News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by devoutsalsa on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:06AM (#26969509)
Nope. You don't sell it. You donate it. It's considered a charitable contribution, not a sale, and that makes it 100% tax deductible. [1]

I guess you'd have to spend $20 million on the painting, but you're buying it from yourself, so in reality you're only on the hook for the 2% fee from the auction house.

[1] https://www.usa.gov/donate-to-charity#item-211605

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by nightski on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:10AM (#26969552)
Before that though, when you bought your own painting for $20M. I'd imagine it would be pretty difficult to write off that purchase as a business expense or something. The IRS is going to notice a $20M write-off for a business with no additional income pretty quick. But you will have to pay taxes on the $20M income, even if it is coming from yourself.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by cronin101 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @10:18AM (#26969645)
In the above example you pay capital gains on the one (1) $20m initial painting that allows you to then donate N "equal value" paintings. So you can dilute the capital gains % indefinitely (1/N).
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:41AM (#26970644)
But your tax basis in the other paintings is still $1M. If you donate them claiming they're worth $1M, you don't get a $20M deduction. If you claim they're worth $20M then transferring them is a realization event and you owe capital gains on $19M. Then you get a $20M deduction which cancels out the capital gains and leaves you with just the original $1M deduction for what you actually paid, right?

What people really do this for is insurance fraud. Buy some paintings for $1M each, get them appraised and insured for $20M each, then somebody "steals" them or you have a convenient structure fire and make the N*$20M insurance claim.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by toast0 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:20PM (#26971121)
As another poster said, assuming paintings are treated like stock, as long as you've held it for more than one year, donating an aprechiated asset is magic.

In this example, you get a $20M deduction and you don't have to realize the $19M gain.

Depending on how the shill purchase in the hypothetical is arranged, you might have realized a gain there... but then again, maybe you just pay the auction fees.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:11PM (#26971732)
EDIT: this was wrong, did research and you actually have to hold for a year

Original: Holding a year or not doesn't matter for donating appreciated assets, AIUI

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by Bedon292 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @03:05PM (#26972881)
If you don't hold it for the year you still don't realize the capital gains, but you only get to deduct the cost basis. After a year you get to deduct the current value.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by sbelskie on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:11PM (#26971010)
Unless paintings are different than other assets commonly donated (e.g. stocks), this doesn’t sound right. If I donate a stock that has appreciated in value, I pay no capital gains tax and am still able to deduct the full market value of the stock (up to certain limits).
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by devoutsalsa on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:21PM (#26971134)
> If you claim they're worth $20M then transferring them is a realization event and you owe capital gains on $19M. Then you get a $20M deduction which cancels out the capital gains and leaves you with just the original $1M deduction for what you actually paid, right?

Nope. Think of it this way:

- you lobby government to make charitable donations tax deductible, meaning you can reduce your income by the stated value of the donation

- you use the auction house hack to inflate the value of the painting from $1_000_000 USD to $20_000_000 USD buy buying it from yourself

- No one will buy your painting for $20_000_000 USD, so it's not really worth that in the open market, but the art museum (in your backyard & founded by you) will give you a receipt stating the art is worth $20_000_000 USD

- Unless you reduce your income, your tax rate is 50%, so you donate the inflated art piece (to your art museum in your backyard), give yourself a receipt for the donation

- You attach that receipt to your tax return, lowering your taxable income from $A_LOT to $A_LOT minus $20_000_000, which at a 50% tax rate saves you $10_000_000 in taxes

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by wtracy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:33PM (#26973832)
- you use the auction house hack to inflate the value of the painting from $1_000_000 USD to $20_000_000 USD buy buying it from yourself

Isn't that a realization event right there?

Obviously, the described scheme could still work if you sold one painting to yourself, and then donated N paintings based on that valuation.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by devoutsalsa on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @04:55PM (#26974078)
"The federal tax code allows you to contribute long-term appreciated securities—such as stocks, bonds, and mutual fund shares—directly to a charity without paying capital gains tax on the appreciated value, as you would if you sold it first and then contributed cash to the charity." [1]

[1] https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/personal-finance/tax-bre...

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by wtracy on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @05:05PM (#26974189)
Sure the donation isn't taxed, but why wouldn't the original (fraudulent) sale be taxed?

Selling an item at auction and buying it yourself isn't exactly a charitable contribution.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by MagnumOpus on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:47PM (#26986501)
You can of course donate $20 mil to a charity that you can influence (a foundation of a relative or a friend’s family, say) and get that charity to buy the first painting at auction.

This way you pay cap gains on 19 million but can offset 20 million of charity donations against the gain.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by devoutsalsa on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @06:10PM (#26974879)
You don't pay (an income or capital gains) tax when you buy something. Only when you sell it. Maybe there's some other tax, like VAT or luxury or sales that are all based on the purchase price.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:16PM (#26971785)
Donating assets to charity is not a realization event under US tax law. This is why donor-advised funds are a thing - this rule applies to publicly traded securities, which means you can donate appreciated stock to a DAF and have the fund distribute cash to charity on your behalf, avoiding the capital gains you would incur if you normally sold appreciated stock and donated the proceeds.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:40PM (#26972009)
So I think I'm wrong. I'm doing the math for selling the asset and donating the money. In theory just donating the asset shouldn't make any difference -- either it's a realization and that cancels with the donation, or you're donating at the original tax basis, and either way the net deduction is the original tax basis. Because otherwise it's double counting and you get all kinds of bizarre incentives and rich people not paying any taxes.

For example, if you bought $1 of a stock that appreciated to $1000 and they increased the capital gains rate to 60%, you wouldn't pay any taxes. The IRS would take in less money from the higher rate. Because even if you don't care about charity at all, you'd donate half the stock to a charity when you go to sell the other half and keep 50% of the money instead of 40%. The IRS would get nothing instead of whatever they got at the lower rate.

But the tax code is full of bizarre incentives and rich people not paying any taxes, so apparently this is one of them. (Which at least has the benefit of encouraging charitable donations.)

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ThrustVectoring on Thursday April 29, 2021 @10:31AM (#26981647)
Yeah I agree that it's weird, unintuitive, and not how the ideal tax code should work. It shouldn't matter whether you or the charity sells the stock. Similarly, it shouldn't matter whether you or your heirs sell your stock, but it does, and that's a whole other can of tax optimization worms.

This is because the cost basis of assets "steps up" on the owner's death to the fair market value at that date - without any capital gains owed. So if you own $10m of non-dividend paying stock, you can comfortably borrow and spend $200k/yr against it, pay no income or capital gains taxes, and when you die your heirs don't owe any capital gains either and can sell off a portion to repay the loan.

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ChrisLomont on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:40AM (#26970621)
Any charitable giving of over a low threshold would be audited for value to prevent this type of grift. You'd likely end up in serious tax trouble.

For example: "Donating non-cash items to a charity will raise an audit flag if the value exceeds the $500 threshold for Form 8283, which the IRS always puts under close scrutiny. If you fail to value the donated item correctly, the IRS may deny your entire deduction, even if you underestimate the value."

https://budgeting.thenest.com/much-should-donate-charity-tax...

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by coliveira on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @11:55AM (#26970806)
Yes if you're poor, that would stick out on your tax returns. If you're rich and other parts of the tax returns are even more complex, I think this would fly without any problem.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by Matticus_Rex on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:15PM (#26971056)
From rich friends' experience, that's not how it works. The bigger the fish, the more resources get thrown at it. A friend got audited and they came up with the most absurdly tiny mistakes in really complex things. It turned out they couldn't find anything they thought was more than a mistake, but their thoroughness was pretty incredible.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by lozaning on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:53PM (#26972110)
On average, the more money you have and the more complex your taxes the less likely you are to be audited.

https://projects.propublica.org/graphics/eitc-audit

Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by coliveira on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:20PM (#26971122)
The difference is that the rich have the lawyers to deal with that. You shouldn't worry about them. An audit for a rich person is just another annoyance that they pay to go away, it is not gonna change their behavior.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:18PM (#26971810)
This is why you hire someone to appraise the value of the item and document the third-party appraisal. If someone else says your painting was worth $20m on the day you donated it, and they're wrong in the view of the IRS, well, it's an honest mistake on your part and at worst you just have to pay some money for getting caught.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by gnopgnip on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:51PM (#26972725)
That is why you hire a tax pro, and have an appraiser so the donated item is valued correctly.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by ChrisLomont on Thursday April 29, 2021 @05:58AM (#26979218)
Once it's valued correctly by a proper appraiser you will not get the tax scam to work. They are not as dumb as this chain of posts assumes. Neither is the IRS.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by suifbwish on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:05PM (#27019011)
There is a hole in this logic. It’s perfectly legal in the US to create your own religion proclaiming you as a deity whose boredom will destroy the universe and thus you need lots of expensive toys to keep your boredom from collapsing the universe. Any religion can have a nonprofit organization formed around it, making it acceptable and even expected that any donations made to that religious nonprofit are used to carry out the observance of that religions doctrine, that being the purchase of more expensive toys to prevent your boredom from ending the universe. Any donations to the religion would be not taxable.
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by josho on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @01:27PM (#26971909)
OMG, I wonder if this is why Trump has his own charities that also happen to make frequent donations of paintings!?
Re:TikToker makes ‘scamcoin’ as a joke and within an hour it... by MagnumOpus on Thursday April 29, 2021 @04:49PM (#26986517)
That’s a bingo.

(Sometimes it is just bribery or money laundering, transferring worthless hard-to-value art for millions is ideal not just for tax fraud.)