News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by MrMan on Thursday April 22, 2021 @09:09AM (#26902322)
I agree we already have a system of money and trust. Bitcoin energy demands will scale much more than any other uses of the energy grid going forward, so our entire economy becomes slaved to preserving bitcoin. A dystopia
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by rfd4sgmk8u on Thursday April 22, 2021 @10:01AM (#26902827)
We do NOT have money and trust today. Every single government ever has debased their currency. Central banks cannot be trusted not to destroy your hard earned savings. A dystopia is being enslaved to the existing economic debt machine, rather than being free to trade the hardest money ever invented by humans. When folks understand this, they run to the fiat exits.
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by rspeele on Thursday April 22, 2021 @12:25PM (#26904623)
If the dollar inflates to hell, I wouldn't lose much. I'd still have my skills, to work for a living. I'd still have my house, my car, my workshop, my tools, my computers, etc. Unless it's a total collapse I'll still have my stocks, too.

Preserving my wealth in the event of the dollar rapidly losing value is not a problem for me. I'm 90% OK on that front without even trying particularly hard to do anything about it.

What would be a problem for me, is that a failing dollar might be a symptom of the US government failing, in which case society would be falling apart around me. If basic services like roads, infrastructure, fire and police, electricity and clean running water aren't working properly nationwide, it's going to interfere with my life big time. Maybe directly, maybe indirectly: e.g. my grocery store has trouble restocking because the supply chain is not running smoothly. Bitcoin doesn't help me with that type of problem at all.

I'd be better off trying to keep my government functional by promoting and voting for good policies, staying involved at the local level, and generally acting as a participant in government rather than a subject of it. Playing John Galt and pretending that I'm just going to have my own safe little bitcoin world if our government fails, so I don't care and in fact assume that it WILL fail, would be both sickeningly cynical (regarding society's outcome) and naively optimistic (regarding my own outcome).

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by Hermio on Thursday April 22, 2021 @10:06AM (#26902903)
To trust whom instead?

How would a world, realisticly speaking, look like if we ever reach a dystopian level where we all stop using the currencies of our own countries?

Srsly, if i stop trusting in the Euro, i can't imagine how our whole economy has to look like. I think we might have a lot of bigger issues at this point in time as bitcoin and probably not enough resources anymore to run bitcoin.

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by merpnderp on Thursday April 22, 2021 @10:31AM (#26903171)
Your "dystopian" world was the status quo for thousands of years as people used gold. You don't have to imagine how the economy would look, you could just pick up a history book.
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by gamblor956 on Thursday April 22, 2021 @05:49PM (#26908606)
Gold was not a universal currency, and it wasn't a currency in common use.

You could pick up a history book, and you would learn that gold was almost never used as currency because it was simply too rare, and too valuable for the amounts traded in normal commerce.

Rather, silver was the currency of choice in Europe and most of Asia, with lower-value denominations eventually showing up as coins made of less valuable metals.

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by rfd4sgmk8u on Thursday April 22, 2021 @10:21AM (#26903056)
Math and Energy. That's the beautiful thing. If you trust the ECDSA is secure, and you trust that SHA256 is secure - You don't need to trust the individual network participants.

If ECDSA or SHA256 were shown to be weaker than believed, they can be substituted in the bitcoin codebase (given approval of all participants, which are incentivized to ensure the computational security of the protocol).

The energy is the barrier to prevent malicious parties from rewinding history. Fundamental, understood quantities in the universe is far better than the political whims of the party in charge.

What does hyperbitcoinization look like? This infographic video provides some introduction to what this could be: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pDlaOGA2ac (Bitcoin: Everything there is, divided by 21 million)

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by zepto on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:38AM (#26903977)
You will still have political parties. They will be the ones with the militaries.

The endgame of HODL is a digital Fort Knox. Under the gold standard people didn’t actually exchange pieces of eight. They used paper money.

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by rfd4sgmk8u on Thursday April 22, 2021 @12:24PM (#26904603)
Yes, and what will they pay the soldiers? Worthless Fiat? Part of the debasement of the roman currency was to pay their armies. When you take that ability away from a state, how do you maintain them without unlimited funding? I don't know if bitcoin will end all wars, but it is far closer to a peaceful coexistence than debt-based economies.
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by zepto on Thursday April 22, 2021 @01:43PM (#26905583)
You might manage to cause an upheaval in which who runs the state changes hands, but nothing else will change for the better.

You’ll just get a new state which holds Bitcoin and issues debt based on Bitcoin in the form of promissory notes.

It’s pretty simple - just require taxes be paid in Bitcoin and use violence against those who don’t pay. Just like with other revolutionary wars, you pay generals with land and soldiers with the new currency (I.e. Bitcoin). Some of those generals will end up as a dictator or president depending on whether you are able to establish a democracy.

The state will be the ultimate HODLer just as it was with gold.

Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by MrMan on Friday April 23, 2021 @08:01AM (#26913808)
Yes I see bitcoin causing a lot of trouble, if it is successful. And by trouble I mean violence and political upheaval
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by matheusmoreira on Thursday April 22, 2021 @11:51AM (#26904159)
Nothing dystopian about it. Precious metals were standard currency for most of human history. It's the modern fiat currency system that's abnormal and highly inflated in value.
Re:SolarBatteryBitcoin by MrMan on Friday April 23, 2021 @07:57AM (#26913778)
We don't have trust? You should look deeper at every transaction and interaction you undertake, every day