On the contrary, users are consistently willing to pay more than advertisers when given the option.
Problem is after a while, the advertisers and middle men eyeball all that ad-free content, and decide you’ll accept just a little advertising ...
Next thing you know, you’re subscribing to ads.
Problem is: there is a huge difference between paying even one cent and not paying. If you ask for $0.01, you will probably get the same result as asking for $0.10 or even a dollar. And if the only thing you have to offer is a mildly interesting blog post, no one will give you a dollar, so, if you want that cent per view, putting an ad is the only option. Micro transactions turned out to be largely a failure.
Another option is to find an editor/platform that gives you a share of a larger subscription. But even then, most people don't want to pay. For example, the usual reaction when I mention YouTube Premium is "why would I pay for something free?". And it gives even more power to large platforms: YouTube can reasonably ask for $10/month given the amount of content, it is much harder for a small player.
So what is the solution? Braved tried something with BAT, but it is still an ad-based solution, and I don't really trust it. Carriers tried it with the equivalent of premium-rate phone numbers. Governments suggested tax-based solutions, none of them convincing.
I think western society struggles with banning things. But we've shown an aptitude for taxing vices. It's all about the money, right? Rather than banning, would taxing this economy achieve a compromised version of what you're seeking?
If the money isn't destroyed you will end up in smaller scale corruption. One example that comes to mind is HK zoning fees and the government's increasing dependency there of.
On some level, if the tax is there to "discourage" people, then the fact that they're willing to buy "smuggled" goods to save a bit of money shows you that they're not discouraged enough and they're not your target audience.
I don't think that's either possible or desirable. Attention seeking would simply take on sneakier forms that are indistinguishable from legitimate distribution of information and protected free speech.
Instead of somewhat independent ad funded publications, you would get publications that are owned by product companies (or political parties) themselves. The content they publish would be far more biased. Subscription based publications wouldn't stand a chance against those free and well funded company owned publications.
Advertising is very annoying, but I think it can be more transparent than almost any other form of influencing people.
Tracking for personalised advertising is an entirely separate issue. That's where I think a blanket ban could work.
Often progress is about eliminating one large negative externality, only to discover that there are others to handle too.
The 'submarine' type content you're referring to is somewhat addressed by trust networks, fact checking, link reputation, and various other techniques.
One large question is whether we're ready for all of the economically-motivated actors to start shifting into that space.
PS: You make a good point about transparency. It's nice that (at least the most honest) adverts are identified clearly as such.
Could we have similar transparency in content? ("I wrote this because I'd been thinking about it after reading an article by X about Y yesterday, and here is the source)
I believe it would happen on a far greater scale, because it would be the only way to get the message across and competition from independent ad funded publishers would cease to exist.
Today, it's more difficult for a product company to justify the expense of running their own large scale publishing and influencing operation because it would have to outcompete advertising in terms of effectiveness.
People will always try to get other people's attention for their own gain. Trying to stop this is a quixotic endavour. I think we should regulate to limit the negative impact of this social constant, not try to stop it altogether.
>Could we have similar transparency in content?
Yes, I do think we could. But I also think that people would still prefer high quality if biased company bloggers to paying for expensive subscriptions. Don't forget that most subscription based publications show adverts to their subscribers as well. Without advertising, subscription prices would rise steeply.
I'm not necessarily advocating either to stop it, or to limit the impacts - just to make it visible. Once the power/influence structures (and the associated leverage they use) are evident, the manipulative ones will be abandoned and the authentic ones will succeed.
I ended up reaching the conclusion that we should ban paying money for your attention, but I haven’t thought of better alternatives for businesses to grow or expand online yet.
USPS becomes vehicle for junk mail Telco becomes vehicle for robocalls Television a ratio of value to ads that gets smaller and smaller Internet becomes vehicle for ad revenue
All of these things are companies abusing communication platforms for your attention and we seemingly are never willing to pay more than advertisers are, maybe because by the time that decision happens folks move to the next platform.
The meta thing is that the Internet is a meta platform and we can keep making new communication methods, but we are still stuck with Google.