News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by podiki on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:25PM (#26864563)
....I have lots of questions about this "homegrown web tracking tool" (assuming this isn't still part of a joke?). What??? Was this opt-in? Did they track across everyone? What was collected? This is troubling, to say the least.
Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by benpopper1 on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:38PM (#26865663)
Hey there - I work at SO. Understand your concern and wanted to share some details.

Browsers fire a copy event when you copy, just like a click event fires when you press on a button. We just added analytics to it like we would any other feature on the site.

We didn't track the content of your copy (browsers don't let you see the text content) but we did track the following:

Meta data about the post and it's parent post like the id, owner, score, tags, if it was a question/answer, if it was accepted

If your copy was from a code block or from text content

The Referer header

Standard analytics properties like the date/time, approximated location, account metadata

Here's our privacy policy on analytics: "Analytics information Stack Overflow uses data analytics to ensure site functionality and to optimize our Product and Service offerings to you. We use web browser and mobile analytics to allow us to understand Network and Apps functionality. In doing so, we record information including, for example how often you visit the Network, how often you contribute content, Network and Apps performance data, errors and debugging information, and the type of activity you engage in while on the Network or in your use of our Products and Services. We may on occasion share this information with third parties for research or product and services optimization."

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by quesera on Monday April 19, 2021 @04:01PM (#26867307)
> Browsers fire a copy event when you copy, just like a click event fires when you press on a button. We just added analytics to it like we would any other feature on the site.

This is a bit misleading.

More accurate would be: Stack Overflow is able to configure our web pages to track certain of your activities on the page, including Copy and Click. We do that.

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by jodrellblank on Tuesday April 20, 2021 @06:28PM (#26882733)
This is a bit misleading; "onclick" and "oncopy" are part of the HTML standard that "must be supported by all HTML elements [...] and that must be supported by all Document objects"

[1] https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/webappapis.html#handl...

[2] https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/webappapis.html#handl...

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by quesera on Wednesday April 21, 2021 @10:52AM (#26890406)
That's right, but nothing mandates that the web page configures these event handlers, and sends these events to the tracking server operated by Stack Overflow.

My point is: "We can make this thing happen, and we do so and record the results" is more accurate than "this interesting thing just happens, and we observe" which is the tone of the original.

Most sites do not configure their pages to track copy events. SO does the unusual thing. They should be honest about that.

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by podiki on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:53PM (#26865897)
I appreciate the response and detail here, would have liked to see that in the original post.
Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by somehnguy on Monday April 19, 2021 @12:55PM (#26865002)
Serious question: why is this troubling?

I don't see the big deal, at all. This is absolutely nothing compared to what big advertising & social media do. Taking a count of people who hit ctr+c? Who cares, I can't see any possible scenario of how that data could be used in a bad way unless you think SO is going to email employers with a time spent & ctrl+c count or something?

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by cryptoz on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#26865110)
Not OP, but, the troubling parts for me are 1) the tone of the post, and 2) the larger-than-SO issue of the gap in understanding copy+paste for the average user.

1) The post says "unfortunately" they cannot tie logged-out users to their logged-in account. In no moral way is this a reasonable perspective to me. It is extremely fortunate that SO does not build the tech to track you as a logged-in user when you are logged out. That's a bad precedent to set. Sure, some sites do that, but I think they shouldn't.

Other examples of the tone in the article abound. It's troubling for sure.

2) It is up to the web devs themselves to decide what goes in your clipboard. Many users don't know this. Sites that exploit the gap between user expectation of privacy while copy+paste as well as tracking do not match with reality. Stack Overflow is merely one of many players here, but they way they exploit this gap is mildly upsetting.

Something needs to be done, either technically or communication to users, about copy+paste reality.

Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by somehnguy on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:09PM (#26865203)
Thanks for the explanation. Honestly I still don't see the big deal though. It's just a little bit of fun with an interesting statistic, not everything needs to be so doom & gloom serious.
Re:How often do people copy and paste from Stack Overflow? by podiki on Monday April 19, 2021 @01:55PM (#26865929)
I wasn't trying to be all "doom and gloom," but as one concerned about tracking (yes, all the social media and stuff you mention, which I try to be very conscious about) the casual mention of adding in tracking to a particular event really could have used more context and explanation (especially given the technical audience). I love see the data analysis on SO, but there is a general need for transparency and opt-in on the internet. Not saying this was a huge deal, but the fact that it can be so casual speaks to the larger issues I'd say.