer scientists
  * a post about a composer and musician growing up
  * Stephen Strogatz's long (and excellent) series on math aimed at non-math people
  * something about philosophy and rational choice that  was dense enough that I couldn't skim quickly enough to summarize
Plus, I don't see ads on any of these pages. Are other people being served ads on the original article?

edited for formatting

edited again: in another browser, I see that this page does indeed have ads, so I was wrong about that.

Re:Google's War on Nonsense by nhebb on Monday June 27, 2011 @10:37AM (#2701436)
... especially when you consider that the New York Times owns about.com.
Re:Google's War on Nonsense by AlisdairO on Monday June 27, 2011 @10:49AM (#2701476)
in fairness, I regularly find information that's actually useful to me on about.com. Not the highest quality site, but I certainly wouldn't rank it with the demand medias of this world.
Re:Google's War on Nonsense by nhebb on Monday June 27, 2011 @12:00PM (#2701778)
In fairness, you are right. I've found a few helpful pages on about.com. (I've found a lot more unhelpful ones, though.) And even Demand Media has shining moments. Thanks to eHow, I was able to fix a jammed disposal last month.
Re:Google's War on Nonsense by paganel on Monday June 27, 2011 @04:15PM (#2702842)
> New York Times owns about.com.

Wait, what?! Fuck, I hate that website. I was once searching for something like "Chernobyl cancer statistics" or something similar and, sure enough, about.com was there in the top 10 for that search. And that was after update Panda. At this point I've started to give up, I'm just adding "wiki" in almost all of my searches, hoping that Wikipedia has something smart/accurate to say about the subject I'm interested in.