News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by Havoc on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:29AM (#26887220)
It’s very neat for individual servers

Doesn’t work well for monitoring multiple servers though from what I can tell.

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by Abishek_Muthian on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @10:08AM (#26889885)
Neat project but I'm also confused with 'distributed'; It sounds like designed for monitoring multiple systems in a single dashbaord OOB with 'zero-config', But on further digging it seems like the distributed monitoring works 'only' with their cloud service[1].

Further clarity on this would be appreciated.

[1] https://github.com/netdata/netdata/blob/master/docs/quicksta...

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by ohthehugemanate on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:21PM (#26893494)
It's OOTB configured to use their free cloud service, but with 2 lines of config you can run your own central collection point instead. That's what I do for my home install.

BUT the UI for this is just a dropdown for each of your monitored servers. I've found I actually want to export data to a more robust system so I can view patterns across machines, too.

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by Abishek_Muthian on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:34PM (#26893675)
Thanks, So monitoring multiple machines is possible in a central console although not in a single dashboard. Hopefully it will be available soon and the project seems useful as it is as I like the idea of getting the system information of all the Servers, SBCs in my network.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by cakrit on Monday April 26, 2021 @11:36AM (#26943681)
This is what we do with Netdata Cloud. We want to keep the FOSS agent as a powerful single node monitoring tool and use the cloud for free infrastructure monitoring. You can see ktsaou's comment above on how we intend to monetize.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by szszrk on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:40AM (#26887318)
That is true. It has some features to allow to quickly jump between many machines, but indeed out of the box it is not for many servers at the same time.

BUT it can be configured to push data to Prometheus or similar (it's called a "backend") and some other integrations like notifications can be done.

Super neat project, very easy to set up. I highly recommend it to anyone who does performance troubleshooting. Netdata put into a standard Linux system will detect a lot of different things, like firewalls, containers, a lot of software like databases, queuing systems, mail systems and provide additional data every second.

Works flawlessly on Proxmox clusters!

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by ktsaou on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @11:32AM (#26891001)
Hi. I am the founder of Netdata.

We complement the Netdata agent with Netdata.Cloud, a free-forever SaaS offering that maintains all the principles of the Netdata agent, while providing infrastructure level monitoring and several additional convenience features.

In Netdata.Cloud, infrastructure is organized in war-rooms. On each war-room you will find the "Overview" page, that provides a fully automated dashboard, very similar to the one provided by the agent, in which every chart presented aggregates data from all servers in the war-room! Magic! Zero configuration! Fully automated!

Keep in mind that Netdata.Cloud is a thin convenience layer on top of the Netdata agent. We don't aggregate your data. Your data stay inside your servers. We only collect and store a few metadata (how many netdata agents you have, which metrics they collect, what alarms have been configured, when they triggered - but not the actual metric and log data of your systems).

Try it! You will be surprised!

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by Havoc on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:09PM (#26895494)
>I am the founder of Netdata.

Awesome! I see the free tier is indeed looking generous. Just hooked up a node and looks good - I like the calculate correlations on alerts thing in particular.

>Keep in mind that Netdata.Cloud is a thin convenience layer on top of the Netdata agent.

I see. Didn't know/understand that.

On the claim node page - could you perhaps add the kickstart bash script code too? I find myself needing them one after the other yet they're on different pages

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by andrewm4894 on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:25PM (#26896220)
Good to hear metrics correlation might be useful to you, just as background you can get more info here: https://www.netdata.cloud/blog/netdata-cloud-metric-correlat...

At the moment it's based on a short window of data so the focus is more for short term changes around an area of interest you have already found.

Longer term it would be cool to be able to use an anomaly score on the metrics themselves (or if a lot of alarms happen to be going off) to automatically find such regions for you so its more like surfacing insights to you as opposed to you having to already know a window if time you are interested in.

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by linsomniac on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:05PM (#26896023)
>Keep in mind that Netdata.Cloud is a thin convenience layer on top of the Netdata agent. We don't aggregate your data.

I didn't get that from the website until just now. I was looking and looking for how much it would cost to subscribe for our 150 dev/stg/prod VMs -- usually that's the killer.

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by dddw on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:38AM (#26887302)
Indeed, very handy tool. I once used it to discover that a new deployment generated spike CPU load. Reason was a badly implemented javascript doing a call on the db when hovering over a product (preview stock). Fun to see the actual correlation in a GUI in realtime.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by odyslam on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:12AM (#26887519)
Hey,

That sounds super interesting. Would you be interested to share the use-case in our forums? https://community.netdata.cloud

Ping me (@odyslam in the forum) if you need any help. We are always looking for awesome stories like that!

Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by dddw on Thursday April 22, 2021 @03:09AM (#26899704)
sure I'll be in between jobs soon, so I got some time to write something
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by PanosJee on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:01AM (#26887455)
Have you given a try to netdata.cloud? It's still early but solves this problem without any effort
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by _joel on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:08AM (#26887501)
There's a netdata prometheus exporter, but it overlaps a lot with node-exporter. If you're already runnning netdata however then it could be a good choice
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by lima on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @09:20AM (#26889296)
node_exporter is a lot more robust. Had both running for a while and netdata would get stuck when there's I/O trouble, while node_exporter was carefully built not to do any I/O and kept working just fine.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by _joel on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @10:10AM (#26889921)
Yes, I'd stick to node exporer where possible.
Re:Netdata: Open-source real-time monitoring platform by underhood on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:29AM (#26887638)
Did you try Netdata Cloud?