News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by danboarder on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:20AM (#26817582)
This story reminded me of a project my father did with two 1965 Mercedes sedans; one was hit in the front, the other in the back. He cut them both in half where the roof meets the rear window, and welded and reassembled the two good halves into a perfectly functional car that we drove for years. Not the scale of the French submarine project, but the same kind of ingenuity -- it was still a big project to get everything rewired and all put back together, including bodywork and paint!
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by bloak on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:16AM (#26818062)
That sounds like the notorious "cut and shut" thing where criminals create a dangerous vehicle for the second-hand market, except that it's from a different era. Seeing as a 1965 Mercedes is built rather differently from a typical modern car, and safety standards have changed since then, too ... any comments on how hard it is to this without compromising safety?
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:17AM (#26818534)
Combining vehicles like this is one of those things that isn't bad but gets the Reddit experts screeching because their only experience is that their mom's sister's boyfriend's uncle's roommate got swindled by someone doing a crap job on a Civic that they thought they were getting a good deal on.

Vehicles build on frames are cut and extended/shortened all the time as a part of routine modifications for commercial use and it's far less labor intensive to "do right" than a unibody vehicle. Putting two good halfs together is no big deal and is a relatively standard operation, all the known techniques and whatnot transfers right over. (I assume a 60s Mercedes falls into this category.) Unibody vehicles are also routinely repaired in this manner in eastern Europe where it's cheaper to buy wrecked stuff from the west and fix than to buy new. In the west the limo and mobility van industry does very similar things (only they're inserting stuff in the middle rather than repairing the car)

People do cut and weld jobs all the time for their own personal vehicles and classic cars. When you're doing it for your own car or a car you don't intend to flip you can afford to spend the time to do it right.

Quick hackjobs are the issue, not the technique.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by hwillis on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:29AM (#26820207)
There is/was lots of speculative armchairing as well, when HSLAs started coming into the picture. Structural adhesives also get pointed to as a reason not to do big repairs like this. In practice it isn't really borne out.

HSLA (high strength low alloy) steels are stronger (and therefore lighter) than mild steels. Many alloy steels (non-HSLA) are sensitive to heat treatment and improper welds make them weaker, so tons of people were being very vocal about HSLAs ruining cars, making repairs impossible, etc etc. Things like saying you'd need proprietary filler to match the composition, that welds would be poison, etc. In reality it doesn't really make a difference.

Adhesives are also sometimes/often used to secure panels together instead of welds. The theory was that subtle differences in shape would introduce tensile stressed that would cause adhesives to pop in a crash. Not real. Alternatively stress during modifications could introduce cracks and weaken the adhesive- also bullshit, those adhesives go through stress every time they drive. They're fine.

They aren't invalid concerns, but unless you're putting a torch to the adhesive or welding seams down the middle of alloy beams, you aren't doing anything that will cause problems.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:39AM (#26821059)
I think with the benefit of hindsight structural adhesives make things easier. Way easier to apply glue and clamp (or whatever the instructions are) than to weld somewhere you can't see without a mirror or building a custom spot welder tip that replicates what the robot used in the factory. I also like that you can not ruin the paint around an area where you apply adhesive whereas welding usually cooks off the adjacent paint. This is very beneficial in environments with corrosion. Holy crap are the consumables expensive compared to welding though.

> Things like saying you'd need proprietary filler to match the composition, that welds would be poison, etc. In reality it doesn't really make a difference.

The nice thing is that the car OEMs are high enough volume that even if they use something exotic someone will come along with special consumables or procedures or procedures or whatever that makes it trivial to work with. I hope some other OEM's follow Tesla with the stainless and we get cheap weld backing tape as a result.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by Tade0 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:06AM (#26818452)
My friend is a car mechanic and his weekend car is a 1985 Nissan Z31, which he welded from two halves - front and back.

It's physically possible to do it and maintain reasonable safety but you need proper equipment, skills and time.

The frame is generally not designed to be welded like that, so without reinforcement it will be significantly weaker.

He did is as a hobby project but generally done properly such operations are not cost-effective.

Nevertheless it's still a service some shops provide at the cost of safety.

My aunt used to have such a car - she only noticed because she was blowing through sets of tires - the halves were misaligned(rotated) by less than one degree in each axis, but it was enough to make proper tire alignment impossible.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by himinlomax on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:07AM (#26819414)
> The frame is generally not designed to be welded like that, so without reinforcement it will be significantly weaker.

Welds can definitely be strong enough if done properly, as evidenced by the fact that welded parts involved in accidents can often be found to have broken somewhere other than a nearby weld.

However achieving the proper level of welding is easier said than done, and in particular being confident that a particular weld is done properly requires advanced equipment for non-destructive testing (x-ray, conductivity, echo ...)

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by RugnirViking on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:17AM (#26820082)
You can hit it with a hammer and listen carefully! (No really, i've done some work on industrial robotics welding and it does this to produce a map of the weld it just performed for strength testing purposes - it can be done at the same time as peening)
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:22AM (#26821552)
Yes, that's a good idea to get an idea of the hardness of a weld. Better yet: anneal your welds.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by extraAccount on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:36AM (#26819124)
Depending on where you live, buying a car with this modification may require disclosure. There are plenty of videos on youtube about people buying cars which end up being two parts welded together. I don't think it is safe at all.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by Tade0 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:09AM (#26819429)
Poland - we're in the "sweet spot" of having:

-Schengen(so a steady stream of cars imported from Germany with no additional fees).

-A Skilled workforce.

-Cost-conscious customers.

-Badly enforced regulations.

Which create an ideal environment for a cottage industry of shops which will take your storm-damaged aluminium roof sheets and turn them into an inspection, passing, moving car with a real VIN by next week.

I could create a Blade Runner'esque quote on stuff I've seen on the roads around here - especially regarding commercial vehicles.

It's less so like that than comparing to the 90s, but still.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by csunbird on Thursday April 15, 2021 @07:26AM (#26819031)
Welding chassis of a car is a practice strongly recommended against, since it makes it significantly weaker at the welding point(s). It is very unsafe, although since it is an oldtimer restoration project, I salute your friend with respect!
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by userbinator on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:20AM (#26820115)
Welding done correctly is as strong if not stronger than the base metal.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by meowster on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:40AM (#26821073)
The weld will be stronger, but the heat-affected metal will become weaker than the rest of the metal, which is why if it breaks, it will be next to the weld.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:26AM (#26821604)
Only when done improperly. Yes, this is a common failure mode, no, it does not have to be that way.

Typically the reason is not that the heat affected metal will be come weaker, typically the reason is that the weld is thicker than the material right next to it creating a stress point in the structure. The hardening can be taken care of by annealing.

The best way to fix cars is to increase the length of the weld if you can, the original weld points are there for a balance between economy and strength. If you start welding in 'original new and interesting places' you need to plan how you want to achieve the required strength since economy is likely the least of your worries.

Every stretch limo is essentially a demonstration piece to show that this does not need to be a problem, and that you actually can re-inforce a body quite nicely. Keep in mind that the wheelbase of a stretch limo pretty much guarantees much higher forces on all of the welding in the body including the existing seams.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by blagie on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:25AM (#26818592)
I can't imagine it'd be all too tough with a 1965 car and good welding technique. At the time, cars were still pretty over-built and over-engineered. Good welds are pretty darned tough. Most things, you can cut-and-dice without problems.

With a 2020 car? I wouldn't trust it unless the person performing the work was a pretty good engineer. As engineering is more optimized, you can't just do stuff like this without being very careful:

1) Welds do leave a heat-affected zone around the weld which is weaker. If you're overengineered (1956) and everything is thicker than necessary, this doesn't matter. If you're near-optimal (2020), and using the exact amount of material needed to avoid failure under expected driving conditions, you might weaken things enough to see failures.

2) If reinforced, you'll affect the overall systems design. Engineered objects flex. Making one part more rigid than expected will put additional strain on other parts.

Counterintuitive as it might sound, optimal engineering makes designs safer. You analyze failure modes, put in appropriate safety margins, and do things right. Engineering classes drill that over-engineering is bad engineering. The flip side, though, is that if you can't tweak optimized designs like you can over-engineered ones without being careful and thoughtful about it.

Same thing with bikes. You can fix up a $100 Huffy with any old welder. A $2000 steel frame with thin-wall double-butted tubes? You want a really skilled welder and close inspection to make sure it's not compromised.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jasonwatkinspdx on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:35AM (#26821719)
You're overstating the difficulty/brittleness of "engineered" objects.

I used to be around the rally racing scene, and it's utterly routine there to weld tons of re-enforcements into the unibody. Most people with the money will straight up laminate the suspension mounts with plate. The safety cage makes the car incredibly rigid, as does replacing all bushings. The cars work just fine. The people doing this have relatively ordinary welding skills. Modern cars are not some sort of high tech magic that can't be modified or repaired with ordinary metalworking skills... it's just usually not cost effective to do so.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:57AM (#26822086)
This is all true as long as the base material is steel. When you get into aluminum the number of people capable of producing good welds drops rapidly.

But you are on the money with the cost effectiveness bit, that's exactly why it is perfectly possible to do these modifications with confidence: you are not operating under a budget that gets counted out to the last 1/10th of a cent, so you can do it right, even if it costs a few bucks more. Something a car company operating at scale would never do. Once the cost constraint disappears there isn't a whole lot you can't do.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by blagie on Friday April 16, 2021 @08:18PM (#26840477)
There's a gap between:

1) reinforcing the whole car for a rally (which brings the car up to 1965 overengineered standards, and well beyond); and

2) simply welding two halves of a car together.

If you were to weld two halves of a car together, and weld a ton of reinforcements into the unibody, it would very obviously work fine.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:57AM (#26818828)
Please stop throwing generalized internet engineering tropes at the wall. Just because it all looks like rocket science to someone who doesn't have industry experience doesn't mean it is.

The repairs you are proclaiming to be impossible are perfectly possible to do with good results. These repairs are often performed often, just not in the high cost of labor parts of the world where HN lives (the low cost areas buy our wrecked cars to fix and sell to the point where sourcing parts for major repairs is often easier there than in the vehicle's country of origin). There's autobody industry specific tools and literature that help professionals in the industry perform the repairs properly. It's perfectly possible to take a car apart and reassemble (with good parts) the way an OEM would have if you're willing to invest in the tooling (mostly for welding in hard to reach areas). Car passenger cabins aren't supposed to flex (but in practice they do so within acceptable limits) and OEMs provide service literature telling you what you can and can't modify, much repair info can be gleaned by reading between the lines of such service literature. The welding issues you are describing are simply not an issue for skilled welders. Your opinion of engineering education is hard to reconcile with the observed performance of new engineers in any/every field.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by blagie on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:49AM (#26819800)
Did you even read what you were replying to?

The conclusion of what you're replying to: "You can fix up a $100 Huffy with any old welder. A $2000 steel frame with thin-wall double-butted tubes? You want a really skilled welder and close inspection to make sure it's not compromised."

Yes, it's possible, and yes, I know folks whom I'd trust to do it. The guy in my local auto shop? Definitely not. Random car shop in the developing world? I've seen the results. They'll drive, but they're far from save by Western standards.

What you wrote: "if you're willing to invest in the tooling" "The welding issues you are describing are simply not an issue for skilled welders"

I mean, seriously. You responded to a something entirely different from what I wrote, repeated roughly what I actually DID write, and mixed a few errors in (if car cabins weren't made to flex, they'd be using a very different type of steel; virtually everything made to be tough is made to flex).

Please find a place in my post where I "proclaiming [repairs] to be impossible"

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by VBprogrammer on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:43AM (#26820386)
Anyone who has jacked up a car at one wheel and tried to open a door knows that flexing is very real.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by blagie on Friday April 16, 2021 @08:25PM (#26840519)
Work is force times distance. How tough your car (or anything else) is depends on:

1) How much force it takes to flex it -- the spring constant

2) How far it will flex before it breaks

Multiply the two together (or specifically, 1/2 kd^2 where d is how far it will bend before it breaks, k is the spring constant, and 1/2 kd is the average force you're applying), and you get how much energy it takes to break it.

*Everything* flexes. Rigid things just flex less for the same force.

Things which break when flexed just a little bit are called brittle.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:00AM (#26820594)
> Anyone who has jacked up a car at one wheel and tried to open a door knows that flexing is very real.

Have you tried doing that to anything other than a 1960s convertible?

My 90s junk handles that just fine (and they're not particularly rigid cars). Matter of fact I did it yesterday afternoon to change rear pads.

Generally speaking you need to get a floppy vehicle really bound up (think 80s Jeep Cherokee or minivan off road) in order to have issues with doors and even then it's usually rear hatch only. OEMs specially try to avoid having bodies that flex enough to be noticeable to consumers, let alone to the point of doors not opening. Heck, I'd be surprised if you can even design a car to pass modern roof strength requirements without also making it stiff enough to have the doors open and close regardless of how bound up it is. (Pickup tailgates are another thing since the bed is open top and bolted to a frame designed to flex somewhat and even then being able to open the tailgate with two tires off the ground is not unheard of)

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by dekhn on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:36AM (#26821032)
When I gave a friend a ride in my 2001 Miata, the very first thing he said was 'huh, you have a rigid frame, if I'd done that turn in my old MG, you could see the frame flexing'
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:28AM (#26821640)
Old MG is bodypanels over chassis, a Miata is a unibody. Totally different construction.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by dekhn on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:35AM (#26821023)
I disagree; I think the person you're replying to is completely correct. To rebuild the safety of a modern engineering system isn't somebody in their garage can easily do. With skills, you can definitely improve things, but not to the statistical level that modern car manufacturers have achieved.

It's similar in microelectronics. I can do a ton of stuff with an arduino because it uses really basic old, tough eletronics. I can put too much current into a pin, ok the pin dies but the AVR is still fine. A modern ESP32? A little bit of current or voltage above the rating and the whole thing is toast.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by phaedrus on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:06AM (#26821365)
It's a numbers game, and you're overlooking the other side of it. The automakers have to engineer to a very low probability of failure because they deal in large numbers. It's true a person in their garage can't match that engineering - but they don't have to. They only have to get to "reasonably" safe not "absolutely" safe.

It's just like people putting turbochargers on their 90s Hondas. Naysayers could claim it's a fool's errand because if Honda, with all their engineering resources, didn't feel they could add turbocharging to their engines in the 90s and have it be cost effective and reliable enough, surely someone in their garage can't do it? But what they overlook is that if 5% of one of Honda's mass market cars blew an engine that would be a disaster, whereas a 5% chance an individual blows his own engine, which he may be able to replace for $500 to $1500: that may be a risk an individual is willing to take that a carmaker cannot.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:21AM (#26821546)
The devil is in the details. I know people that could pull this off. I could pull this off. But I also know people that would try to pull it off, it would look good and maybe even pass inspection but I'd never want to be seen in or near that vehicle.

I've welded up cars that were so rusted through that you had to re-inforce the body before you could start working on them in order for them to stay true (tubeframe inside the main body to fixate the remains). It's all doable, mostly a matter of time and skill.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by tyingq on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:47AM (#26820438)
Older vehicles are frame+body, such that the body integrity is less important than current unibody cars that don't have a frame. This would be a much more significant change on a unibody car.

Though any sort of big modification like this probably changes the characteristics of how it crushes in a crash, flexes under load, etc.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by bunje on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:48AM (#26818322)
I would guess that it is much more dangerous to modify a modern car because they utilize nontrivial shell geometry to improve the rigidity or to reduce weight. When I was attending driving lessons, my teacher claimed that the specific shape of the windscreen or rear window was a very important safety feature in the scenario that the car rolls over.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by sgt101 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:20AM (#26818564)
The big one is the A pillar on the front. This tends to corrode over time and is often why cars are written off. If it is corroded then the structural integrity of the car is compromised. There is really no repair for it - but a bit of welding can disguise things and get a write off sold as a potential project. The new owner can find out when they take the wings off... or they can find out when the front of the car comes off in the event of a shunt, but in that scenario they only find out very briefly.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:03PM (#26822185)
That write-off is an economic affair, not a technical one. A-pillars too can be re-manufactured, but it is usually better not to because if the A-pillar is compromised you are looking at a body that will have a whole lot of other damage as well. The bad part about damage there is that you need to build it up from the inside out which means 'undressing' the whole box layer by layer so you can rebuild it properly, and most people will not have the time, the skills (or the jigs) to do this properly. But it definitely can be done, but likely not in a way that is economical.

I can't imagine an A-pillar that is damaged with the rest of the car being deformed as well, the A-pillar of a modern car is ridiculously strong and meant to be the outer boundary of the safety cage for the passengers. Any deformation there and you'll have a deformed bottom, roof, firewall and probably other parts as well.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by TravelPiglet on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:18AM (#26818543)
Not to mention crumple zones and how the car is intended to protect the people inside
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jacquesm on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:03PM (#26822195)
Those are typically outside of the safety cell.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by southerntofu on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:30AM (#26818641)
> any comments on how hard it is to this without compromising safety?

I would say it greatly depends on your welding skills. The same welded materials can be very solid of very weak depending on how they were welded. I would not dare to do that, personally.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by robbiep on Thursday April 15, 2021 @05:50AM (#26818330)
While travelling in Cuba 2 friends and I hired a cab to drive us to Viñales from Havana - we ended up in a stretch Lada! Front ⅔ of 1 car, back ⅔ of another.

Felt very unsafe but we got there

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:18AM (#26818541)
>Felt very unsafe but we got there

I'm pretty sure 99.999% of HN would say the same thing about a normal Lada.

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jodrellblank on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:20AM (#26819532)
You've signed up with a throwaway account and started the last three comments I've read in this thread with a sneering "I'm pretty sure screeching HN/Reddit morons would think X but I know better"; it's against the HN guidelines to comment in that style: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

"In Comments

Don't be snarky. [...] Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.

Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents.

Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle."

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by imwillofficial on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:29AM (#26820202)
That was a joke, and I loled. I don’t even know what a lada is and I still laughed.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by jodrellblank on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:37PM (#26822763)
Ladas are(were) Eastern European Soviet block cars, with a reputation for being cheap and low quality, and in the UK, a low social status indicator used to mock people[1]. The joke could be that a Lada is already an unsafe car so a stretch-Lada can't be any worse (the joke is that you say one Lada is unsafe but actually they are ALL unsafe, ha ha). But then it doesn't need any mention of "99.999% of HN".

The joke could instead be that Ladas are safe enough, the stretch Lada was probably safe enough, and the thing to laugh at is the 99.999% of HN who can't judge the safety of cars, or naively aren't used to a world outside their Silicon Valley spafe-space luxury. i.e. it's a sneering putdown at HN users and nothing to do with Ladas per-se. Given the context of the last two comments I read by throwaway account starting with sneering at HN and Reddit users, and the need to specify "99.999% of HN users would say X", I lean towards this interpretation.

That doesn't mean you can't find it a hilarious witty comment, sneering at some "inferior" group is a popular thing people laugh at. (Weirdly?[1]) You might find it a funny joke, and it might be sneering and against the guidelines, both at the same time. "I loled" isn't sufficient to say it's on-topic, you should be arguing that it wasn't sneering. Better again, arguing that it was within the spirit of the guidelines more than the letter of them; just jokes alone are not against the guidelines explicitly but are frequently frowned on.

Sneerclub and status grabbing are my own personal soupnazi topics of the moment; once you see comments where the main purpose is to sneer at how dumb some large disparate group is, or the flip-side to claim status as a superior, you see them everywhere. e.g. these two just seen in tabs I have open:

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26821673

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26822285

both where the point is to call someone dumb/inferior.

(And e.g. much of my internet commenting history, tbh)

[1] (is it more social signalling than humour?)

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:45PM (#26822894)
My point was that even a normal Lada is going to feel like a tin can compared to what most people here have as their frame of reference. I'm not sure why anyone found that offensive. In retrospect I like the "stretch Lada is 5/3 as safe as normal Lada" line of reasoning better.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by imwillofficial on Thursday April 15, 2021 @01:01PM (#26823136)
Thank you for your in depth reply! Considering the author responded with His intention, it seems you have read the tea leaves wrong on intended meaning.
Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by daniellarusso on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:25AM (#26818593)
I have seen a few Volvo 240 pickup trucks online.

https://www.justacargeek.com/2013/11/1984-volvo-240-pick-up-...

Re:France cuts two nuclear-powered submarines in half to mak... by fifilura on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:06PM (#26822234)
These are pretty common in Sweden because, if properly modified, they can be driven by a 15 year old as a tractor. While 18 years old and a more complete drivers license is required for a regular car.

And obviously because Volvo is swedish, that is the most common model to modify.

One of the required modifications is to remove the rear seat so that it is no longer built for personell transport. It should also not be possible to drive faster than 30km/h.

You can see the images here, but there is no corresponding page in english. https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-traktor