Re:Vertical turbines are more efficient in large-scale wind ...
by hinkley on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @07:28PM
(#26975530)
If memory serves, the resonance problem with 3 blade turbines is when the blade passes in front of the pylon. But with the VAWT the blades instead pass into the shadow of every other blade, which is twice per revolution?
Does a VAWT behave better or worse in this regard with an even number of blades? Seems like with an even number multiple blades would occlude each other at the exact same time.
Re:Vertical turbines are more efficient in large-scale wind ...
by jacquesm on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @08:47PM
(#26976134)
It is the tower occlusion that sets off the problematic resonance, which ends up eating the base bearings.
Re:Vertical turbines are more efficient in large-scale wind ...
by bigiain on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:23PM
(#26977068)
There are a couple of (small, obviously academic/experimental) vertical axis wind turbines near me which both have helical blades. I wonder what the tradeoffs for that design are?
Here's a picture (not mine) one of them: https://www.flickr.com/photos/nicephotog/25044930672/
Re:Vertical turbines are more efficient in large-scale wind ...
by hasmanean on Thursday April 29, 2021 @06:52AM
(#26979543)
For very tall VAWTs in a grid, could you dampen the resonances by tying the tops of the masts together with guy wires?
There are some VAWTs in the rockies that lived for more than a decade but they made really little power compared to the amount of money that went into them.
But they look nice and are deceptively simple on paper (one less parameter to deal with due to the fact that you don't need to steer them, and the generator stays at ground level). So likely people will keep trying but it almost certainly isn't going to move the needle in the longer term.