News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by wufufufu on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:22PM (#26958838)
I think of Bitcoin as a hail mary attempt to fix the inequality caused by central banking. I got a lot of flak for saying that I would trade the environmental damage done by bitcoin for negating central banking in another thread, but I believe that wealth inequality is the biggest humanitarian problem we face.
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by teachingassist on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @01:25PM (#26958875)
I don't see that Bitcoin has any hope of solving wealth inequality. If anything, it's a mechanism to entrench it.

Up to now: 1. only a fraction of a minority of the population have gained wealth from Bitcoin, and 2. those people had wealth enough to buy sufficient Bitcoin in the first place.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by doggosphere on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:35PM (#26959698)
Wealth inequality comes when you can create money out of thin air and buy bonds with it, injecting cash into the financial system. Bond owners get to sell their devaluing assets to the fed at inflated prices. Those profits get put back into the system via buying stocks, bitcoin, houses and other rare assets. The people who gain the most are the people who already own this assets, which is typically not the poor.

Bitcoin cannot be created out of thin air. You can't arbitrarily decide to inject more of it into the system. When you own Bitcoin, your holdings cannot be debased. Since poor people's wealth is mostly cash, debasement of currency hurts them the most.

There is a tragic irony, in where if a poor person throws their savings into Bitcoin, they are chastised as being foolish and preyed upon, and they need to be protected. If they keep their savings in fiat, they get debased (USD debased by 20% in 2020, 320% in last 20 years) as inflation eventually catches up. The Feds took away the ability to save. A Bank of America savings accounts offer 0.01% APY, 0.05% if you have more money. No one believes in a future where saving is worth anything.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by teachingassist on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:54PM (#26960662)
> Since poor people's wealth is mostly cash

A reasonable definition of 'poor' is holding no net wealth, or less - which applies to 30-40% of households in Scotland (for example):

https://www.gov.scot/publications/wealth-assets-scotland-200...

So your arguments here don't apply for my understanding of 'poor'. You have to be approaching median wealth before those arguments start to apply, if they do at all.

A poor person is not greatly affected by debasement of their savings in currency, because they don't have any savings.

A poor person is not considering throwing their savings into Bitcoin, because they don't have any savings (beyond essential cash).

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by doggosphere on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:10PM (#26960880)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Unite...

"The bottom half of the income distribution had a huge share of its wealth tied up in real estate while owning essentially no shares of corporate stock. The top 1 percent, by contrast, wasn't just rich — it was specifically rich in terms of owning companies, both stock in publicly traded ones ("corporate equities") and shares of closely held ones ("private businesses")...So the value of those specific assets — assets that people in the bottom half of the distribution never had a chance to own in the first place — soared.

NPR also reported in 2017 that the bottom 50% of U.S. households (by net worth) have little stock market exposure (neither directly nor indirectly through 401k plans), writing: "That means the stock market rally can only directly benefit around half of all Americans — and substantially fewer than it would have a decade ago, when nearly two-thirds of families owned stock."

A poor person is not greatly affected by debasement of their savings in currency, because they don't have any savings.

Debasement eventually shows up in the form of inflation of consumer goods prices. And inflated housing prices makes it nearly impossible for future generations to ever own a home, depending on the city.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:14PM (#26960931)
> Debasement eventually shows up in the form of inflation of consumer goods prices

Sure. But nominal price inflation doesn’t matter to the poor as a class, but to those on fixed nominal income (e.g., many retirees, or people dependent on benefit programs with fixed rather than indexed benefit levels.)

Real increases in prices of goods disproportionately in demand at lower income levels matters to the poor, but that’s a different issue than general inflation.

> And inflated housing prices makes it nearly impossible for future generations to ever own a home, depending on the city.

Real increase in housing prices (or, more to the point, increases in housing prices relstive to a particular poor persons income), which has nothing to do with currency debasement/devaluation or general inflation, makes homeownership less accessible.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by doggosphere on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:24PM (#26961038)
Real prices have been increasing. They approach bubble territory.

Home price to income ratio: https://www.longtermtrends.net/home-price-median-annual-inco...

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:09PM (#26960871)
> poor people's wealth is mostly cash

poor people tend to be net debtors considering dollar-denominated assets and liabilities, and to have most of their gross value of assets (even ignoring short-term consumables like perishable food) in physical goods, not cash or other dollar-denominated assets.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by wmf on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:24PM (#26959565)
With 60,000x gains, you didn't need to buy much Bitcoin to become rich. Of course, winning lottery tickets have even better odds but they're not solving inequality either.

An argument has been made that "elites" were "brainwashed by the system" to believe that crypto would fail and thus they never bought in. Instead, "outsiders" bought crypto and may one day eclipse the old elites. However, crypto's "outsider" early adopters were mostly middle-class techies not working-class people. So yeah, Bitcoin is still not solving anything.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by chrisco255 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:44PM (#26959823)
Yeah, if you were in on the ground floor and if you had conviction not to sell once you 10x or 100x. Few people can make that claim.

But meanwhile there have been several other crypto projects that have cropped up that have seen life-changing gains and are actually built on sustainable, value-adding platforms (Ethereum, Uniswap, Synthetix, Aave, etc).

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by ChainOfFools on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:00PM (#26960009)
> winning lottery tickets have even better odds but they're not solving inequality either.

lotteries are cancer and I'm in no way a supporter of them (except to acknowledge they may be the best answer to a problem that has no good solutions), but the model does work like a vice tax, in that a substantial fraction of ticket proceeds go toward various social and investment programs.

the prizes only consume 20-70% of the revenue (specific fraction depends on the game).

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by wufufufu on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:23PM (#26961754)
Then any new asset type, IPO, or security also entrenches wealth inequality for the same reasons. Unfortunately that would have to happen to get away from using fiat currency.

My original comment was just saying that I think Bitcoin is the best alternative we have, not that it would necessarily succeed.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by yunohn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:04PM (#26959315)
Do explain how Bitcoin fixes wealth inequality? Genuinely curious…
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by wufufufu on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @06:25PM (#26962661)
Not a "fix" (I should have picked my words more carefully), but it would stem the bleeding from inflation.
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by frockington1 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @02:39PM (#26959763)
The government can't print 1.9 trillion more Bitcoin overnight so the unions and lobbies they serve can get a bail out.
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by yunohn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:07PM (#26960085)
You’re explaining how no more Bitcoin can be generated once all is mined. That’s not solving any wealth inequality. More so because lower income people own almost zero BTC.
Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by rawtxapp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:42PM (#26960514)
I don't think wealthy inequality will ever be "solved" and I don't think it's necessarily a bad thing unless it's extreme inequality. We need some kind of incentives for people to go ahead and build stuff.

Imagine if you were paid in BTC or saved money into BTC, you won't get diluted over a long enough time, that's the promise. When you get paid in BTC, someone gives you theirs, it's a zero-sum game.

Also, since nobody can print more of it, if someone goes ahead and plays around with high leverage and gets wiped out, their losses won't be socialized by bailouts.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by yunohn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:45PM (#26960571)
I’ve literally never heard of anyone refusing to work for fiat currency, due to concerns that it will be diluted.

On the other hand, I’ve heard from innumerable people that crypto’s volatility drives them away.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by rawtxapp on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @03:58PM (#26960734)
Because they never had the alternative to fiat. Some professional players [1], tech workers [2], city workers [3], etc, are starting to get portions of their salaries in BTC. You can always take fiat from work and save it in BTC as well.

It won't be this volatile forever, as the market cap gets larger, the volatility goes down.

1: https://ftw.usatoday.com/lists/nfl-draft-trevor-lawrence-cry...

2: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/olaf-carlson-wee-first-coinba...

3: https://www.newsweek.com/miami-passes-resolution-allow-payin...

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by yunohn on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @04:59PM (#26961477)
But all of these people make significantly larger sums than any average person. And, for sports stars, they make lots of side-money via endorsements.

To reiterate my earlier points, none of them are doing this due to dilution concerns; rather the usual crypto speculation to cash out massive gains.

This neither fixes nor mitigates any sort of wealth inequality.

Re:Some thoughts on the $660k copy of Super Mario Bros by wufufufu on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @07:26PM (#26963368)
What happens to wages when the QE occurs? Nothing, they stagnate. What happens to real estate and securities? They skyrocket.

I don't care if it's cryptocurrency that we end up using. As long as we can pay people in some kind of security that cannot be inflated, then wages cannot be silently garnished via inflation.