It would be impossible for Loopt to enrich itself at the expense of the local businesses. A local business wouldn't take the deal unless they felt it was to their advantage-- unless it was a "win-win" scenario.
Let the businesses decide what's at their expense.
Suppose Loopt posts some deal, like this one with the bi-rite creamery, and then bi-rite is like "heck no!" What will the user think? They will think "bi-rite sucks, what the heck, those jerks aren't honoring their commitment. Dicks."
It is waaaay too much to expect users to have a thorough understanding of what's happening here.
Put another way: For myself, I like to underpromise and over deliver. Loopt here is making the promise, and then saying "Hey, so your users now have this expectation. It's your choice whether you meet it, which may not financially tenable, or fail to meet their expectations, damaging your brand."
I want to attribute this whole thing to Hanlon's Razor, but it's hard to believe that a bunch of professionals are so brazenly callous about the use of others' trademarks.
Now let's look at what the Loopt UI looked like:
1 - It's presented in a way that's extremely similar to what all of the other group-buying websites look like. Which is to say, a reasonable person can easily confuse this for a deal from an affiliate (Groupon-style)
2 - The bullet points do not do anything to dissuade this. In fact, nowhere on Mr. Agrawal's screenshot does the website mention that the merchant must approve the deal.
3 - In fact, there is nothing on the page that would indicate to a user that this isn't the standard group-buying affiliate-deal we're all used to seeing. There's not even messaging in the vein of "Tell Bi-Rite you want to see this deal!" that might defuse confusion.
So it really comes down to reasonable interpretations. When a reasonable internet user, who has heard of Groupon, LivingSocial, et al, sees this Loopt UI - would it be reasonable for him/her to perceive a affiliation or endorsement for Loopt from the merchant?
Personally, I'm leaning towards "probably". Had the user base of HN not been tipped to the business model prior to seeing the feature, I would expect much confusion even from our seasoned web-guru user base.
* Sunday Super-Deal: $50000 YCombinator Seed Funding! *
Value: $50000, Discount: 5%, You save: 5% off the share that YC would normally take
Purchased: 17 of 100
Time Remaining: 2d 21h 43m 13s
[Big Green Button ->]
Loopt is building a mailing list of people using the business's brand name and causing customer service issues for them.
I've forward to this to some friends in the payments space. This might be considered credit card fraud because they are also taking people's credit card numbers in conjunction with a service they can't commit to delivering.
We're taking credit card numbers in the same way Priceline does for name-your-own price deals and Groupon used to when deals might not tip. Please let me know what your friends say, though.
The difference between Priceline and what you're doing is that Priceline has already established relationships with hotels. They have the ability to fill demand that meets certain criteria.
You don't have the ability to fill demand for the product you're advertising. Now, if Loopt were willing to pay the difference out of its own pockets (as some daily deal vendors do), that's another story.
Even then, you've got a trademark infringement issue.
That's not true. Unless this is genuinely valuable to enough businesses, it won't be sustainable. If too few businesses accept the offers made to them by buyers, the buyers will find the service useless and won't recommend it to their friends, and traffic will dry up.
I agree it's unsustainable, but this seems to miss the point: while the business model of the idea in question does not revolve around win-lose deals and trademark infringement, something ethically questionable has happened here.
This is reminiscent of the AirBNB brouhaha - while the service itself may be valuable, the means by which the company chose to market and launch itself was sketchy to the extreme. If AirBnb's core offering was not compelling, spamming people on Craigslist would've been unsustainable, as it would be here - but the fact that the product doesn't suck is not justification for questionable behavior such as this.
Some material harm (thankfully it would seem, not much) has come to at least one business involved, and had it continued in that format (i.e., vague text that doesn't seek to distance Loopt from these unaffiliated merchants) it would certainly have caused more damage.
It should also be noted that Loopt picked really high profile businesses like Bi-Rite and Ritual Coffee. These places usually have lines and don't have much need to run large discounts.
If Loopt had picked obscure businesses, it would make it easier to claim they weren't trying to benefit from the business's good name.
But not a net benefit. Unless this is sustainable, it will have been a very expensive way to collect email addresses.
http://redesignmobile.com/2011/06/22/loopts-u-deals-offer-an...
How on earth is that? This is not an AdWords/web traffic model - Loopt does not make any money unless they can close a deal with a business. If Loopt really is what you say it is then it will go under as soon as they run out of cash, and you don't really need to worry about it so much, as it's just like any other bad startup idea.
Having said that, some businesses will likely go for this, and the legal penalties will probably be lower than your profits, so kudos!
Obviously, it doesn't work for us unless it works for both of those groups [consumers and businesses]
This is where I'd hope trademark law kicks in. Here's hoping Loopt gets what's rightfully coming to them.