News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by _jal on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:09PM (#26999372)
Any employer that abruptly told me I needed to watch what I said at work would lose me, too.

I'm not saying I demand the ability to be rude and awful, or go on political tirades, or anything even vaguely like that. But I spend more time talking to people I work with than any other set of people.

Telling me I have to avoid entire categories of normal conversation is itself authoritarian politicization of the workplace, and I'd happily tell him to go fuck himself, too.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by tdfx on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:08PM (#27000052)
> Any employer that abruptly told me I needed to watch what I said at work would lose me, too.

You don't already feel this way? There's a long list of things that would have you packing your desk if you discussed them at any other company. Society has already decided certain extreme positions are too brand damaging or disruptive to tolerate.

This policy seems to reflect that a not-insignificant portion of the population has collectively lost their minds over the past year of isolation and now is looking to pick a fight over things that no one would've blinked at 2-3 years ago. It's destroyed friendships, family ties, and I'm sure a lot of team cohesion at many companies.

I think requesting that this discussion takes place outside of company channels is a pretty reasonable reaction.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by _jal on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:55PM (#27000588)
> It's destroyed [...] a lot of team cohesion at many companies.

I have trouble imaging how a response to an apparent social cohesion issue that results in 1/3 of the office immediately walking can be considered a good outcome.

It sounds more like a corporate schism to me.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by tdfx on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:27PM (#27016502)
Well, everyone is the good guy in their own story. While the policy seems reasonable to me, I'm sure they have their own internal justification for why their departure is a reasonable reaction.

If there was a cascading series of events that led to this policy announcement that turned them off to working at the company, it's not my place to judge them. On the other hand, if they are quitting simply because they can't engage in inflammatory political rhetoric at work then I certainly hope that I never to have work with any of these people in the future.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by rodgerd on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:20PM (#27000829)
> There's a long list of things that would have you packing your desk if you discussed them at any other company.

Yeah, like pulling extracts of customer names to circulate and make fun of them. That mis-use of customer data, and tinged as it is with racial and xenophobic overtones, would have me sacked for misconduct in no time flat.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by tdfx on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:36PM (#27016566)
> and tinged as it is with racial and xenophobic overtones

This appears to be a kneejerk reaction that's separated from the facts of this situation. According to DHH:

"It's not a list of, say, primarily Asian names. Out of the 78 names listed on the last version we were able to recover, just 6 names appear to be Asian." [0]

The overwhelming need to connect anything distasteful to racism or xenophobia is a relatively recent social construct that didn't manifest itself widely until we were all locked in our homes for a year during this pandemic. Before that, we could probably all agree that maintaining a list of customer names that are laughed at is a disrespectful and stupid thing to do.

[0] https://world.hey.com/dhh/let-it-all-out-78485e8e

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by kbenson on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:10PM (#27000744)
> Any employer that abruptly told me I needed to watch what I said at work would lose me, too.

That's literally 99.99% of employers.

> I'm not saying I demand the ability to be rude and awful, or go on political tirades, or anything even vaguely like that.

Based on your initial response, it sounds like that's exactly what you're saying. They have a problem with employees not being able to speak about politics without some of them going on tirades, and some of them accusing others of acting in bad faith, and more assuming those that try to refrain are implicitly agreeing with one stance or another.

> Telling me I have to avoid entire categories of normal conversation is itself authoritarian politicization of the workplace, and I'd happily tell him to go fuck himself, too.

And you can! And they did! These people were not only there by choice, they were given a very good way out if they didn't like the change. But I also hope none of them that left because they feel the need to proselytize at work don't come work with me.

But also, let's consider when the types of interactions being described at this company became "normal conversation".

> But I spend more time talking to people I work with than any other set of people.

Hopefully primarily about work, at least when working. They aren't paying you to talk about politics. If you're doing it outside work, nobody cares. Basecamp doesn't care either. They made that clear. Just keep it off their company communications. You can even talk politics privately with your friends if you work there, because they aren't going to turn you in (and if they would, then maybe you should consider why and maybe not bother them with stuff like that).

Most people aren't hired to speak their inner thoughts to the rest of the company. Most people don't try to. Somehow it's a problem when people are told explicitly what they should have already internalized, please don't.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by baryphonic on Saturday May 01, 2021 @01:13AM (#27003349)
I wholeheartedly disagree. I have very different political views from the vast majority of people I work with. 99% of the time, those topics never come up. But if they do, I have to shut my mouth and smile and pretend I find it amusing. To call this woke improv theater I have to do "no fun" would be an understatement. It feels like being gay in the time when that could completely ostracize someone, not to mention send him to jail.

But it's even worse because I care about my colleagues. We've worked hard together and produced some pretty amazing things. When I hear them sometimes say things that are frankly ignorant, bad-faith, uncharitable, etc. about their political out-group, I just have to shake my head.

Somehow I get through my day at work avoiding discussing much about my beliefs. We chat about our families, recent happenings in our lives, hobbies, trips, interesting articles we saw recently on HN, etc. Turns out none of those things is a terribly political topic. Maybe a small part of me wishes that the tables were turned, and the people I disagree with had to hold their tongues for fear of ostracism when "political" opinions arise. But in reality, I don't want them to feel this way either. I'd rather work at a place that strongly discouraged political chatter and activism using work resources.

I'd hope that we could at least get a balance where there enough companies like Basecamp or Coinbase that can meet my needs so that the companies like Google or Spotify can continue to meet yours, and we can sort into the places where we work best.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by toolz on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:15PM (#26999444)
and neither you nor your employer would be in the wrong. There's absolutely nothing wrong with wanting no limits w.r.t. political talk in the workplace but people like myself very much prefer a workplace where I don't have to bite my tongue 24/7 simply because my political views aren't popular in the tech industry.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:51PM (#26999838)

    prefer a workplace where I don't have to bite my 
    tongue 24/7 simply because my political views 
    aren't popular
It's not that cut and dry; There's a difference between disagreeing about what is the optimal rate of taxes on labor and capital, if marijuana should be legalized, how much public money should be spent on infrastructure and so on vs say if trans people deserve acceptance & healthcare, gay people should be able to marry, women allowed to get abortions, or that ethnic and religious minorities shouldn't have to assimilate the values of the majority group.

If the discussion is about the person you are talking to getting to enjoy the same basic rights everyone else does (or even just exist) that's not just any political discussion and it affects them very personally and directly.

As they say, "your liberty to swing your fist ends where my nose begins".

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:01PM (#26999953)
I'd encourage you to introspect on this. "Ethnic and religious minorities shouldn't have to assimilate the values of the majority group" is a common position, and one I strongly agree with. But you also seem to be saying that, across a pretty wide range of contentious social issues, everyone needs to assimilate your beliefs and you can't work with anyone who hasn't. Do you see the tension here?
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by heavyset_go on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:32PM (#27000336)
People have used their religions to give a pass to discrimination for a long time[1]. Today's scapegoat is gay and trans people, but a few decades ago it was miscegenation. People discriminated against mixed-race couples and said it was a core tenet of their religion[1]:

> Almighty God created the races white, black, yellow, malay and red, and he placed them on separate continents. And but for the interference with his arrangement there would be no cause for such marriages. The fact that he separated the races shows that he did not intend for the races to mix.

When it comes to discrimination and freedom of religion, the ACLU[2] has this to say:

> Instances of institutions and individuals claiming a right to discriminate in the name of religion are not new. In the 1960s, we saw objections to laws requiring integration in restaurants because of sincerely held beliefs that God wanted the races to be separate. We saw religiously affiliated universities refuse to admit students who engaged in interracial dating. In those cases, we recognized that requiring integration was not about violating religious liberty; it was about ensuring fairness. It is no different today.

[1] https://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=55...

[2] https://www.aclu.org/issues/religious-liberty/using-religion...

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:25PM (#27000257)
When it comes to basic rights (sometimes even the right to exist), yes that is what I'm saying. Homophobia, Transphobia and so on are not better than racism & religious discrimination.

This is sometimes hard to see for people who are themselves not part of the "contentious" group (and not always due to malevolence, sometimes it's just hard to sympathize with people who aren't like yourself).

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:34PM (#27000350)
It's not about "better than". The problem is that your principles directly conflict. How would you respond, for example, to a devout Muslim with religious objections to gay marriage?
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:40PM (#27000412)
I would respond to them in exactly the same way I'd respond to a devout Christian who religiously objects to gay marriage. And I would still not think Islamophobia is justified (just like the existence of homophobic Christians doesn't condemn Christianity & Christians as a whole).
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:47PM (#27000496)
But what is the way you'd respond? It doesn't sound like you'd fire them. So it seems like your only option is to say "alright, I don't agree with you about this, but that's fine as long as you understand that you can't go around arguing this at work".

Which is a reasonable solution, don't get me wrong. But this kind of solution is what people mean when they talk about limiting politics at work, and these kinds of conflicts are why it's a good idea. In order to work with people who don't share your precise values, there have to be ground rules to minimize conflict.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Saturday May 01, 2021 @01:21AM (#27003401)
The problem is that a broad "no politics at work" ban also limits you from calling out bigotry as that would be seen as political as well. You need a more refined approach rather than an all out ban hammer.

How I'd respond to homophobia in the workplace: I will call it out and expect that person to get the hint and no longer make homophobic comments at work. If they repeatedly continue to do so afterwards then yes I'd expect them to be fired, but it will not be out of the blue or without warning.

EDIT: I think the current top thread already better formulates my opinion so I suggest reading that instead of continuing here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27001075

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by stale2002 on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:09PM (#27000731)
So are you basically saying that you would fire anyone who is a Muslim, if according to their own beliefs/faith, they don't support gay marriage?

Your position is probably straight up illegal by the way.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Saturday May 01, 2021 @01:24AM (#27003425)
No I would call them out if they make a homophobic comment at work & expect them to get the hint and stop. If they don't stop then yes they should be fired, and it has nothing to do with Islam.

You seem to expect this to be an inevitability but I've worked with plenty of Muslims in my 18 years career as I live in a city with almost half a million Muslim residents and I've never encountered a Muslim being homophobic at work.

I have in the past called out people making misogynistic comments at work & generally people do get the hint and stop doing that. If they don't then you've identified a problem.

EDIT: I think the current top thread already better formulates my opinion so I suggest reading that instead of continuing here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27001075

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by stale2002 on Saturday May 01, 2021 @01:33AM (#27003469)
> make a homophobic comment at work

See, but here is the rub. What if the comment is just "according to my islamic faith, my religious belief system does not support gay marriage".

For all I know, you would call this statement homophobic, but if you punished this person for saying this a couple times, it would absolutely be illegal.

> Nothing to do with Islam.

Yes it does. Many people, do not support gay marriage because it a part of their faith. And if you fired or punished them for stating that this is their faith, then it would absolutely be illegal discrimination on your part.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Saturday May 01, 2021 @01:41AM (#27003527)
That's what I mean in the other branch about more refined approach than an absolute "no politics" hammer. Where/why would someone say that multiple times in the company slack (never happened to me despite working with lots of muslims and lots of gay people btw)?

If they say that as a reaction to a gay man posting somewhere "I'm out of office next week as John & I are getting married" than answering this with "with all due respect, as a Muslim I can't support you getting married to a man" is out of place. If they repeat after being called out that then yes that's a problem.

They have the very reasonable possibility of simply not saying anything but that may require developing a company culture where people learn if and when to do that - this may require some "political" discussion between consenting adults and that's fine!

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by stale2002 on Saturday May 01, 2021 @03:08AM (#27004018)
> Where/why would someone say that

Maybe someone asks them about their faith, in an informal setting, such as during lunch, and then they answer the question that was asked of them regarding how their faith applied to gay marriage.

If you then punished them for this, then that would absolutely be an example of illegal discrimination, on your part.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Saturday May 01, 2021 @03:42AM (#27004211)
If they just answer respectfully when someone asks them specifically ("in my faith that's not allowed") but don't interject it themselves unasked for, over and over again when an individual mentions they are gay then that falls into "live and let live, you do you & I keep my opinions about your personal life to myself".

Again this is in no way unique to muslims, and is just as likely to be the case with similarly devout christians so I don't see why you need to focus on islam specifically. I've personally also worked with orthodox jews who I am sure hold a lot of opinions I disagree with and somehow they managed to never voice homophobic or misogynistic comments & I managed to never tell them what I think about interpretations of the bible as the literal word of god.

This is a situation which among reasonable people doesn't require outright ban of "political speech". You can cultivate a good company culture that deescalates flame wars without such a blunt instrument that may also have a lot of undesirable side effects.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by stale2002 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @01:56AM (#27012658)
I mean, ok. Just understand that there are absolutely very dangerous illegal actions that you might be taking.

It is very much possible, that according to the law, you are engaging in illegal discrimination against certain religions.

> I don't see why you need to focus on islam specifically

Well, the important reason why to focus on certain groups, is because of the possible illegality of your actions. Thats why.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by disgrunt on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:40PM (#27001073)
It's not that cut and dry; There's a difference between disagreeing about [issues I don't have strong opinions about] and [issues I do have strong opinions about].

Now scramble those weakly / strongly held opinions for every individual...

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by nailer on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:54PM (#26999862)
> if trans people deserve acceptance & healthcare, gay people should be able to marry, women allowed to get abortions, or that ethnic and religious minorities shouldn't have to assimilate the values of the majority group.

You think this. Others don't. Your values are not universal. If you want to advocate for your positions, arguing on a company slack while being paid to do something else isn't the time.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by ido on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:02PM (#26999977)
The problem is that some people's mere existence is political. If you're trans, gay, black or muslim (for example) someone arguing against who you are is not a theoretical debate.

If a coworker was saying or acting in an anti-semitic way (possibly not even consciously), I would absolutely feel unsafe as a Jew in a company that told me "that's just their beliefs, you don't have to agree with their politics". I would call that out on the company slack & if they continue doing so would expect them to get fired.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by nailer on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:23PM (#27000229)
You’re confusing innate and non innate qualities. Islam isn’t an innate quality. People can and do leave Islam. Whether transgenderism is an innate quality is up for debate. People certainly can and do stop identifying as a different gender from their sex assigned at birth.

In the case of your other example of black and Jewish people: it’s already inappropriate to be racist at work.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by oezi on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:38PM (#26999700)
Well, but isn't there a big difference between talking on the company slack which is archived for eternity or do it in your private buddy group. I think most companies wouldn't be very fond of large scale political discussions (which might easy hurt and offend) on company media. But since everybody is flex time/remote anyway that doesn't stop you from it anyway on different media.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by nikisweeting on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:59PM (#26999925)
Why not just have dedicated opt-in channels for political discussions at work? Thats how the Recurse Center does it and it seems to work well. If you don't want to engage, you don't have to, and political discussions outside of those channels are actively redirected by everyone with a nice reminder to keep those chats in the dedicated channel.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by tdfx on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:15PM (#27000142)
In my experience, those channels are usually dominated by people with the most extreme views who use it as a place to bully anyone with opposing views. I've worked with a few people who I enjoyed immensely but my perception of them as a person suffered after learning how they conduct their political discourse. I'd prefer to keep that negativity outside of my work interactions.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by nikisweeting on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:17PM (#27000169)
So don't subscribe to the politics channel?

That has not been my experience of these channels in general though. I think it depends greatly on the company culture and the people, code of conduct, and tone set by leadership.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by oezi on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:36PM (#27000381)
I think basecamp got exactly into trouble because of such politics channels which festered over years and when the lid was opened nobody liked what they saw (laughing about customer names). And you are right with leadership you could have prevented it, but at the same time an inclusive workplace is one where leadership doesn't have to monitor each channel.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by nikisweeting on Friday April 30, 2021 @09:51PM (#27002130)
Laughing about customer names != politics, that would not fly in the politics channels I've been in.

> an inclusive workplace is one where leadership doesn't have to monitor each channel

I disagree with this statement. Just because there are dedicated channels for a specific subject does not mean they should be unmoderated. There should be a code of conduct and at least light moderation / ability to report misconduct just like all other company communication mediums in shared spaces (i.e. not DMs).

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by tdfx on Friday April 30, 2021 @06:24PM (#27000238)
That's actually exactly what I've done in these situations. You can't lose if you don't play.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by cblconfederate on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:24PM (#26999552)
> I spend more time talking to people I work with than any other set of people.

Aren't they a remote company?

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by CydeWeys on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:27PM (#26999590)
It's still full-time employment.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by cblconfederate on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:37PM (#26999692)
i think we need a social movement about "life exists outside work"
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by CydeWeys on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:47PM (#26999796)
Yeah, but it would be nice if life existed at work too. You spend half your waking hours at work. Even if you have a life outside work, that's an awful lot of time to waste doing something that prohibits having a life at work.
Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by mrandish on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:37PM (#27001030)
> prohibits having a life at work.

From my perspective that seems like an odd way to think of work. You have a life at work but it necessarily has certain constraints since you've sold your time, attention & best efforts to your employer.

Re:“About one-third of Basecamp employees accepted buyouts t... by CydeWeys on Wednesday May 12, 2021 @09:54AM (#27130330)
Not many people have the luxury of not needing to work though. And from the employee's POV, you'd obviously want there to be as few constraints as possible that make the job boring/unpleasant.