Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf]
by DannyBee on Monday April 05, 2021 @07:01PM
(#26705763)
It was zero courts before, too, no?
CAFC does not have natural jurisdiction over copyright and thus always applies circuit law.
Here, this was also a 3-judge panel of the federal circuit, and en banc review was denied.
Those decisions are already not binding on future 3-judge panels IIRC (it's been a while, honestly), and definitely not binding on the circuits
Re:Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf]
by dragonwriter on Monday April 05, 2021 @07:06PM
(#26705808)
> It was zero courts before, too, no?
Right, and I think this played an important role in why the Supreme Court ducked API copyrightability; they’d rather not do so absent a binding lower circuit decision, or especially a conflict between circuits, preferring to let the issue percolate (and also provide Congress more time to intervene) of there is another basis dor resolving particular cases with less sweeping impact.
No, it doesn’t. Because the Court expressly declined to examine the question, the CAFC decision is binding only where it would have been without the Supreme Court decision, i.e., those courts bound by the CAFC’s interpration of how Ninth Circuit law applies. As it turns out, that is exactly zero courts.
The reason the Supreme Court often likes to find the narrowest grounds possible for a decision is to avoid making more binding case law than is called for; giving the lower court rulings on all questions not addressed (including those the Supreme Court explicitly avoids) the same binding effect as the actual Supreme Court holding would defeat the purpose, and it is very much not how things work.