News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by JediWing on Friday April 30, 2021 @02:50PM (#26997657)
This is all so ridiculous and anti-consumer. There are working apps. Right now! The status quo should be that existing apps stick around.

As far as codecs, or anything of the sort, Roku has a device that they sell to customers. Google must write an app that works on that device.

I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by tw04 on Friday April 30, 2021 @02:54PM (#26997711)
So google should continue to be forced to pay royalties for a codec because Roku refuses to slightly increase the cost-of-goods by utilizing a newer chipset that supports AV1?

On HN of all places, I'm surprised to see that the guy throwing his weight around to GET RID of proprietary codecs is being portrayed as the bad guy.

I'm sure if you dig far enough into my history you'll find I have absolutely no sympathy for google under almost any circumstances, but in this case they're doing the right thing.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by danbmil99 on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:25PM (#26998094)
Hear hear. (Disclaimer: I am founder of On2, bought by Google, ancestor of AV1)

I have zero pity for Roku and the rest of the video streaming cartel. For years (decades in fact) these companies colluded to shove down everyone's throat an expensive, unwieldy, made-by-committee 1-size-fits-all technology (MPEG), with a get-out-of-court rule from the Justice dept not to target them with price fixing.

That a small company like On2 was able to survive, much less eventually get acquired by Google (who have dutifully kept the VP* and AV1 codecs open-source) is really quite a miracle.

There is depth to this story that has never been plumbed.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by danbmil99 on Saturday May 01, 2021 @03:26PM (#27009072)
Curious about the downvotes. AV1 is a true Free and Open Source technology,, with additional protection against patent trolls. Surely HN readers would prefer a world where this sort of solution at least co-exists (if not preempts) proprietary tech created by+for the benefit of a few large companies who protect it via a cartel of dubious patents.

What is better for tech startups who don't have a legacy patent to bargain with the patent pool barons? (MPEG-LA)

What is better for artists -- musicians, independent film makers, content creators in general -- a world where the popular devices fully support FOSS protocols, or a world where a few large media companies make back-room deals with tech giants (or just consolidate tech+content into FAANG megaliths)?

This is not a trivial issue. I encourage everyone interested in this to do some research and common-sense thinking about how you want technology to evolve, and who you want controlling and exploiting that technology. It matters.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by smileybarry on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:04PM (#26997834)
Roku already supports VP9[1], a royalty-free codec. If getting rid of royalties was the true cause they can use that.

1: https://developer.roku.com/en-gb/docs/specs/media/streaming-...

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by devrand on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:30PM (#26998161)
Only obvious limitation is that they only support that for HLS streams whereas YouTube normally uses DASH.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by cpeterso on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:12PM (#26997946)
When I watch 4K YouTube videos in Firefox or Chrome on Windows, YouTube uses VP9. I don't see why YouTube could use the same 4K VP9 streams for Roku, like you suggested. Perhaps they have different requirements from partners for DRM content on YouTube TV?
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by JediWing on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:39PM (#27001059)
Average consumers don't care about codecs. Google runs a video streaming service. Paying codec royalties is a cost of doing business unfortunately.

If we could snap our fingers and make it go away, then great but holding consumers hostage on some impractical FOSS crusade is ridiculous.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by coliveira on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:11PM (#26997925)
That's not the issue. Google wants other companies to adapt to their software, not the other way around. Is the MS playbook all over again.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by yipeedipee on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:01PM (#26997799)
I would understand if: A) Roku were not paying to have it on their platform B) Consumers weren't paying for the service as well.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by jsnell on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:21PM (#26998050)
But per the earlier reporting, Roku is not paying to have the app. The money is flowing in the opposite direction: they are taking a cut from both subscriptions and adds.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by totalZero on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:04PM (#26997831)
> On HN of all places, I'm surprised to see that the guy throwing his weight around to GET RID of proprietary codecs is being portrayed as the bad guy.

When it comes to these gluttonous Big Tech companies, I tend to err on the side of the smaller guy. Your comment doesn't capture that dimension of the conflict.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by cmeacham98 on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:22PM (#26998064)
Why? Roku had over $1 billion in revune in 2019 (couldn't find 2020 data) - they're massive. While Google is obviously bigger comparing their relative sizes doesn't seem to make much sense.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by totalZero on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:31PM (#26998179)
Assuming this is a serious question:

Roku net income was $67m for the Dec quarter versus Google at $15.2b. Two hundred Rokus still do not a Google make. And Google did even better ($17.9b) in the most recent quarter.

Phrased differently, Google will probably earn more profit this year than Roku's entire market cap.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by kbelder on Friday April 30, 2021 @05:52PM (#26999846)
Or, Google will make more profit this week than Roku did over the last couple years.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by VWWHFSfQ on Friday April 30, 2021 @02:56PM (#26997734)
> supports VP1

You mean AV1

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by atomicUpdate on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:06PM (#26997854)
> Google must write an app that works on that device.

Why? Saying they must support Roku devices is a pretty firm (and strange) stance to take. Where does the line get drawn on what devices they do or don't have to support?

> I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats.

This would certainly have unintended consequences. What do you consider "stupid corporate spats"? Why should Google be forced to support codecs on HW they don't manufacture?

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by hundchenkatze on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:18PM (#26998008)
I believe they mean that if Google _wants_ YoutubeTV to run on Roku's devices then Google must write an app that supports that hardware, not that Google must support all devices in existence.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by JediWing on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:33PM (#27000980)
Yes, exactly what I meant. If they want to be on the device, write within the bounds of the device and support it throughout it's lifetime. Don't hold your massive customer base as leverage after having supported multiple apps on the platform since forever.
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by shakna on Friday April 30, 2021 @02:53PM (#26997700)
> I think it's time we have legislation that working apps cannot be removed from platforms over stupid corporate spats.

That's the way the Roku works. If you already have the app installed, then it will continue to work and function as-is.

It's only disappeared from the store. If you uninstall, you won't be able to reinstall, but the app isn't remotely removed.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by JediWing on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:34PM (#27000986)
But if the app is working, why shouldn't it be on the store?
Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by g_p on Friday April 30, 2021 @04:50PM (#26999133)
I am particularly concerned by the eWaste implications of this kind of decision. At a time of a global semiconductor shortage (likely for 6+ months), it looks like consumers will be left to deal with the fallout of these kinds of deals.

If we normalise "deprecate that hardware as it lacks some logical software feature", that's bad for the environment, and bad for society in general. That's currently normalised though, so we have a long way to go to get this put right.

It's a shame we're nearly full circle - we had fully programmable computers, now we need to add hardware codecs to them, in order to prevent those general purpose programmable computers from lasting too long (!)

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by aranelsurion on Friday April 30, 2021 @02:53PM (#26997696)
Seems to me all these problems would simply vanish if consumers could decide what they want to install.

All this craziness started with App Store 's to begin with, and hopefully one day might end with their demise. One can hope.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by falcolas on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:09PM (#26997898)
Nah, this all started with normal retail channels. They introduced the concept of the middle man and the markup that entity would demand for their services.

App stores just brought this into the digital space, overwhelmingly large profit margins and all.

Folks here frequently laud Epic for their attack against Apple, but even their (comparatively low) margins are kinda ridiculous for the bare minimum service they provide.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by oofabz on Friday April 30, 2021 @03:15PM (#26997985)
You want to legally mandate backwards compatibility? That would cause all kinds of unintended consequences.

The ability to break backwards compatibility has been central to the continued development of every platform. Windows, Mac OS, Android, iOS, the web, are all unable to run certain old programs. Some of these platforms offer more compatibility than others, but none offer 100%.

Most of the time, the breaking changes end up being good for consumers, especially in the long run. Change is necessary for technological progress and banning such activity would be like throwing out the baby with the bath water.

Re:An update to our YouTube TV members on Roku by JediWing on Friday April 30, 2021 @07:37PM (#27001027)
It's not backwards compatibility support, it's warranty. Google is running Youtube. It's very profitable. They can afford the maintenance burden of running these apps for the supported lifetime of Roku devices. It's really no different than running Youtube to an old computer.