News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by anticodon on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:14AM (#26903663)
Pasternak was given Nobel prize for "Doctor Zhivago". When reading the book I was disappointed a bit: why give such a high prize for such a boring book. Only about 15-20 years later I understood that Nobel Prize is mostly about politics, not literature.

I don't know if Maria is a good poet. I'm not a big fan of poetry. Opened a couple of her old poems (on stihi.ru) and wasn't impressed.

But since almost half of the article is devoted to how it is important to be in opposition to the current Russian government and how it's a good thing to vilify Russian past (especially Soviet past), I tend to assume that she's an ordinary poet (maybe not bad but definitely not exceptional like the article claims) that is just being used as an ideological weapon against Russia.

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by bryanrasmussen on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:24AM (#26903792)
>Pasternak was given Nobel prize for "Doctor Zhivago"

When Boris Pasternak, under fire from Soviet authorities, turned down a Nobel Prize. - https://lithub.com/when-boris-pasternak-under-fire-from-sovi...

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by cafard on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:51PM (#26906594)
There are definitely politics around the Nobel Prize for literature, though it is not always clear what they are--I don't really follow it.

But Mikhail Sholokov was in good odor with the Soviet government, and he got the prize for literature in 1965.

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by anticodon on Friday April 23, 2021 @03:02AM (#26911840)
I guess sometimes you have to award the prize based on the merit. Otherwise it would be too obvious.

Just like propaganda uses lies mixed up with truths to be less evident.

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by cafard on Friday April 23, 2021 @10:08AM (#26914931)
I'm not sure that qualified critics regard Sholokov's as an example of a merit-based prize. I haven't read the books in about 50 years, though.
Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:51PM (#26906584)
> Pasternak was given Nobel prize for "Doctor Zhivago". When reading the book I was disappointed a bit: why give such a high prize for such a boring book.

Maybe other people liked it, even if you didn't?

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by anticodon on Friday April 23, 2021 @03:01AM (#26911829)
> Maybe other people liked it, even if you didn't?

Never saw anyone who liked it. Everybody I asked about Doctor Zhivago, said it is graphomania (I don't know if it is customary to call bad books by this name in English, but we usually use this word).

Re:Maria Stepanova, one of Russia's greatest living poets, c... by wolverine876 on Friday April 23, 2021 @04:52PM (#26919067)
> graphomania (I don't know if it is customary to call bad books by this name in English, but we usually use this word)

Great word! And as someone who knows a bit about English literature, I've never heard it before.

It's a common trope about widely respected, intellectual works, 'nobody really likes them'. (The following is not about you; I don't know you at all, of course:) Frankly, I think people can find them difficult, naturally, and an anti-intellectual response is an easy cover story that they know will be socially accepted. Lots of people like these works, including Dr Zhivago and Maria Stepanova. As I've grown older I've learned that if I don't like it then usually there's something I'm missing, which an opportunity for me to learn. As I've grown more sophisticated, I've learned why they are so admired - I just lacked the background to grasp it before. Certainly, reading these works in school was often impractical. Now, I'm sorry I don't have the time to read them all.