News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Donald on Monday April 12, 2021 @12:26AM (#26776048)
What’s the angle here? Microsoft wanting a position with interactive voice products for dataset curation? Getting into the automotive supplier space? Surely it’s not for the speech tech. Nuance has largely failed to fully embrace deep learning approaches.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by otoburb on Monday April 12, 2021 @01:27AM (#26776293)
>>What’s the angle here?

Probably the patent portfolio that Nuance aggressively asserts[1]. They also went on a 51-company (!!!) acquisition spree up to 2018[2] after ScanSoft acquired Nuance[3] (but kept the name) in 2005, when both of them were #1 and #2 in the speech recognition space.

While Nuance may have failed to embrace DL approaches, Apple has been willing to license Nuance technology to power Siri for many years[4].

EDIT: They recently acquired another company in February 2021.[5]

[1] https://www.ft.com/content/dd908d81-4859-4d19-a1e8-e5f7b4f01...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuance_Communications

[3] https://www.computerworld.com/article/2556291/scansoft-to-bu...

[4] https://www.forbes.com/sites/rogerkay/2014/03/24/behind-appl...

[5] https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/practices/nuance-acquires-s...

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by scruffyherder on Monday April 12, 2021 @05:28AM (#26777459)
I was at one of the companies Nuance absorbed. They laid us all off, nice touch but turns out they needed me. I got all my demands met with zero resistance which only means I was thinking too low.

I got to see inside the beast and it www just out of control growth from acquisition. The IBM voice patent had eclipsed scansoft was.

Kind of strange MS wanting it for anything but their patents. The business was shit. As a side benefit they can shut down Siri since the apple deal was such a linchpin.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by b0tzzzzzzman on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:35AM (#26776570)
This could pair very well with the Discord buy.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by DebtDeflation on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:32AM (#26777879)
>What’s the angle here?

As someone who works professionally in this space, I can say that most commenters thus far have completely missed it. The angle here is Conversational AI in the Enterprise Call Center market. This is a market worth hundreds of billions of dollars annually. This announcement is almost certainly a reaction to the partnership between Genesys and Google to create Google Cloud Contact Center AI. I know a lot of people hate customer service chatbots, doesn't matter, companies are spending a fortune on them to replace agents and Microsoft/Google/Amazon want a slice of that pie.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by AndyMcConachie on Monday April 12, 2021 @07:30AM (#26778196)
Your reply intrigued me. I worked with Nuance about 20 years ago, around the time VoiceXML was being created. I was writing code in a language that was one of the precursors of VoiceXML, and then for a while I was writing code that generated VoiceXML for telehony user interfaces and that depended on Nuance.

I even wrote a VoiceXML interface to Zork that used Nuance. The user could say stuff like, 'Go east', 'use axe', etc. It was pretty silly but you could play original Zork via the telephone :)

20 years ago people were talking about the big money in voice recognition being in enterprise call centers. And so it's interesting to me that this is still the big market force.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by fzzzy on Monday April 12, 2021 @10:23AM (#26779771)
Playing Zork with voice sounds really fun. Back a few years ago when conversational ai was the hot thing to invest in I wondered if text adventures had a chance of coming back because of it. Probably too geeky still.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by peterlk on Monday April 12, 2021 @12:49AM (#26776162)
> Nuance has largely failed to fully embrace deep learning approaches.

This may be a feature, not a bug. Explainability is very difficult with deep learning systems, and that often makes deep learning less suitable for some compliance applications like government usage. Microsoft may also still be feeling more conservative after their twitter bot learned so well a few years ago.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by PeterisP on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:40AM (#26776594)
The pre-deep-learning speech recognition methods don't have any reasonable explainability anyway, it's also based on large statistical models, so I wouldn't consider explainability as a reason.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Saad_M on Monday April 12, 2021 @01:41AM (#26776348)
Also for healthcare. Nuance is a big player in the healthcare market. A whole segment where DL approaches are not suitable due to lack of transparency.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by elcomet on Monday April 12, 2021 @03:21AM (#26776787)
You won't use speech recognition to heal patients or make diagnosis..

And if you use it to control medical devices, then transparency is not what matters. A protocol matters, like the machine repeating the commands and asking for confirmation.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Closi on Monday April 12, 2021 @03:46AM (#26776896)
No, you use it for recording patient interactions and making notes.

The main difference in voice for these apps is an intentionally limited and specialised vocabulary, where you have to be pretty certain that they said aberrant rather than apparent, or anuresis rather than enuresis. A lack of humeral would mean you are lacking a particular fluid, while a lack of humerous would mean you are missing a bone. The difference between an apparent mole and an aberrant mole is pretty huge, so you want to be sure your AI isn't over-fitting.

Also the wider ecosystem of this is that you have to have a full software for editing and checking the notes that is compliant to local healthcare regulations, and standard interfaces into medical software. Also penetration into the healthcare market is notoriously hard.

I would imagine synergies in this space include things like Microsoft Teams being in a good place to take on remote consultations compared to Zoom et al, as you could have a seamless flow from consultation to record in the healthcare system and medically-accurate transcription.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by fny on Monday April 12, 2021 @05:27AM (#26777456)
I'm going to write this all with the speech to text on my droid and add line breaks after.

Aberrant mole apparent mole. Works like a charm. Now let me blow your mind with another speech to text: ganglioneuralgia.

I think this acquisition has anything to do with DL vs traditional. We're running opaque DL models transparency at a major academic hospital to help treat patients. This is a cake walk by comparison. Specialized vocabulary? Just pay a few people to read some medical textbooks and your done.

I think they just want the reputation customers and product suite.

Also they're making integrations out the wazoo with ehrs. I actually can't believe it, but epoc let Microsoft integrate teams. Integrating and licensing voice is easily a next step.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by ethbr0 on Monday April 12, 2021 @07:04AM (#26778042)
Microsoft is having success with aggressively pushing Teams because most enterprise IT is too small-minded to explore anything else.

So it's the most "modern" solution they can offer their company without having to do any real additional security work.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Closi on Monday April 12, 2021 @12:46PM (#26781679)
> Microsoft is having success with aggressively pushing Teams because most enterprise IT is too small-minded to explore anything else.

Or alternatively, no other solution offers similar price/performance - They are having success because for most corporate subscriptions it is free. Also it's the most commonly used solution for business in the UK, so I have less problems with people joining teams calls than any other provider.

I don't think it's small mindedness - what other solution should they offer?

* Zoom - Awful internal messaging capability. A full office 365 subscription costs almost the same as a standalone zoom licence.

* Slack - No support for external conference calling without integration to another service.

* Google Meet - Makes sense if you use google suite, but not really if you use 365. Other than that not too bad.

* Webex - Awful client requires downloading which causes people to have issues half the time.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by fny on Monday April 12, 2021 @08:42AM (#26778729)
The big deal here is that EPIC has been classically closed off to outside software. The fact that they partnered with Microsoft to create an integration is astounding.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by elcomet on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:26PM (#26784709)
Yes and as you say, you don't need interpretability for those use cases. You need performance, as in most situations. Also, people cannot explain why they heard a sentence, they just heard it. So explainability doesn't really mean anything in speech recognition. Performance is key, and dragon was used because it was better.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by microtherion on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:31AM (#26777872)
1. It's not like Hidden Markov Models (the approach that dominated recognition prior to the deep learning revolution) is any more explainable than deep learning models.

2. You generally don't gain more confidence in the accuracy of a particular word by looking at less context. This is neither how human nor machine recognition works.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Closi on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:37AM (#26777910)
I'm not saying that a particular technical approach is better, I'm just saying that from a product perspective the medical industry has specific requirements which are currently satisfied in Dragon and not in the generalised speech libraries Apple / Google have at the moment.

I've not got direct experience in healthcare, but do have experience in industrial voice, and this is an area where Apple/Google generalised libraries perform significantly worse than specialised software (Dragon is also big in this industry, albeit at the SDK level). In industrial voice the main requirements are high levels of background noise, restricted vocabulary (20-30 words) and people speaking very quickly.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by avrionov on Monday April 12, 2021 @12:37AM (#26776109)
Monopoly Money - Microsoft stock price is really high. They are buying a revenue and market share.

Nuance has very strong presence in medical transcription, retail and a few other areas. Microsoft can move them to Azure and their own speech to text technology.

Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by ocdtrekkie on Monday April 12, 2021 @01:19AM (#26776266)
The main reason I am worried about this is Microsoft killing off yet another viable on-premise speech technology in favor of forcing people to pay for Azure subscriptions.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by indigochill on Monday April 12, 2021 @08:28AM (#26778610)
When people want to pursue antitrust legislation, these sorts of purchases are what we should be going after. If we continue letting incumbents buy all the tech (coughFacebook's purchase of Instagramcough) with their country-sized budgets, no wonder the incumbents are unkillable.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by andyxor on Monday April 12, 2021 @02:19AM (#26776489)
if they kill off this patent troll it's a net benefit for humanity.
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by Multicomp on Monday April 12, 2021 @06:11AM (#26777771)
as long as MS continues to sell an offline on device version of Dragon (Naturally Speaking) in the future, I can agree. But otherwise I'm stuck on Pro Individual 15
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by wrnr on Monday April 12, 2021 @01:48AM (#26776369)
The automotive bizz was spun off into Cerence
Re:Microsoft in advanced talks to buy Nuance by AJRF on Monday April 12, 2021 @04:10AM (#26777029)
I'd wager services for Azure.