Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by astrange on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:06AM
(#26708925)
There was a recent issue where Chinese citizens pointed out that IMEs with telemetry enabled could capture what you type into Signal and it didn't warn you or try to mitigate this; the Signal guy ignored them, then dodged them for weeks and told everyone they were harassing him, then a white guy pointed out the same thing and his suggestions were immediately taken up.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by saagarjha on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @07:07AM
(#26710441)
If I remember correctly the claim was from a Chinese citizen who pointed this out and when Signal didn't treat this as a major security issue (which I felt was understandable given that her concern was mostly along the lines of "you can't say that Signal is secure given that people install other software on their phone that could be a keylogger so you should have a disclaimer") she decided to continue to escalate on social media until she was, IMO, harassing Moxie for his "lack of engagement". I didn't come away particularly impressed by that exchange.
Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by codethief on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @10:37AM
(#26712301)
Exactly, this had nothing to do with one person being Chinese and the other being white.
Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by yorwba on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @03:49AM
(#26709202)
And what was the suggestion? The flow of information is (You typing → IME converts key presses into text → Signal receives text) so Signal can't do anything to prevent a malicious IME from sending the text elsewhere. The best they could do is raise users' awareness that Signal won't protect them if there's spyware with privileged access on their device, and that their IME might be such spyware.
Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by astrange on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @04:00AM
(#26709276)
Mainly the OS has security options to prevent IME network connections that aren't always on by default, but users can enable them. (They might be off because it disables some features that need internet access.)
IIRC there was also some Android API that could be used in the app to help, but I don't remember what it actually did atm.
Re:Leaked phone number of Mark Zuckerberg reveals he is on S...
by alias_neo on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @05:51AM
(#26709984)
Perhaps your man the incognito keyboard option? Signal uses it, but no API I can imagine will protect against a malicious IME.
Worse still, even if you block IME internet access on a device with a factory-maliciois IME, they could just upload the data using some other service on the device.
Installing a known-good IME seems like the only fix I can think of?