Curiously enough, one of the consequences of the rise of YC-like investors is that it will no longer be so easy to pull the sort of trick you claim Oracle pulled. We get common stock, so you can't screw the common sharedholders without screwing us, which most people would think twice about.
You can rest assured that if you put your 4+ years into a YC company, and it gets sold while you are no longer with it, your interests and YCs will be aligned. With a YC company, your vested common stock actually _means_ something when you leave the company. (Or, at least it means you and YC will get screwed equally - and as PG rather ominously said, that is something "which most people would think twice about." :-) )
I respectfully disagree with PG on how rare it is for employees who've left a company to get zeroed out or severely diluted compared to the ongoing-employees in an acquisition deal. I've heard enough anecdotes to convince me it is far from "very rare."
Like O'Shaughnessy said: "You’ve got to be in it to win it."
If so, perhaps you got lucky :)
Sounds like you didn't exercise the options and then didn't participate in the sale later.
The employees still at the company received substantial retention bonuses. The only one of these bonuses disclosed in the purchase papers I signed was that the president got an additional bonus of perhaps a year's salary, but later other employees told me they got substantial retention bonuses, too.
I don't feel like I got "screwed", exactly. I was a bit disappointed in the quantity, but it was a big improvement over what happened with KnowNow, where I never got back any of the US$6000 or so I spent to exercise my options, as the company's successive VC-approved management teams gradually mismanaged the company into bankruptcy.
It even said so at the top of the contract where it said the purpose of the options were retention and not remuneration.
Because only the best and brightest would understand what it actually meant?
> there are probably any number of ways that you will get wiped out if you are no longer with them
That's why Facebook employees sell their options on secondary markets.
In theory, the board of the acquiree thus has a "yes/no" decision to make, and whether or not it screws non-employee common stockholders, the "yes" decision might be in the greatest interest of the maximum number of shareholders.
It's a lot more complicated than this, but if you want an illustration of why it will cost you 6 figures to lose a court case over this issue, there you go.
I actually like the honesty of this quote:
"Silver Lake declined to comment. When asked about Lee’s situation, Skype spokesman Brian O’Shaughnessy said, “You’ve got to be in it to win it. The company chose to include that clause in the contract in order to retain the best and the brightest people to build great products. This individual chose to leave, therefore he doesn’t get that benefit.”"
Most people will look at it and say "What an Asswad" - but at least he's not being a hypocrite. That's precisely what everyone in the M&A team is _thinking_ they just aren't _saying_ it.
This is another take on what Oracle did when they bought Oblix (I had just left Oblix in 1999) Oracle gave MegaBonuses to all the existing employees and executives, two of the founders, and paid absolutely nothing for the common shares. The acquisition price was still $100Million plus, but there was only enough money to cover the preferred options + liquidation preferences in the "on the record" purchase prices. Effectively, they wiped out all the employees who were common shareholders, but no longer with the company (or were part of the 15-20 out of 100 who were laid off during the acquisition) while taking care of the VCs and the acquired employees. (As a side bonus, they called the money they gave to the acquired employees "Retention Bonuses" - which resulted in the top people having to hang around for another year)
Lesson to be learned: When you leave a company, and it is still private - if they are Sold, instead of going public, there are probably any number of ways that you will get wiped out if you are no longer with them - possible exception if you are a founder with a significant percentage of the company, and you might be able to raise a stink for minority shareholder rights. Then you'll get a "consulting bonus" to shut you up.
This story is more common than not.