News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:50AM (#26818786)
Inquisition meant still burning or torturing people to death - or threatening of doing so, if they continue to speak heresy, like "the earth moves around the sun".

(Galileo and the Inquisition)

Inquisition (which still exists today! only with no physical authority anymore) might be a bit missrepresented in their thirst for blood - but the harm they done over the centuries to free thinking and therefore advancement of science and technology and therefore progress of humanity as its whole - is something on its own validating their bad reputation.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by diegocg on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:56AM (#26819298)
> torturing people to death

No, the Spanish Inquisition strictly forbid torturing people to death (death only happened when people were condemned to it). There were, in fact, regulations that required to not provoke any bleeding (even just a drop) during the torture -you can cause severe damage without bleeding of course-, and the process had to stop if it happened. A person was dedicated to oversee the entire process and stop it in these cases.

What people often misses is that these tortures weren't anything special at the time. The right to not be tortured is quite modern. The Inquisition just took a look at what the existing institutions were doing, and imitated it (regulating the entire process in the way: there were only three types of torture methods allowed, for example)

The Inquisition wasn't an unified entity either - Galileo was condemned by the Roman Inquisition, but the Spanish Inquisition didn't have any problem with his theories and didn't forbid his books.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:14AM (#26819479)
Sorry, but for me burning to death is torturing to death.

And I am aware, that the real inquisition was much more restrained, than their image - but it doesn't change anything for the better, of what they did.

They represented the highest authority in terms of what was allowed to be thought and said. And they did use tortue and execution to cement their authority. Basically killing scientists for doing science. And stopping people to become scientists in the first place, as everyone knew what happened to free thinking scientists. Rather work your field, peaseant - or pray your prayers low monk.

I cannot see anything positive in that institution.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by anthk on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:46AM (#26821898)
That's false. More like confronting Catholicism, but even monks did science. How do you think cathedrals were built in Middle Ages? Weapons? Armory? Trebuchets? Astronomics to sail to "The Indians"?

Monks were very faith-obsessed but not ultimately dumb to power.

Also, the School of Salamanca (around Don Quixote era) was the roots of Humanism.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:33PM (#26822693)
Did I say no science happened?

I said it was blocked a lot.

Because when every research that you do, has to align to the literal words of a big book, under the explicit threat of burning at the stake - it is surprising, how much progress was possible despite of it.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by anthk on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:52PM (#26823006)
OFC, but it wasn't just an empire made of castles, churches and hamlets.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by Mikhail_Edoshin on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:51AM (#26819253)
Do you know Galileo received a pension from the church? Galileo had many admirers among the clergy, including the pope himself, yet by publishing a book he broke an earlier agreement on not teaching his theory and this wasn't taken lightly. A modern analogy would be to break an NDA.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:06AM (#26819400)
Yes I know, that Galileo prefered the money and luxery(and de facto imprisonment) over death. How noble of the inquisition to offer him that.

And comparing that with breaking an NDA, well I don't know. I didn't know NDA's contain that.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by User23 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:13AM (#26820041)
If violating your NDA reveals a trade secret you can face prison, yes[1].

[1] https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-trade-sec...

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:16AM (#26820071)
with the alternative of death at the stake?
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by mwigdahl on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:23AM (#26821568)
No, but that's why it's an analogy (and a reasonable one) rather than an exact equivalence.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by hutzlibu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:43AM (#26821844)
You really think it is a reasonable analogy to threaten someone with burning at the stake and jailing someone because of a trade secret?
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by User23 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:00PM (#26825439)
Yes, it follows from the definition of analogy. Perhaps you are thinking of equivalence instead? In that case you are correct that the two are not equivalent.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by bobthechef on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:22AM (#26819552)
> Inquisition meant still burning or torturing people to death - or threatening of doing so, if they continue to speak heresy, like "the earth moves around the sun".

A perfect example of the tidy little "big bad Church vs. SCIENCE (tm)" fables that refuse to die. The first problem with your statement is that somehow heliocentrism is heretical. Show me where this contradicts dogma. You can't because it's not true. A moment of reflection should make it obvious that it is utterly irrelevant, from a theological perspective, whether the ball of burning gas revolves around the rock or the rock resolves around the burning ball of gas. To claim that because the Bible uses language that speaks of the sun rising and setting, it must mean that such trivialities are theologically important is as absurd as claiming that geocentrism is widespread today because we still use that language. This is phenomenological and descriptive language that is only used as an occasion to convey some other point, not a scientific explanation. Common sense is easily blinded by bigotry.

> (Galileo and the Inquisition)

This whole "affair" actually lasted decades and really had nothing to do with heliocentrism. Galileo had made political enemies and was known for his harassment and vicious remarks directed at people in power, who, btw, were slow to anger; it took decades for him to finally be put under...house arrest overlooking the Vatican gardens. Seems pretty mild esp. given the witch hunts taking place in Protestant northern Europe at the time.

> Inquisition (which still exists today! only with no physical authority anymore) might be a bit missrepresented in their thirst for blood - but the harm they done over the centuries to free thinking and therefore advancement of science and technology and therefore progress of humanity as its whole - is something on its own validating their bad reputation.

Not this again. Show me where the brave, good, noble men of SCIENCE (tm) were prevented from climbing the hills of PROGRESS (tm) by the big, bad, mean old Church? If you peer a little more closely at the stock examples (Bruno is one), you find nothing of the sort. You find no such trend. This is a historically illiterate trope that, frankly, is embarrassing.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by cygx on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:35AM (#26820274)
For reference, here's an excerpt of Galileo's Papal Condemnation of 1633:

> We say, pronounce, sentence, and declare that you, the said Galileo, by reason of the matters adduced in trial, and by you confessed as above, have rendered yourself in the judgment of this Holy Office vehemently suspected of heresy, namely, of having believed and held the doctrine—which is false and contrary to the sacred and divine Scriptures—that the Sun is the center of the world and does not move from east to west and that the Earth moves and is not the center of the world; and that an opinion may be held and defended as probably after it has been declared and defined to be contrary to the Holy Scripture; [...]

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by viklove on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:57AM (#26822074)
Man, reading this thread makes me feel like I'm on some pro-christian, fringe, conspiracy-theory subreddit. This is what HN has become? How weird.
Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by goto11 on Friday April 16, 2021 @11:06AM (#26834790)
Catholic thinkers have been building a revisionist conternarrative to the prevalent "age of reason" narrative. The counter narrative is that the Church was actually the ones promoting science, Galileo was just being an asshole, and the inquisition was really a fair and decent institution which only tortured lightly and only burned people when it was absolutely unavoidable.

But yeah, I am surprised how prevalent this thinking is here on HN.

Re:We Keep Telling the Myth of a Renaissance Golden Age and ... by goto11 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:31AM (#26819626)
The church did also ban the astronomical works by Copernicus and Kepler.