News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by ButtSpark69 on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:03AM (#26940028)
“For profit US corporation fighting foreign government atrocities”

I think that's a bit of an unfair phrasing. How about "Good people upholding their morals instead of dropping them at the door when they go to work"

I really am not a fan of how far we've taken the general image that 'business is business' and a bunch of regular morals are OK to toss out. We should preserve the social stigma we hold against people equally against companies.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by forks34 on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:40AM (#26940245)
No. The U.S. 300 million citizen don’t have the monopoly on morals when 1 billion Indians have a different idea about them. So don’t be pretentious, adapt to local laws and let people figure out their own ideas about life. Maybe, just maybe, the U.S. has the wrong laws.
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by fighterpilot on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:53AM (#26940313)
1 billion Indians aren't all supporters of government censorship of criticism.

If the US government enacted some ridiculous law, you would hope that US corporations would try to push back a bit, at least rhetorically, because you recognize that the state isn't its people. Why suddenly the different tone for India?

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by input_sh on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:38AM (#26940527)
Plenty of countries in the world have a lax view on nudity, show it on TV, go to the beach naked, have a regulated sex work industry etc.

Yet, since almost all large platforms and payment processors are American, good luck posting photos of sand dunes because some algorithm at Facebook might confuse it with woman's breasts, and I don't see anyone pushing back.

Point being adapt to local laws and culture instead of pretending that a couple of thousand of unelected dudes in Silicon Valley should have any say in what's allowed in some country none of them stepped foot in.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by fighterpilot on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:37AM (#26940797)
> adapt to local laws and culture instead of pretending that a couple of thousand of unelected dudes in Silicon Valley should have any say

I think we might both agree there's a line beyond which even you would abandon this view.

We may just disagree on where that line should exist.

If the Indian state was forcing Twitter to delete the profiles of anyone who is a homosexual, would you agree that Twitter should just adapt to local laws and not at least say something? Probably not, right?

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by input_sh on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:56AM (#26940896)
We don't have to play pretend, there are countries like Saudi Arabia where that's already a thing. Turns out Twitter happily complies. https://www.humanrightsfirst.org/blog/twitter-not-safe-saudi...

The only moral high ground I'm willing to accept is them leaving such a market, but that doesn't align with their pockets.

[dead]
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by skinkestek on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:33PM (#26945335)
> Persecution of homosexuals is a Christian (and, to an extent, Islamic) phenomenon.

Can we please stop pretending that Christianity is worse than other religions?

As already mentioned by another numerous well known examples of other groups of people exist who punish homosexuality by death today (leaving out names as I'm not trying to not continue a flame war here, I'm not out to criticize any other religion or culture here). On the other hand I'm not aware of any current Christian groups who kill or beat anyone for that.

> Hindus haven't really cared[1] about homosexual behavior till the British came in and brought their anti-buggery laws with them.

You know what else the English brought?

They brought an end to burning young widows in their "husbands" funerals.

History isn't black and white and while I know it is extremely trendy to blame white Christian guys for everything we should strive for a better standard here.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by ehvatum on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:26AM (#26941386)
What Christian theocracy will put you to death, today, for being homosexual? Numerous Islamic government examples exist, yes. I’m looking for Christian, since that’s where you say the focus must be.
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by sinyug on Monday April 26, 2021 @07:59AM (#26941593)
> since that’s where you say the focus must be.

Not what I said. I simply asked him to pick an appropriate example instead of one that has no basis in reality.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by fighterpilot on Monday April 26, 2021 @08:33AM (#26941819)
> no basis in reality.

It's just a hypothetical that I put out there for rhetorical purposes. It doesn't have to be realistic. You can substitute India for another country (say, Saudi Arabia, like another poster did) if you think that realism is important. The argument will remain the same.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by true_religion on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:56PM (#26944838)
With India’s population size, it’s possible more people support the government than exist people in the entirety of the United States.

Why are they wrong and Americans right?

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by fitzie on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:11AM (#26942144)
I see rights being of intrinsic value how much a country, both its culture and regulators, protect them can be directly scored. you can argue what exactly those rights should be, and you can argue that a society can still be happy and productive without those rights, but you cannot argue that people have their rights when the gov't and their proxies in the business world suppresses them.

all that being said, I suspect there is less policing of speech on twitter in India then what twitter does to discourse in the states.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by dTal on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:14AM (#26940691)
We are talking about freedom of speech here, not food regulations. Once it goes away, it doesn't come back. Where is the line between "culture war" and "moral imperative"? How far does moral relativism go? A country is gradually turning fascist - will you continue your hands-off policy even as they commit genocide? (A million Uighurs say yes unfortunately).

Countries aren't wild animals, to be observed Attenborough-like but not interfered with. They're people. If free speech is good enough for me then it's damn well good enough for them.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by nirav72 on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:10AM (#26942135)
A significant part of the world doesn't see what's good for you is good for them.
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by dTal on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:37AM (#26942348)
If they're forbidden from talking, how would we even know?

Indians aren't an alien hive-mind, they're regular people like you and me, and until someone proves otherwise I'm going to assume they don't like being oppressed.

Reality check - Twitter is censoring tweets critical of the government, at government request. Am I really supposed to believe that this government represents the people? Because it sounds less like "cultural differences" and more like bog standard authoritarianism.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by mrtksn on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:08AM (#26940060)
I agree. IMHO, corporations must be hold morally accountable(whatever that is, locally). However, if the local morals say that "It's all about profits" or something permissive then they will operate in oppressive regimes. What I disagree with, is the expectation of enforcing US morals to other parts of the world. If we are going for the moral stance of "should not tolerate censorship", instead of expecting Twitter to "fight the oppressive Indian govt" , it's more reasonable to expect Twitter not doing business there.

So far, as we see with Apple, Twitter, FB, Palantir, Oracle, Cisco and many others, the Americans are fine with their businesses working with those governments.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by bellyfullofbac on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:33AM (#26940201)
Twitter allows posting of naked photos. I have no problems with this, but should a country's laws against pornography be ignored because "our morals are superior"?
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by fighterpilot on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:51AM (#26940302)
I don't think it's valid to compare different pornography laws with a government censoring criticism. The former has very little societal significance, the latter is correlated with rather unpleasant state authoritarianism.
Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by ehsankia on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:38AM (#26940238)
At the end of the day, this goes back to a debate that's been had here many times before, such as with Google's Dragonfly, which is that is Twitter doing more good being available in India with occasional censoring, or if it do more good if it wasn't available in India all.

I'm not siding one way or another, but it's not clear that taking down the platform as a whole is always a better solution than running a slightly censored one.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by FlyingSnake on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:55AM (#26940326)
> Good people upholding their morals instead of dropping them at the door when they go to work

Who gets to define the "Good people"? We've seen time and again that the social media platforms are far from altruistic and in fact enable movements like Trump '16 and Brexit. I agree with your general point though, we should hold companies accountable to the same rigor that we have for govts and individuals.

Re:Twitter is blocking tweets that criticize the Indian gove... by idownvoted on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:05AM (#26940368)
> upholding their morals

What ethics are you talking about?

The ones where they silenced "Far-Right" Sceptics of Corona-Measures in Europe? A rapper responding with "ok, dude" to a trans person? HK Virologist Li Meng-Yan? The government of Hungary?

Or where they permanently ban conservative cartoonists, the MyPillow guy, Project Veritas – but not the Ayatollah?

AFAIC there's nothing special here to see. Standard Twitter Behaviour.

Also OP's critique is misguided, as there is no specific Indian law Twitter would have broken (according to the article) if it hadn't complied with the government's request. Likewise, there was no law forcing twitter to permanently ban the accounts I've mentioned.

Twitter is just a typical SV org, laden with upper-class virtue-signalers, who couldn't even notice their own bigotry if the stench of human-feces covered San Francisco actually made it into their comfy homes.