News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by thenewwazoo on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:05PM (#26811591)
Sorry for the meta-discussion (which I know is against the guidelines), but I'm finding it really hard to respond kindly to your comment, given the overarching tone ("no respect", "hard to swallow", sarcasm about parts, "shitty pricing"). I'd love to engage with you on the merits of pricing for what the market will bear, CoGS including software and craftsmanship, etc, but I am not able. Perhaps that's my failing, but I'd like to encourage you to be less acerbic in the future.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by smoldesu on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:14PM (#26811700)
If my tone comes off as "acerbic", I guess I'm a little surprised. I love Teenage Engineering (and own a few Pocket Operators too), but I gotta call them out on the pricing issue here. When the price of the OP-1 did start to skyrocket in 2012, Teenage Engineering said absolutely nothing, and then discontinued it in 2013, sending the secondhand market soaring again. Of course, their response is to put it back into production at a higher cost, for more customers. You can slice this any way you want, but there's not really an excuse for an all-digital synth to increase in price like that. I have no doubts that a simple redesign could bring the BOM down to sub-$200, even in 2015. Failing that, they could have taken the re-release as an opportunity to fix some of the issues in the original model: give it a sensible charging port, improve the microphone quality, or even improving the sample transfer software. None of these issues were ever addressed. The insult added to injury is the OP-Z, a "successor" that was designed to be inferior to it's predecessor, as not to cannibalize it's market.

Maybe I am hateful, but Teenage Engineering has definitely had a fall from grace. Even their recent modular kits left a bad taste in my mouth...

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by thenewwazoo on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:19PM (#26812500)
There are schools of (microeconomic) thought that would encourage them to raise prices even further in order to reduce demand to match their supply capability. If the second-hand market prices a good higher than the original seller, that's a very clear signal to increase the price. At least that way the profits end up in the manufacturer's pocket (which they can use to increase volume) instead of a speculator's. That is all to say, their raising prices is ethical, legal, and moral.

You seem to be seeing something nefarious in their discontinuing the OP-1, and then re-continuing it at a higher price. Even absent the above, it makes perfect sense that they could be losing money on a product, and then re-introduce it at a higher price so they stop losing money.

Now, should they have been losing money at the lower price point? You talk a lot about CoGS, but that completely neglects things like design and development time. The OP-1 is, by all accounts, extremely well-designed and built. Economies of scale let companies like Apple pick lower margins because that R&D time is amortized over a huge number of devices manufactured. Boutique operations can't do that.

All that still ignores squishier questions like choosing to keep a price point in order to fund other projects (that may never be built) with increasing margins over time, or hell, I dunno, paying bigger bonuses to employees. Clearly people are willing to pay it, and they're under no obligation to price their goods according to any objective thing at all. Maybe the CEO is a mystic and likes the numerology of the new price better.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by brandonmenc on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:34PM (#26813412)
> You seem to be seeing something nefarious in their discontinuing the OP-1, and then re-continuing it at a higher price.

This is typical behavior of a certain large class of musicians, particularly electronic ones.

The message boards are full of people complaining that these companies charge "too much." They will also then complain that Behringer sucks for "stealing" ideas and pricing them affordably.

Meanwhile, it has never been cheaper to buy music equipment and software. And there are tons of high quality free software out there.

I would hesitate to enter into the business of selling music software or hardware. It seems pretty thankless.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by tinco on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @07:52PM (#26814598)
If it were truly possible to create and sell the OP-1 or an equivalent device for under $1000, some company would have done it already. I'd gladly buy a Behringer copy of the OP-1 for $500, and I bet loads of other people would as well.

It could even be twice the volume and be ugly AF.

I don't know why it's so difficult or unattractive to put a sequencer, a sampler and a synthesizer in one box with a keyboard on it, but the OP-1 seems to be the only successful implementation of that idea.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by SauciestGNU on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @08:00PM (#26814650)
The Behringer thing is really confusing to me. I know there are other personal/ethical reasons to dislike them, but cloning out of patent devices is not one of them. That's what patents are for and why they're only valid for a defined period of time. It makes even less sense to criticize them when the originals they are cloning aren't even made anymore.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by capableweb on Thursday April 15, 2021 @06:33AM (#26818661)
I don't think Behringer only creates clones of "out of patent" hardware but also current gear that is still being sold. I guess the latest example is the Behringer Swing that is obviously a clone of the Arturia Keystep.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by brandonmenc on Thursday April 15, 2021 @10:15AM (#26820778)
There are only so many ways to arrange three knobs and transport controls on a keyboard.

This is like two mobile phone companies putting their volume buttons in the same place.

This is another weird aspect of the (often amateur, electronic) music production world - making something simple and obvious seem like a mysterious and unique breakthrough.

This is a community that likes to use the terms “aleatoric” and “euclidian” instead of “random” and “evenly distributed”. Yes, I know the origins of those two terms but I don’t care - I eyeroll every time I hear them.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by capableweb on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:44AM (#26821864)
> There are only so many ways to arrange three knobs and transport controls on a keyboard.

You're joking right? There are thousands of combinations of where to put things to make a clone less obvious, but obviously they didn't care to do anything of that.

Have you seen them compared side-by-side? It looks like a Mark 2 version of the Keystep, except some naming changed, here's an example: https://www.gearnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/behringe...

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by brandonmenc on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:31PM (#26825750)
I have seen them, and I'm not joking.

> There are thousands of combinations of where to put things to make a clone less obvious

Disagree. This is like saying there are thousands of combinations of where to put doors on a car or volume controls on a phone. There are really only like one or two, and I doubt any of them are like, copyrightable.

These are simple devices with simple features, not a single one which was invented by Arturia.

If I slap an arpeggiator on a midi keyboard, do I have to put the knobs on the right hand side to not infringe on the Keystep? And at that point, can no one else put an arpeggiator in a 25-key midi keyboard because all layout combinations in that form factor are "used up?"

I just don't get the outrage over this other than I think it comes from people who already hate Behringer.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by capableweb on Friday April 16, 2021 @06:55AM (#26832282)
> I just don't get the outrage over this other than I think it comes from people who already hate Behringer.

Then you have your first counter-point here, because I don't have Behringer, I simply think some of their practices are shady. But no hate, and I have nothing against people who chose to buy their gear. I don't want to, because of their shady practices, but that doesn't mean I hate Behringer in total.

And no, if you have an arpeggiator on a midi keyboard, you don't have to place them in a different place than the Keystep. But if you have exactly the same features, and you put them in the same place, with a so similar design that consumer could be confused which one you have in front of you, then it starts getting into a territory that me myself, is not comfortable with.

If you remove the Arturia and and Behringer logo together with the text on the Swing, you think most people would accurately be able to separate which one is which? I think not, and that's when you're infringing on someones copyright.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by SauciestGNU on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:14AM (#26821457)
>There are only so many ways to arrange three knobs and transport controls on a keyboard.

>This is like two mobile phone companies putting their volume buttons in the same place.

In this case I think Behringer directly copied the look and feel of the keystep because of its amazing success in the low budget controller space. I don't expect much innovation in the budget controller space, but this one seems to be a clear case of trademark/copyright infringement if "rounded corners" can be protected.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by brandonmenc on Thursday April 15, 2021 @04:16PM (#26825594)
> this one seems to be a clear case of trademark/copyright infringement

Then Arturia should be taking Behringer to court, right?

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by SauciestGNU on Thursday April 15, 2021 @11:11AM (#26821429)
I forgot about that, I'm not such a fan of that one.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by unixhero on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @11:40PM (#26815972)
To be fair, Behringer is priced right, great prices for low quality gear.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by zokier on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:51PM (#26812150)
Why do you think the BOM cost should have any relation to the selling price?

> You can slice this any way you want, but there's not really an excuse for an all-digital synth to increase in price like that

Adjusting to market bearing price seems like a good excuse to me.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by smoldesu on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:00PM (#26812274)
Whatever justifies it for you. For every extra dollar they eke out of bougie hipster, they ostracize people like me who would definitely buy one if it was $500 or $600
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by blairbeckwith on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:07PM (#26812357)
Companies are under no obligation to not ostracize potential customers. Do you also think that luxury car companies are shitty and ridiculous because they charge more than cars that "do the same thing"?
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by monkmartinez on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:53PM (#26812918)
I do, but I am admittedly a small sample. A case can certainly be made that luxury cars, in general, are not very "good" cars in most metrics as by which the industry measures what a "good" car should be. I think OP has a valid point, if the synth Teenage is selling is inferior and more expensive but sells because "status" and signaling.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by blairbeckwith on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:59PM (#26812996)
But they do sell, and Lamborghini or Porsche are not under any obligation to make a cheap car so that everyone who wants one can afford one, nor should they.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by zokier on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:27PM (#26812601)
Why do you feel entitled to be able to buy it at price point that suits you?
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by monkmartinez on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:05PM (#26813082)
I didn't get a sense of entitlement. I see someone frustrated with features for price, then calling it out as non-sensical. I like when people do that frankly. Is it judgey? You bet, and its ok to have an opinion on the matter!
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by type0 on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:35PM (#26812708)
> Even their recent modular kits left a bad taste in my mouth...

Their modular is ridiculous, I can't imagine what they were thinking.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by koolhaas on Thursday April 15, 2021 @03:43AM (#26817325)
> I have no doubts that a simple redesign could bring the BOM down to sub-$200

lol gotta love armchair HN

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by Marazan on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @03:31PM (#26811926)
I've no problem with a company pricing a product to be what the market will bear.

However, Teenage Engineering claiming they were jacking the price due to "supply issues" is just insulting.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by bsder on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @09:25PM (#26815190)
I would have agreed with you, but sourcing OLED displays is a pain in the ass. I've been personally bitten by this.

So, if they bought a 1000 obsolete displays and burned through them, it may actually take an act of God to get more. And you'll probably have to redesign your circuits.

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by Marazan on Saturday April 17, 2021 @03:17AM (#26842274)
Sure, but TE talked about the OP-1 as a 20 year project. The idea they paid the tooling costs for the body and then just slapped some remaindered displays on them stretches credulity.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by mwfunk on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:01PM (#26812281)
I haven't heard about this. Were they busted lying about supply chain issues as an excuse to raise prices? Their stuff is pricey but cool, but if it's documented that they lied about that, that would be hard to get past.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by voxrumor on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @04:40PM (#26812760)
They have talked about it some, seemed reasonable. Also understand why it would not be a popular decision though. Think running a business, and understanding success can be very temporary if you are not careful helps.

"We have had to face other costs than the actual components’ costs of course. The currency conversion, inflation, sourcing of the new component, re-coding the display, re-designing the mounting, new tools etc. are just a few of the “why”. When Teenage Engineering faced the reality of the OP-1’s future, there were only 2 choices: kill or save. We decided to save it. I understand that the new price is a disappointment to many of our fans. But I do hope some are happy that we did not kill it."

https://www.gearnews.com/teenage-engineering-open-up-about-t...

Re:Ten years of OP-1 by mwfunk on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:53PM (#26813584)
That seems unfortunate but reasonable. I don’t begrudge anyone making that choice, and I don’t begrudge anyone thinking their prices are too high (and I don’t begrudge anyone buying their stuff anyway because they think something’s cool). I was way more concerned about the claim that they lied about it and were scamming their customers somehow, but so far there’s no evidence of that.
Re:Ten years of OP-1 by coldtea on Wednesday April 14, 2021 @05:16PM (#26813211)
>I'd love to engage with you on the merits of pricing for what the market will bear

Well, there's also the level of pricing and milking it that poorer consumers will tolerate without hating the company, so there's that...