News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:03AM (#26886645)
You're comparing a risk-free rate (government bonds) with a rate on risky investments. Not really comparable at all. You can also find high-yield bonds (aka junk bonds) denominated in USD.

Also real interest rates are set by the market not governments. Monetary policy has, at best, only small effects on real rates (in theory it should have none).

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:36AM (#26886850)
> You're comparing a risk-free rate (government bonds) > with a rate on risky investments.

I don't think so. What is the "risky investment" here?

I compared lending of different currencies. In the case of Euros or Dollars, the lender is a government. In the case of crypto, the lender is a smart contract. Both are assumed to be reliable.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by kristjansson on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:13AM (#26887093)
If your smart contact is truly reliable and anyone can lend on it at a rate of their choosing, and all loans are fully and perfectly collateralized, the natural interest rate is exactly the risk free rate. As above, for ETH I think that ends being the return on staking, minus the costs of actually running a staking node - so pretty close to zero?
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by bidirectional on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:49AM (#26886933)
The last resort of the US, UK, etc. governments is to print money if they really want to avoid defaulting on their debt. Can smart contracts print money? Surely there must be some way for the counterparty in the contract to default.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:55AM (#26886976)
"Defaulting" in crypto means the collateral goes from the borrower to the lender. The collateral is always more valuable than the borrowed asset. Otherwise, all borrowers would "default" all the time. As there is no other downside to it than to lose your collateral.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:32AM (#26887250)
So, the borrower starts with X BTC. They post X BTC as collateral and borrow X-y BTC (where y > 0). Once the loan is paid off, they get the collateral back. This means they end up with X BTC minus the interest paid on X-y. Why would anyone do that?
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:45AM (#26887348)
I am not sure if lending makes sense if the collateral is the same asset that is borrowed.

A more typical example I can envision:

Someone owns land in Decentraland. The land is an NFT on the Ethereum blockchain. To make profits from the land they need to put a hotel on top of it. But they don't have the means to buy/build the hotel. So they lend Decentracoins (some other asset on the Ethereum blockchain) and provide the land as collateral.

If all goes well, the borrower buys/builds a hotel with the decentracoins. Makes more decentracoins from visitors. Pays back their debt.

If it does not work out, the land goes to the lender.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:11AM (#26887514)
> I am not sure if lending makes sense if the collateral is the same asset that is borrowed.

It doesn't. And if the collateral is a different asset, there is no certainty that the value of the collateral exceeds the value of the principal. So there's a risk involved and that explains the premium over the risk-free rate. It's got nothing to do with the fact that the loan is denominated in some cryptocurrency.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:25AM (#26887609)
> It doesn't

Proof needed. I can in fact think of counter examples:

Say there is a DAO that gives more voting power if you own more ETH. In that situation, it might make sense to borrow 900 in ETH with 1000 ETH collateral. Then you make your vote on the DAO with a power of 1900. And pay back 910 in ETH to the lender. The vote on the DAO might trigger an action that is worth more than the 10 ETH you paid in interest. For example if you run a company and the vote on the DAO was to buy a service from your company.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by dmihal on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @07:19AM (#26888065)
> it might make sense to borrow 900 in ETH with 1000 ETH collateral. Then you make your vote on the DAO with a power of 1900

No, you would vote on the DAO with a power of 900, because your original 1000 ETH collateral is being held by the lending protocol

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @12:54PM (#26892196)
Not necessarily. There are mulitple ways it could work.

Two examples:

The DAO could support the lending protocol. Counting your assets in the lending protocol towards your voting power.

The lending protocol could support the DAO. Not allowing you to withdraw you collateral but allowing you to signal something to the DAO.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:13AM (#26887090)
> What is the "risky investment" here?

Well, you tell me. Where do the profits come from?

> In the case of crypto, the lender is a smart contract.

That doesn't make sense. The smart contract is a contract, that is, an agreement between two or more parties. An agreement is not a lender. The lender is one of the parties.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:31AM (#26887233)
> The lender is one of the parties

The "parties" do not know each other. And it does not matter who put the contract up, who put assets in and who borrowed assets from the contract.

Because everything is in the smart contract. Even the assets. Are you aware that Ethereum contracts hold assets?

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:50AM (#26887384)
Let's pretend the lender is "smart contract" (even though it's not). You lend X to the smart contract, and after a while the smart contract pays you X+y. Where does the y come from?
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:54AM (#26887416)
> even though it's not

We should sort this out first. It does not make sense to discuss higher level concepts if we disagree on lower level concepts.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by inter_netuser on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:46AM (#26886909)
the risk-free bonds have failed numerous times. Often they wiped out investors entirely.

Full list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_debt_crises

They cannot print value, only paper.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:08AM (#26887059)
And you'll find these failed governments bonds were paying a considerable risk premium, i.e. a spread over the risk-free rate.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @05:50AM (#26887387)
Not necessarily. Since the government can print the money they lend, they can dictate the risk premium. They can keep it as low as they want.

Italy and some other European countries are basically broke. But they pay less interest than the USA.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:32AM (#26887669)
The risk premium is the interest rate spread that investors demand. Not clear how the government can "dictate it" by printing money.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:36AM (#26887697)
The government prints money and buys government bonds with it. And other assets. When you have infinite amounts of money, you can dictate the risk premium.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @06:53AM (#26887824)
> When you have infinite amounts of money, you can dictate the risk premium.

But how? If you're an investor who is considering buying government bonds, how can the government dictate the interest rate that you are willing to accept in return for buying the bonds?

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by inter_netuser on Thursday April 22, 2021 @02:04AM (#26899276)
read up on yield curve control. https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2020/august/what-y...

Basically: central bank has infinite money and buys all the debt at 0%, and outbids everyone else.

Simple.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @07:13AM (#26887997)
The government is an investor. If the government buys enough bonds at X% interest rate, that is the market rate.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @08:22AM (#26888651)
Sorry, that's not how it works. The governments runs an auction where the bonds are sold to investors. That sets the market rate. The government would not buy its own bonds in the auction (it wouldn't make sense) and cannot force investors to buy the bonds at a particular rate.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by ArtTimeInvestor on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:02PM (#26892308)
In Europe, the government does buy its own bonds. Via the central bank. They print the money. Hold it for a few days. Then buy government bonds with it.

Read what the european central bank (ECB) writes about it:

https://www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/scpwps/ecbwp1956.en.pdf

https://www.ecb.europa.eu/mopo/implement/pepp/html/index.en....

Search for "government bonds" in these papers.

Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by lottin on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @02:39PM (#26893743)
The central bank buys bonds in the secondary market, and any effect on the risk premium is only indirect (investors perceive the bonds as being safer). This is completely different from the government "dictating the risk premium". The risk premium is the spread deemed necessary by the market to compensate for credit risk, and as such it can't be dictated by anyone.
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by cinquemb on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @04:06PM (#26894741)
Then there is also the downstream effects of buying these "safe" bonds on the secondary market: strip mining the "highest" quality collateral out of markets, and making markets ever more reliant upon fewer on tradeable cusips…
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by cinquemb on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @09:08AM (#26889167)
Yet, i've seen defi protocols that tried to fix the rate + maturity of said "bonds" they were offering and be complete baffled why demand for them changed when market conditions changed… wish there were more voices like yours in the sea of fecal matter floating around in the ecosystem…
Re:Ethereum: A Store of Value with Cash Flow [pdf] by MrMan on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @01:27PM (#26892696)
Thank you for wading in and trying to speak to them sensibly