News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by burlesona on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:01AM (#26749997)
Honestly, people need to get over HyperCard.

Yes it was cool, but there’s no conspiracy behind its demise. It died because the World Wide Web accomplished basically the same thing, not initially as elegantly or powerfully, but open and universal (and today, very much more capable than HyperCard was).

HyperCard usage declined and Apple gave up on it. It’s not complicated.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by mumblemumble on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:53AM (#26750590)
I think that TFA said it well, if brusquely:

> And if you think that XCode, Python, Processing, or the shit soup of HTML/Javascript/CSS are any kind of substitute for HyperCard, then read this post again.

The thing that made HyperCard great was that it wasn't very capable. Which made it approachable.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by ajuc on Friday April 09, 2021 @03:37PM (#26755082)
> Which made it approachable.

And still WWW had orders of magnitude more users almost immediately.

Hypercard is only easier to learn than "regular" programming languages if you're English speaker.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by mumblemumble on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:17PM (#26756305)
I think that that point actually supports the gist of the argument.

In 1995, putting together a website was easier than using Hypercard. And so people flocked to it. Even people who were already somewhat familiar with Hypercard. Even though, at the time, Hypercard was largely more powerful. Some of that was because the Web made it so much easier to share. But I don't think that's the whole story.

Fast forward 25 years, and the Web has become much more powerful, but the number of people making websites recreationally who don't also get paid to write software seems to have dropped precipitously.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by mpweiher on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:20AM (#26750885)
Sure, Xcode today isn't a substitute. But Xcode is a large step back from what NeXTstep had, at least when it comes to this kind of capability.

The standalone Interface Builder had palettes, which you could fill with custom objects. There were third party palettes that allowed non-programmers to click together and configure custom applications for specific domains.

There were palettes that extended the whole shebang with scripting languages so that you could also add custom logic in Interface Builder.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by spacedcowboy on Friday April 09, 2021 @01:13PM (#26753167)
That's no different to Xcode. You just need to decorate properties for simple things, and maybe write a setup method or two if you want live-updates (eg to pull a weather map from a server)... Google @IBInspectable and @IBDesignable.

Unless you're saying that the most recent versions of Xcode don't do that, which would be news to me.

I agree that it's not well-used, but that's not the fault of Xcode. As far as I can tell it provides everything you'd need.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by mpweiher on Saturday April 10, 2021 @02:47AM (#26759491)
I am familiar with IBInspectable and IBDesignable, and have, for example, put my own Smalltalk and Postscript implementations in IB that way.

Not the same thing. At all. Not even close.

Palettes were final-packaged components that were at the same level as pre-built ones.

IBDesignable is a way for adding some interactivity to the views you are creating for an app while you're building said app. Like SwiftUI Previews. And it works about as well, that is not really at all.

With IBDesignable, Xcode was continually trying to build the entire dependency tree, meaning for example the entire Postscript interpreter. And failing >50% of the time, which then kills your view. I hear the same happens with SwiftUI previews once your project gets bigger. It certainly happened to me almost immediately when I was trying it out.

Again, they're not even close.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by debo_ on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:48AM (#26751227)
I hope that "extended the whole shebang with scripting languages..." was an intentional pun.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by Wistar on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:32AM (#26751817)
Although it was capable of Myst.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by nabla9 on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:21AM (#26750199)
> World Wide Web accomplished basically the same thing,

This is incorrect and I'm convinced that you agree after you think it little more. HyperCard was tool for non-programmers. Like spreadsheet. Web is not alternative to HyperCard. You have to learn web programming to do anything.

We should not get over it, but create replacement or recreate it.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by parasubvert on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:31AM (#26750317)
The Web was a gateway tech for a whole generation of “non programmers”, and for at least its first 10-15 years (through 2005 or so) you could build reasonable sites without being a programmer.

But as with all simple things in tech, there are more people whose pay depends on complexity. And so Web 2.0 rose and CSS+JavaScript became what it is today.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by throwanem on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:03AM (#26750720)
You still can build reasonable sites in the circa-2005 style - I'm actually helping one of my mentees work through doing just that, as a way to learn the basic concepts of web dev without having to fight through all the added abstraction that more modern tools involve.

(If anything, it's easier today to build a circa-2005 style site than it was in 2005! The native API has grown up enough that you don't need jQuery any more, and honestly good riddance.)

The trouble with the circa-2005 web is that it wasn't actually all that simple. You still had similar complexity to what people do today, but not very many ways to make that complexity manageable. So it was very easy to create situations in which things went wrong a lot and you couldn't really figure out why - something I think the rosy glow of nostalgia easily obscures, these days.

My early career, in hindsight, really was built on dealing with that kind of "unfixable" complexity, finding ways to reduce or replace it or at least make it more manageable - if often just in self-defense, as I typically was also largely responsible for maintaining the same stuff I built. The "capstone project" of that phase was something that we would today describe as an SPA, built in 2011 when the concept barely existed - I hadn't set out to (re)invent that wheel, nor did I even understand until a few years later that that was what I had done, but I found my way to it as the only reasonable option for coping with the essential complexity of the user interaction it expressed, and it worked really well!

That work was for one of our biggest contracts, which we were at risk of losing if I didn't find a way to fix their broken and unusable registration process. It would probably have sunk the company if I'd failed. Reworking it into an SPA avant la lettre solved the problem and saved the contract, and it was some of the hardest work I've ever done precisely because, at that time, there were no tools to help manage all that complexity. It's only gotten easier since then, as successive frameworks have built on prior work in removing accidental complexity and making essential complexity easier to express and manage.

Yes, today's tools are themselves more complicated than jQuery or whatever, sure. That's fair. You need to spend more time learning how to get the most out of them, that's also true. But the tools also do more, and largely do it in ways that are worth having.

A Bridgeport mill takes a lot more learning than a chisel, too, and you can do a lot more damage with a Bridgeport mill used wrongly. Used rightly, though, you can achieve far more with a Bridgeport mill, far more quickly and easily, than any chisel in the history of the world could ever let you do.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by parasubvert on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:31AM (#26751026)
I agree, though I think the same can be said for HyperCard. Extending it was complicated.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by burlesona on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:53AM (#26752159)
I learned how to build web pages by hand writing HTML and copy pasting it into Geocities when I was 9. It wasn’t real programming then and it isn’t now.

Don’t mistake the explosion of JavaScript land for being the same thing as the World Wide Web. Static websites are as easy to build now as they were in 1995, and in some ways easier.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by TetOn on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:32AM (#26750326)
> You have to learn web programming to do anything.

Sorry, but I don't see how that is at all different than "you have to learn the Hypercard scripting language to do anything."

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by throwanem on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:39AM (#26750411)
You could learn enough HyperTalk to do useful things inside a day - I know; I did exactly that, when I was 11 or 12 and had a chance to find out on a Mac at the museum where an uncle of mine then worked. Granted I already had experience with Apple BASIC, so wasn't a complete programming novice, but I'd never worked in a graphical environment before, and yet still managed to turn out a fairly presentable, if short, "choose your own adventure" style game with some complex world state in just a few hours.

It would be utterly risible to suggest that a child of similar age and prior experience could do the same today, starting from scratch with web technologies. Yes, you can do more with the modern web. But the initial complexity barrier is very much higher.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by parasubvert on Friday April 09, 2021 @09:50AM (#26750550)
Not that risable: my 11 year old has gone through the Python Crash Course book and built a basic Django pizza ordering website with a database in a day.

That’s after work his way through much of the book, of course, but... as with any complex domain, the right teacher can make a big difference.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by throwanem on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:07AM (#26750760)
I think that goes to both your point and mine; sure, the website does a little more in that it can be accessed from computers other than the one where it's running, but he also needed a whole book to do not much more than scratch the surface of what we call "web programming".

That's not to say it isn't a significant accomplishment, and he should be proud of it!

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by parasubvert on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:28AM (#26750986)
I don’t know that it is only scratching the surface - the book gets you into an interactive site that is styled with Bootstrap, uses a database, uses web APIs, pushes to Heroku so it’s HA and scalable, etc.

It’s pretty much all the major elements of web programming but using the more elegant ways of simplifying the experience.

I’m not denying the complexity just saying that there are still many (particularly in Python or in cloud PaaSes) who value streamlining the experience.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by throwanem on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:38AM (#26751926)
I'd still call it scratching the surface in that I doubt it goes into details on how any of those things actually work, and that's an important consideration because it's the basis for knowing how to deal with any of them going wrong. No doubt you'd have been able to provide support in that case, but it still goes to the point of there being a much larger potential depth of complexity here.

I get the sense the book tries to surf the reader over the top of most of that ocean, and that's reasonable enough, but the ocean is still there. I wouldn't consider it all that comparable to Hypercard, which in this metaphor I guess is more like the town pool back when those still existed? People who are ready for the deep end can dive into it, and people who feel like paddling around in the shallow end is more their speed can safely do that too.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by mimixco on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:17AM (#26751589)
I think the key part is "in a few hours." No one, even professional devs, can do this "in a few hours" today.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by throwanem on Friday April 09, 2021 @08:22PM (#26757782)
I mean, I can, if you spot me Node/Express or even TS/React as the stack to use. Those are at the core of my professional discipline, and I know what's going on well enough with them that standing up a new project, complete with compilers, linters, style formatters, style linters, and so on, doesn't take me much.

But that's building on close to twenty years of working in the field, and a bit over three decades since I first put my hands on an Apple IIe's keyboard and wrote

    10 PRINT "HELLO"
    20 GOTO 10
Which is the key part, really - I wasn't far past 10 PRINT "HELLO" when I happened upon Hypercard, and I was still able to use it effectively with no more background than that. I don't know that there's anything comparable today.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by disqard on Saturday April 10, 2021 @11:49AM (#26762345)
I think you might enjoy checking out BlockStudio (disclaimer, I created it):

https://www.blockstud.io

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by parasubvert on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:49PM (#26758762)
Depending on the toolchain, they absolutely can. Tech is more complex but there are still pathways to extreme productivity.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by jasonwatkinspdx on Friday April 09, 2021 @11:15AM (#26751569)
Yes, todays web is far more complex. But the early web from the time when HyperCard failed was totally different. At that age I absolutely learned enough to make my own home page. For many years that's simply all the web was: home pages, webrings, etc.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by nabla9 on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:15AM (#26750839)
Hypercard scripting was intended for non-programmers. Normal people can do wonders with simple tools after little learning. Just like people using spreadsheets. Hypercard made programming available for non-programmers.
Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by yoz-y on Friday April 09, 2021 @10:17AM (#26750859)
> We should not get over it, but create replacement or recreate it.

I feel that enough people complain about it not existing and then quickly proceed to not recreating it. If there was market for this, it would exist.

I've never used Hyper Card, but I guess that for prototyping of 'real software', programs like InVision work. Most of the trivial programs you could create with HyperCard (from the examples shown) can be recreated in other software (like excel or soulver) or already exist.

Re:Why Hypercard had to die (2011) by seumars on Friday April 09, 2021 @01:01PM (#26753001)
>not initially as elegantly or powerfully

i wouldn't call the web elegent or powerful today either