News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by rurp on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:39PM (#26813455)
This matches my experience as well.

HN having a reasonably high karma threshold for downvoting was a great decision that guards against a lot of common problems. I think that feature, along with the community as a whole being very mindful about protecting the forum quality, plus Dang being an excellent moderator, have greatly contributed to keeping it strong for many years.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by Graffur on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:03PM (#26814204)
In fact it seems like a no brainer decision. Why should a day 1 account be able to downvote content?
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by r00fus on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:35PM (#26815245)
There's a lot more. You shouldn't be able to downvote replies to your post. Rate limits. Metamoderation. Hell/shadowbanning. Most good forums rely on an active superadmin moderation a lot - when that goes away or is unreliable the site dies.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by CaptainZapp on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:54AM (#26817877)
> There's a lot more. You shouldn't be able to downvote replies to your post.

You're not allowed to do that anyway. You can only upvote direct replies to a comment of yours.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by paxys on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:26PM (#26814375)
Why should a day 1 account be able to upvote content? They both ultimately have the same impact.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by bitshiftfaced on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:18PM (#26814779)
I think people tend to downvote out of negative emotion but more likely upvote out of genuine interest. All it takes is one bad actor to downvote a comment early and it may never again gain enough visibility to get the position it actually deserves.

On the other hand, the absence of upvoting keeps the comment at a neutral level. Its speed of losing visibility can't be unfairly accelerated, and so it has a chance at competing with comments of the same level.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by busymom0 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @10:26PM (#26815548)
If a new account can neither upvote nor downvote, then wouldn't it be a catch 22 where no one ever gains any karma? Also as someone else pointed out, people often downvote for political purposes whereas the only reason I can think of someone abusing upvotes would be for spam which gets handled by HN's filters pretty well.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by Dumblydorr on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:35PM (#26814453)
Well, you can use a bunch of troll accounts to downvote people who disagree with you. Meanwhile, troll accounts up voting a bad post would put it neutral or slightly positive, I'd guess.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by stevenhuang on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:43PM (#26814509)
I imagine it promotes discourse by encouraging discussion instead of shallow dismissals by downvoting.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by biasKillsHN on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:20PM (#26814328)
I can't agree on the moderation.

The bias in favor of Apple is extreme. I genuinely don't know if the mods are actively paid off, if Apple astroturfs, or whatever. But it seems those threads are disingenuous. It's impossible to form evidence because good criticism of Apple is often deleted.

Meanwhile other threads are dumpster fires.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by dang on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:38PM (#26814471)
People with the opposite view see the opposite "extreme" bias. It's basically entirely in the eye of the beholder.

What's odd is how common it is, and how absolutely people are convinced that their particular strain of these contradictory generalizations is the accurate one.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by biasKillsHN on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:44PM (#26814530)
That's not what I'm referring to.

I see political topics better debated and I'm radical.

It's just Apple comment threads. You know dang.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by busymom0 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @12:53AM (#26816311)
Just yesterday there was a post with high engagement and criticism of Apple's App Store:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26794228

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by confidantlake on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:01PM (#26814655)
There was an article about bad service at apple stores. I commented that I had mostly positive experiences. Was downvoted.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by cgriswald on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:31PM (#26814861)
There’s a similar dynamic on Nextdoor in my neighborhood. You’re basically not allowed to disagree with the OP. Commenters will say things like “this isn’t the place for it” without addressing the content or actual appropriateness. Usually you’ll be drown out by a bunch of “compassionate” posts or stupid questions[0] as well.

If you want to disagree with someone you can start your own post and many of the same people will “protect” your post from disagreement as well. It’s basically impossible to have an actual discussion in that environment.

[0] - Stupid as in the answer to their question is literally in the text of the post they’re responding to in the first place.

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by everybodyknows on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:39PM (#26815280)
This is clearly a minority opinion, but in my view well-stated factual anecdotes that the majority find uncomfortable deserve upvote, always.

But that's not what they get, not even here on HN.

The high karma threshold is helpful, but I doubt raising it further would do much. Some qualitatively different vetting mechanism is wanted. Thought about the problem a lot, but so far reached only a few inchoate notions.

[dead]
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by striking on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:25PM (#26813861)
You can usually be un-IP-banned by going to a particular URL. It's usually not permanent.

As for the thing you were banned for, do you feel like HN owes you the ability to make an account per comment?

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by ascar on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:25PM (#26813864)
Are static ips a common thing in the US? Here in Germany getting a fresh ip is as easy as restarting the router unless you explicitly pay for a static ip.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:39PM (#26813986)
Depends on the ISP.

For some people, simply rebooting their router gets a new IP. Others have to explicitly tell it to release the IP and then renew it. Others have to change their router's MAC address.

I know that personally, if I release it and renew it, I'll get assigned the same IP. Though my IP is technically dynamic, it hasn't changed in the 5 years I've been in this house. I haven't tried changing my MAC address, but with a previous ISP, I had changed my router's MAC and it wouldn't even get an IP at all until I changed it back. Makes me wonder what would happen if I had changed it to the MAC of a router being used by another customer...

Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by jpindar on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @06:37PM (#26813963)
Static ips are not common, but ips that are technically dynamic but in fact rarely change are.
Re:The value of downvoting, or, how Hacker News gets it wron... by 8note on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:56PM (#26814625)
That's been helping out my valheim server. I was expecting it to hanger kinda frequently but my IP hasn't changed in more than a month in counting