News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by checker on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @04:38PM (#2680300)
Quoted from comments and decided to analyze: "A family sedan for $80,000. That will work."

At an average of 15K miles/year, 30mpg, and $3/gal of gas, that's $1500 in gasoline a year. Over 5 years, that's a savings of $7500 ($10000 for $4/gal). We're not quite at that point where it offsets completely from a pure 'gas vs electric' POV (I'm not sure if the car has a Mercedes-comparable interior or a Toyota-comparable interior).

I don't think this means it won't work, but I was interested in the gas savings over time. I would buy one if I could afford an $80000 car.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by cube13 on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:06PM (#2680425)
Let's assume that it's a high-end luxury sedan, not a low-end family sedan. Unless gas goes up to $100/gallon, there's no way you'll save money by buying the Tesla over a affordable mid-size like a Honda Accord or Ford Fusion.

So let's compare that to a Mercedes E-class. According to US News(http://usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/cars-trucks/Mercedes-Be...), the average price out the door is about $48,000 for the model with the fewest options. Let's round that up to $50,000, because we want alloy wheels or some other additional feature.

The mileage of the car is 24 highway, 17 city, so let's average that to about 20(a bit more city driving than highway). So that's $15,000 in gas over the 5 years(30/20=1.5). So the total cost of the car, not counting other replacements, is around $65,000.

That's still $15,000 less than the $80,000 on the Tesla, and you're not going to spend $15,000 on car washes and other parts(brakes, oil, etc.) in that time. It should also be noted that if you need to buy replacement batteries in that 5 year period, the cost increases to $100,000.

EDIT: I didn't include the cost of electricity, or the electrical work needed to get the extra 220 volt circuit out to your garage.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by burgerbrain on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @06:14PM (#2680649)
Most people don't buy luxury vehicles for their economics.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by wooster on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:32PM (#2680519)
The high end Mercedes luxury sedan is the S-class, for which the low end price paid is about $90,000.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by nradov on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @08:39PM (#2681067)
Edmunds estimates the total cost of ownership for a Mercedes-Benz E-class sedan at $77K for five years. http://www.edmunds.com/mercedes-benz/e-class/2011/tco.html?s...
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by khafra on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @10:21AM (#2683208)
Unless the Tesla doesn't depreciate or need repairs, most of that extra cost is going to be similar.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by checker on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:46PM (#2680573)
I agree. The personal carbon guilt price will need to heavily weigh in their favor, as btilly said next to you.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by btilly on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @04:51PM (#2680352)
Your analysis left out the cost of electricity that has to be used instead of gas. Even so in 5 years you save a maximum of 10% of the cost of the car. This only works if you're put a personal value on not using fossil fuels which far exceeds the cost of gasoline.

In return you get a very fast sedan that can't be used for any long road trips. It would be fine for commutes and around town, but even something like a trip from Los Angeles to San Francisco would be a major fail.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by mixmastamyk on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:25PM (#2680487)
LA to SF is a long drive and not comfortable to do in one day. Yes it can be done if you take i-5 and drive like a maniac for ~6-7 hours.

However, I'd much rather take the scenic route via 101 and stop over in Paso Robles and get the car charged up while at a nice B&B, wine tasting, etc. ;)

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by philwelch on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @07:23PM (#2680826)
Google says it's less than 8 hours with traffic. I've easily made 8 hour drives in a single day.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by ChuckMcM on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @06:45PM (#2680728)
Must be a perception thing. One way isn't "long" in the sense that its only 300 miles. Its 'long' to drive SF to Las Vegas. Basically any drive over about 480 miles of freeway starts getting long.

That being said, the 'long trip' scenario is somewhat of red herring. If you regularly travel several hundred miles a day then an all electric car is probably unlikely to meet your vehicle requirements. If its an occasional (once a year) kind of thing then creative solutions might arise to address it.

Were the Tesla guys willing to put a high power plug in the back I could imagine a 'trailer' which held a generator and a gas tank and provided power all the way there.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by btilly on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @07:54PM (#2680921)
Until those "creative solutions" have materialized and hit the market, we have to work within the constraints that we have to live with.

As someone with a family, my requirements for a family car need to cover the possibility of extended road trips. Sure, I know that in theory I could just rent a gas car for that, but I know in practice that it won't happen. So "able to handle long road trips" is solidly in my personal list of firm requirements for a family vehicle. Sure, I don't need to do it every day. But it is something I need that vehicle to do.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by ChuckMcM on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @08:13PM (#2680978)
I get that it doesn't work in your particular case. Early adopters will fund the research to get the cost of energy storage down and energy density up.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by yosh on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @07:26PM (#2680833)
There's actually 5 charging stations that Tesla installed on the 101 between SF and LA. If we got serious about electric cars, higher charging station density would help with long trips.

And I agree, SF<->LA is not a long drive.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by hammerdr on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @10:28PM (#2681393)
http://www.afdc.energy.gov/afdc/fuels/electricity_locations....

Every major US city has electric power stations. From that map, you could very easily make a continental road trip in the United States. And, this map is out of date. Chicago alone is building over 250 quick charge stations this year.

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2011-02-10/classified/ct-...

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by btilly on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @10:33PM (#2681413)
You may have power stations. But http://www.teslamotors.com/goelectric/charging says that a full recharge still takes about 4 hours for their best option that they offer. That time needs to come down - way down.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by hammerdr on Wednesday June 22, 2011 @01:29AM (#2681865)
Not sure about all of the charging stations listed, but a Level 3 charging station takes about 30 minutes.

Obviously, there are improvements to be made. But the infrastructure to support electric cars is quickly being stood up. Much of that has come from the Recovery and Reinvestment Act, definitely, but there are going to be the equivalent of 87 gas stations for electric cars in Chicago at the end of this year. I find that amazing and uplifting.

30 minutes still is non-trivial to the person accustomed to the 5 minute fill up. Technology will get better but we also need to be willing to make some lifestyle changes that enable us to live cleaner, healthier lives going forward. Reading a book or exploring a new city or plugging in after lunch is a very pleasant way for those changes to come about.

Edit: The Chicago 250+ are all Level 3s. They are also building a couple hundred Level 2s which take the four hours that the Telsa one does.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by MikeCapone on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @04:47PM (#2680336)
If you really wanted an EV now, you could get a Nissan LEAF for a lot less than a Tesla Roadster. But if you want a couple generations, you should get a pretty decent price and a much bigger range (not to mention that by then fast charging stations should be more common).
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by pitdesi on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @04:49PM (#2680341)
The Tesla model S is supposed to be similar in dimension to the last 7 series BMW... which retails for about $80k. I believe fit and finish is to be up to that par as well. http://autos.yahoo.com/bmw/7-series/2012/

It's not close on a gas savings level, but you don't buy a Tesla for the gas savings... You buy it because it is a different type of car and to make a statement.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by rdl on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @10:28PM (#2681389)
I'm hoping to put in a deposit for a Model S Signature as a bay area vehicle (for personal and/or company use). The 300 mile range is perfect for SFBA, and it's big enough for 4-5 people comfortably, or datacenter equipment, and has more novelty value than a lambo among geeks.

I wouldn't take an exotic (Tesla, Fiskar Karma, F or L, etc.) on long road trips in the US, especially with a non-standard drivetrain, due to the lack of service options.

Within the bay area, especially if you have 240 or 480v charging at home/office, it's perfect. I know a Roadster user who has his mainly because he hates gas stations.

Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by vaksel on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @04:54PM (#2680374)
frankly I don't see why they need to make it so big. Weight is one of the biggest problems for fuel efficiency, it takes a ton more juice to move a 4,000lb car vs a a 3,000lb car.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by checker on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:50PM (#2680585)
I find it interesting that they intend to make a wagon/estate version with rear-facing seats (article says 7 passengers, so my best guess is that it has to be a wagon in that form). They must really want to make the 'family' statement, because no other demographic regularly sits 7 people.
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by lutorm on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @07:37PM (#2680868)
Everyone driving around in an SUV seem to feel the need for seating 7 people, even if a microscopic fraction of them actually do...
Re:Tesla Roadster reaches the end of the line by bh42222 on Tuesday June 21, 2011 @05:06PM (#2680426)
I love the Tesla guys, but I doubt they have the pricing power of BMW.

In that price range we're talking conspicuous consumption, and a beamer is definitely conspicuous, but a Tesla?

Maybe if you're a gay engineer dude, this Tesla will be a great way to score other gay geek dudes - wait or maybe it's for lesbian geeks... not sure, my point is I doubt this will make people think it can get them laid as much an equally priced BMW will.

This is why I think it is overpriced.