News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by robert_foss on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:37PM (#26864730)
ARM can't flourish under Nvidia, which customer would prefer to buy IP from a potential competitor rather than from a neutral provider.

The ecosystem business model that defines Arm simply doesn't have any space for them being perceived as biased this way or that way.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tw04 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:02PM (#26865099)
>ARM can't flourish under Nvidia, which vendor would prefer to buy IP from direct competitor rather than from a neutral provider.

I would imagine plenty. Take a look at the list of vendors that sell Nvidia GPUs despite the fact that Nvidia sells directly into the market.

>The ecosystem business model that defines Arm simply doesn't have any space for them being perceived as biased this way or that way.

I don't know, Intel's recent announcement that they're going to start licensing their IP directly contradicts that. I don't think Intel would waste what will likely be a fairly large amount of money spinning up a new business unit without first doing some market research and ensuring there's demand for it.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by smachiz on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:12PM (#26865254)
When you're thirsty, you buy from the person selling water. I don't think you'll find a lot of love lost between the OXMs and nvidia. I'm sure they would love more competitors in the space.

We have people licensing Arm and building interesting CPUs (Ampere).

I'm not sure that the NVIDIA acquisition would be good for the market or for Arm.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by volta83 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:09AM (#26872365)
> We have people licensing Arm and building interesting CPUs (Ampere).

> I'm not sure that the NVIDIA acquisition would be good for the market or for Arm.

NVIDIA works with Ampere and just started shipping server nodes with Ampere CPUs.

If that was bad for Ampere, they would not be working with NVIDIA on this.

Not that you are right/wrong (I don't know), but Ampere appears to be an example that shows the opposite of what you are trying to claim.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tw04 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:15PM (#26865300)
You haven't explained why Intel is entering the licensing business. If vendors have no desire to get their licensing from a company that competes in the space, there should be no demand for licensing from Intel, all of those OXMs should be going to ARM.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by joe_the_user on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:57PM (#26867249)
The thing about Nvidia is they have spent a lot of money creating a kind of chip+ecosystem situation that is unique and superior to all that's out there. And they charge a gruesome premium on that and use product and license differentiation to extract the maximum in each submarket. It's logical and perhaps necessary strategy to get a return on their huge investment. But it is just as logical that everyone hates them. This is what successful investment leading to a unique technology leading to a monopoly position looks like.

Intel once was in a similar position to Nvidia and everyone hated them then. The failure of their last few generation has meant they don't have as strong a monopoly position and so have to start taking a more conciliatory position with the market. I don't know if they're succeeding here but it's obvious they've been "humbled".

Now, maybe Nvidia will treat ARM completely differently than it's GPUs. But companies tend to have single cultures and so it's easy to imagine Nvidia squeezing dimes from other ARM customers, where ARM has been at the opposite side of the market, reasonably priced, good-enough tech. Charging a high premium on your capital investment works for a market leader, that uses the money for more investment. But for a market followers, the same strategy results in market share shrinking 'till the whole thing dies (not that this isn't a way to make money but when the thing dies, some people are unhappy).

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by robert_foss on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:27PM (#26865499)
Nor have we seen any serious uptake of Intels licensing business. It's a paper launch.

Adding to that Intel didn't exactly pick this model as their first choice. The combination of a wafer production shortage and Intels CPUs underperforming is what drove Intel to this. It is neither Intels or most feasible clients first choice.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by smachiz on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:19PM (#26865365)
You haven't demonstrated that anyone /is/ entering into contracts with Intel.

Intel has done lots of things that it turns out people didn't want to do (with them).

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tw04 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:32PM (#26865565)
They absolutely have people signing up, none of it has been publicly announced (that I've seen) but we already know they were doing custom designs for Facebook/Amazon/MS so they would be logical first-takers.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by Judgmentality on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:37PM (#26865650)
> They absolutely have people signing up, none of it has been publicly announced

I can't tell if you're saying you have insider information or you're just assuming they're getting customers with no evidence.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by smachiz on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:54PM (#26865903)
None of those are OXMs and are the end customer. That is totally different than what your original assertion was.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tw04 on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:32PM (#26866992)
So tell me what an OXM is? Because Amazon sells outpost, an appliance, to end users.

And Annapurna (owned by Amazon) sells CPUs to all sorts of vendors, including Ubiquiti and Synology.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by volta83 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:07AM (#26872348)
> ARM can't flourish under Nvidia,

Why?

> which customer would prefer to buy IP from a potential competitor rather than from a neutral provider.

The same customers that buy NVIDIA GPUs, NVIDIA interconnects, support NVIDIA's software, etc.

You seem to be suggesting that this "somehow" matters, but are not explaining "why" do you think this matters.

AFAICT if AMD wants to ship a data-center node, it needs Mellanox interconnect, and has to buy that from NVIDIA, pretty much in the same way that NVIDIA ships AMD CPUs with their DGX boxes.

There are dozens of thousands of pattents that all these companies need to buy from each other on a regular basis to function.

I don't see how this particular change makes the status quo worse.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tokyojoe on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:54PM (#26864989)
Power consumption is a key application requirement for mobile. I don’t know that GPU’s are designed to run on the smell of an oil rag which the ARM processor cores do.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by plekter on Monday April 19, 2021 @03:07PM (#26866722)
Mobile GPUs (Imagination PowerVR, Qualcomm Adreno, Arm Mali, Apple's GPU) are exactly that.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by volta83 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:12AM (#26872389)
Doesn't NVIDIA ship the CPU for the Nintendo Switch?

Not as low power as mobile phones, but not completely far away either.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by Vvector on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:47PM (#26864872)
The companies that directly compete with Nvidia (AMD & Intel) are not ARM customers. ARM's biggest customers are mobile phones, which could benefit from an Nvidia GPU
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by adrian_b on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:32PM (#26865567)
Qualcomm is a direct competitor of NVIDIA (e.g. for automotive and robotics) and an important ARM customer.

Until now the competing products of NVIDIA and Qualcomm differed in NVIDIA having worse CPUs and better GPUs and Qualcomm having better (ARM-designed) CPUs and worse GPUs.

I do not find it believable that in the future NVIDIA would ever provide Qualcomm with better CPUs than those of NVIDIA products.

Given NVIDIA's desire of dominating the datacenters, it is also hard to believe that they will give to all other companies who will attempt to design server CPUs new ARM cores at the same time when they will be available for the internal NVIDIA design teams.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by volta83 on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @05:15AM (#26872409)
I don't see how this deal changes that.

ARM does not make CPUs (it makes CPU IP), Qualcomm does.

The fact that NVIDIA builds bad ARM CPUs does not change with the acquisition as far as I can tell.

For that NVIDIA would need to invest a lot of R&D into their CPU team, and again, if it does that, it can compete with Qualcomm, independently of whether the acquisition takes place.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by jorvi on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:07PM (#26865186)
Considering how well Apple's M1 is performing, I suspect within 10 years the majority of new desktops and laptops sold will be ARM-based, with both Intel and AMD having to either adapt or languish.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by karteum on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:54PM (#26865908)
Difficult to forecast within 10 years... maybe you are right, maybe it could be Alibaba/Allwinner/Rockchip with RISC-V designs ! :D
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by hellotomyrars on Monday April 19, 2021 @08:58PM (#26869604)
I think this is accurate if we see a substantial uptake of cloud/remote services for what are currently the most common high demand compute consumer devices (Game consoles + PC). ARM is already proving to be a winner in the datacenter as it becomes available so it seems all but inevitable.

I think the overall trend is still accurate and in either case ARM + Nvidia is (or would be) a compelling provider of hardware but the segment of the market that needs/relies on X86 architecture does seem to be shrinking.

Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by detaro on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:43PM (#26866473)
NVidia has embedded product lines, which have a lot more competitors. All of which depend on ARM licenses.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by robert_foss on Monday April 19, 2021 @02:42PM (#26866464)
Couldn't be further from the truth. All Arm SOC manufacturers are competitors of Nvidia.
Re:Proposed acquisition of ARM Limited by NVIDIA: public int... by tokyojoe on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:32PM (#26867643)
ARM is used across a huge array of end market segments. Granted, none are as big as mobile, but they’re important nonetheless. To say that all ARM SoC vendors are competitors is therefore not strictly true.