Re:Backdoored password manager stole data from as many as 29...
by tediousdemise on Saturday April 24, 2021 @09:55PM
(#26929723)
That’s a thoughtful consideration. My logic is that a personal salting algorithm could be compromised after several points of failure, whereas a password manager can be compromised by a single point of failure.
The former requires trust in myself to create a strong algorithm, and the latter requires trust in a black box.
Re:Backdoored password manager stole data from as many as 29...
by scrollaway on Saturday April 24, 2021 @10:22PM
(#26929851)
It doesn't have to be a black box. There are open source password managers. Bitwarden and Keepassxc are two very good ones.
And keep in mind that even if you can create a reasonably strong algorithm which will both be memorable and resistant to reverse engineering, most people won't. Password managers aren't just good for professionals, they're leagues ahead of anything "mere mortals" use. My mom uses 1password -- that's not a slight, I mean that literally; I put her on my family plan.
Re:Backdoored password manager stole data from as many as 29...
by tediousdemise on Saturday April 24, 2021 @10:28PM
(#26929880)
I’m in support of password managers if they promote better security hygiene for the average user. Particularly, preventing the most heinous of all password crimes: reuse.
Re:Backdoored password manager stole data from as many as 29...
by serial_dev on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:18AM
(#26930693)
I use an open source password manager, but in the end, I still "trust a black box". I never looked into the source code in detail, nor would I have the knowledge to find some vulnerabilities that later can be used to expose my passwords. It might not be a black box for you, but for all intents and purposes it is for me.
This can be an OK strategy as long as your salting algorithm is not easy enough to figure out by looking at a few password breaches that you (now or in the future) are exposed by.
It can work if you’re smart about the algorithm, but if someone can guess your algorithm by looking at a few leaked passwords, it can provide a false sense of security.