For an alternative to develop, it is not enough that it is slightly better. And both turbines driven by kites and vertical turbines are known tech, with known problems. They are likely not slightly better. Early wind pioneers knew about vertical turbines. They have some nice properties. But also some not so nice ones.
And this paper does not study vertical vs. horizontal as far as I can tell from a cursory look. It studies what happens with vertical turbines in a small farm.
Kites have the potential of much lower material costs to produce energy. If you have a pumping cycle kite, the "support structure" is the tether, compared to the tower and foundation required for a HAWT. The problems are indeed well known: 1. Tether material difficulties. 2. Need for self-launching 3. Airspace sharing problems at heights of kites 4. Controller design. This last one is what intrigues me personally.
The paper looks at vertical turbine arrangements, but the linked article about the paper starts with "The research suggests that the now-familiar sight of traditional propeller wind turbines may be eventually replaced by the sight of wind farms containing more compact and efficient vertical turbines." I had to respond to this rather wishful statement.
Obviously, they are unlikely to be ever competitive with current HAWT which is really sailing (pun!) along nicely.
But as a niche-player e.g. oil rigs, mobile power sources, etc, maybe not all is lost. What is their projects LCOE ?
EDIT: projected/promised $49/mwh
https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/will-airborne-w...
Alvin Marks (who beat out Edwin Land for the polarized-sunglasses patent) filed a patent on this back in the '80s.
The idea is simple: you ionize air moving through your system, and the wind carries the ions away, accumulating a grid voltage vs. ground. The restoring current can do work. If your screen is on a kite, it can be very high up, to catch very high wind speed. It is very cheap to construct, with no mechanical parts at all; restoring current runs up (strictly speaking, down) the kitestring. Or, a screen could be stretched between upper parts of pairs of existing skyscrapers, or towers of a bridge, almost invisibly.
The trick is how to ionize air cheaply. Certain materials give up electrons to moving air spontaneously; you could have streamers of such materials, modified to be slightly conductive. Otherwise, you need some sort of charge pump to favor losing surface charge. Maybe a mist of water carries away the ions.
Measures of efficiency can be confusing. Ultimately, the measure that matters is W/$. If the installation is cheap enough to build and operate, percentage of available wind power extracted may be almost irrelevant. Stretched between existing structures, you might not want to extract much of the available energy anyway, because of the load it would place on the structure. But the next screen downwind could extract as much power, again.
There are some VAWTs in the rockies that lived for more than a decade but they made really little power compared to the amount of money that went into them.
But they look nice and are deceptively simple on paper (one less parameter to deal with due to the fact that you don't need to steer them, and the generator stays at ground level). So likely people will keep trying but it almost certainly isn't going to move the needle in the longer term.
Does a VAWT behave better or worse in this regard with an even number of blades? Seems like with an even number multiple blades would occlude each other at the exact same time.
Here's a picture (not mine) one of them: https://www.flickr.com/photos/nicephotog/25044930672/
See also: Windtree and other scams.
https://wes.copernicus.org/articles/5/1623/2020/wes-5-1623-2...
[PDF] https://wes.copernicus.org/preprints/wes-2019-105/wes-2019-1...
https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2020/05/14/...
It seems like all your concerns/critiques from above would apply equally, but then I don't have any real expertise in the area.
1. The surface area of the machine is small. Think of this as the area that can capture power from the wind. Due to the cylindrical shape this is way smaller than the rotor area of a HAWT or even a VAWT.
2. Vortex induced vibration [1] is a real phenomenon that can extract energy from a flow. However, to extract this energy, the natural frequency of the structure must synchronize with the vortex shedding frequency of the flow around the structure. This is called "lock-in". Since the wind is a highly variable resource, it will not consistently be in this "lock-in" range in real-world conditions. To give perspective on the norm for HAWTs, pitch control for the blades is used along with generator torque control to achieve power production from 3 m/s all the way to the maximum (cut-out) wind speed of ~25 m/s.
[1]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/we.1806
That's definitely of interest to me, although I think that manufacturers are interested in it. Many manufacturers are very conservative with installed/environmental conditions of their production machines and want to minimize risks, instead of potentially alienating a developer by suggesting a scheme that could fatigue turbines or have other unintended consequences. If anything, the paper suggests to me that if adopted, manufacturers could sell even more turbines!
There are several significant barriers to adoption that VAWTs face.
1. The wind resource is more powerful and more consistent higher off the ground. The hub heights of industry standard horizontal-axis wind turbines are reaching 135+ meters for the new generation of large offshore machines. These vertical axis machines are much lower to the ground.
2. Contrary to the claims of the authors in the Renewable Energy Paper (they say "The potential applications for VAWTs are endless, because the turbines are cheaper and easier to manufacture and maintain. "), vertical axis turbines have consistently had fatigue issues. There is an interesting history of the test-campaigns of vertical-axis machines at Sandia National Laboratories [1] that discusses this. In the 70s and 80s vertical machines were much more common than they are today.
3. It is a huge risk for an industry that is shipping proven technology to switch to a new paradigm that will require much more research and testing to work at scale. It's certainly possible and I find the possibility fascinating as a curious engineer. I would love to have a secure position developing VAWT tech or working on airborne wind machines (check out ground-based generator concepts to get an idea of where I think that will progress, not ill-conceived onboard generator kites like Makani).
The problem of wake blockage in large wind farms (and from adjacent farms to each other) is definitely significant though. The current "top" strategy is wake steering, where turbines at the front use their yaw drive to capture less power and allow for more power to reach the turbines in the rows following. [1]. The bleeding edge of this may be vertical wake steering, which can entrain high-energy wind from above the farm into the plant to capture more power [3].
[1] https://energy.sandia.gov/wp-content/gallery/uploads/SAND201... [2] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68396.pdf [3] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7963037