Re:Deriving the piano keyboard from biological principles us...
by SeanLuke on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:51PM
(#26867179)
12-note equal temperament is a reasonable local minimum but it is by no means the best in the sense of roughness: 31-note is better. Not to promote 31-note (which I do not use), but how is it that this article can arrive at 12-note in some sense of optimality with regard to roughness criteria when it is clearly not?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Deriving the piano keyboard from biological principles us...
by sideshowb on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:17AM
(#26872419)
Hello. I wasn't suggesting 12 is optimal, so much as trying to explain the link between clustering and pianos. I guess by going for 2^7~=(3/2)^12 over other such correspondences I'm bringing some history to the table, intentionally or not.